Should you file a claim if you weren't at fault?

Editorial team Published on

Yes, you should report the accident to your own insurance company even if you were not at fault, but you can choose whether to file a repair claim with your insurer or the other driver’s insurer.

📊 Filing Options Compared

FeatureFiling with Your Insurer (First-Party)Filing with At-Fault Insurer (Third-Party)
Speed🚀 Faster repairs and processing⏳ Slower (requires fault verification)
Deductible💳 Pay upfront, refunded later via subrogation✅ No upfront deductible
Legalities🛡️ Protected by your own policy contract⚠️ Must negotiate with external adjuster

🚗 Step-by-Step Action Plan

  • Report the Incident: Notify your insurer immediately to protect your coverage rights.
  • Gather Evidence: Collect photos, police reports, and witness contacts at the scene.
  • Choose Claim Route: Decide between paying your deductible for speed or waiting on the other party.
  • Avoid Recorded Statements: Decline recorded statements to the other driver's insurer without guidance.
  • Monitor Subrogation: Track your insurer's recovery process to get your deductible refunded.

What not to say when filing an insurance claim?

Never admit fault, apologize, or downplay your injuries when speaking to an insurance company after an accident.

Every word you share with an adjuster can be used to minimize or deny your payout. Protect your claim by avoiding these common statements and actions.

Statements to Avoid

  • "I'm sorry" or "It was my fault": An apology acts as an admission of liability and can be used to reduce your compensation under comparative fault laws.
  • "I'm fine" or "I'm not hurt": Adrenaline can mask serious injuries like whiplash. Saying you are fine early on makes it difficult to claim medical costs later.
  • Guessing or speculating: Avoid guessing vehicle speeds, distances, or the timing of lights. If you do not know an answer, say "I don't know" rather than guessing.
  • "I think" or "Maybe": Using uncertain language damages your credibility when facts are later scrutinized.
  • Agreeing to a recorded statement: You are rarely required to give an immediate recorded statement to the other driver's insurer. Adjusters use these to trap you in inconsistencies.

Actions and Disclosures to Avoid

  • Oversharing medical history: Do not grant broad access to your past medical records, which insurers use to blame pre-existing conditions for your current pain.
  • Accepting quick settlement offers: Early offers are usually lowball amounts before full medical treatments or property damage costs are known.
  • Posting on social media: Insurers monitor your digital footprint. Photos, activity updates, or rants about the crash can contradict your injury claims.

Safe Communication Tips

  • Stick strictly to the basic facts: date, time, location, and basic vehicle info.
  • Report the incident promptly, but defer detailed or speculative discussions.
  • Consider letting legal counsel handle further conversations with the adjuster.

Can insurance penalize you for accidents that are not your fault?

Yes, an insurance company can sometimes raise your rates or penalize you for an accident that is not your fault.

Why Your Rates Can Increase

  • Filing a Claim: If you file a claim through your own insurance policy (such as for uninsured motorists, collision coverage, or personal injury protection), your insurer pays out money. This payout makes you statistically riskier in their eyes, even if you did nothing wrong.
  • State Laws: Regulations vary by location. Some states explicitly ban companies from raising rates after a not-at-fault crash, while other states allow it.
  • No-Fault States: In true no-fault states, your own insurer handles your medical bills regardless of who caused the crash, which can still trigger a rate adjustment depending on the company.
  • Claim History: Multiple past claims—even if none were your fault—signal a higher overall frequency of losses to an insurance provider.

How to Protect Yourself

  • File with the At-Fault Driver: When possible, file a third-party claim directly with the other driver's liability insurance rather than your own to help avoid premium spikes.
  • Shop Around: Insurance rules vary widely by provider. For instance, as discussed on Reddit, opinions and experiences differ, and companies like State Farm may handle not-at-fault claims differently than competitors like Progressive. If your rates go up, you can compare insurance quotes with other companies.
  • Check State Rules: Look up your specific state's department of insurance guidelines to see if rate increases for not-at-fault accidents are permitted.

Does your insurance go up after a claim that is not your fault?

Yes, your car insurance rates can still go up after a claim that is not your fault, depending on your state and insurance company.

Why Rates Can Increase

  • Risk assessment: Insurers look at any claim as a sign that you might be a higher risk for future claims, even if you did not cause the crash.
  • Payout involvement: If your own insurance company has to pay out money for your repairs or medical bills (and then try to get it back from the other driver later), your rates may go up.
  • Loss of discounts: Filing a claim can cause you to lose a "claims-free" or "accident-free" discount, which makes your overall price go up.

State Laws and Rules

  • State protections: Some states do not allow companies to raise your rates if an accident is not your fault. For example, California and Oklahoma have laws that protect drivers from rate hikes in these situations.
  • Company policies: Different insurance companies have different rules. Some companies, like State Farm, choose not to raise rates for drivers who are not at fault, while others might raise them by a small percentage.

What scares insurance adjusters?

Insurance adjusters are most afraid of claimants who are organized, informed, and represented by legal counsel. Rather than emotional outbursts or intimidation, adjusters fear concrete evidence and professional accountability.

What Disconcerts Adjusters

  • Detailed Documentation: Keeping complete medical records, repair bills, photos, and a daily pain journal makes it impossible for an adjuster to downplay your losses.
  • Legal Representation: Hiring a personal injury attorney signals that you will not fall for lowball settlement offers or delay tactics.
  • Strict Fact-Based Communication: Sticking strictly to basic facts and refusing to guess or provide speculative recorded statements strips away their ability to trap you in contradictions.
  • Bad Faith Accountability: Knowing your policy details and threatening regulatory complaints or bad faith lawsuits when they delay or deny valid claims without cause.

What Happens If You Are Not At Fault for An Car Accident?

9 related questions found

What's the biggest mistake people often make when dealing with an insurance claim?

The biggest mistake people often make when dealing with an insurance claim is giving too much information too soon—such as providing a recorded statement or casually saying "I'm fine" to an adjuster. Insurance adjusters often call quickly to get statements that they can use to lower or deny your payout.

Other Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Admitting Fault Prematurely: Saying "I'm sorry" or guessing about what happened at the scene can be twisted into an admission of liability before all facts are known.
  • Accepting the First Offer: The initial settlement check is usually a low-ball offer meant to close the case cheaply before you realize the true cost of repairs or medical bills.
  • Delaying Medical Care or Filing: Waiting too days to see a doctor or report the incident gives insurers an opening to argue your injuries or damages didn't happen during the event.
  • Poor Documentation: Failing to take photos, keep receipts, or track medical visits makes it hard to prove the real value of your claim.
  • Posting on Social Media: Sharing photos or details online gives the insurance company evidence to claim you are less injured or damaged than you state.

What not to tell your insurance company?

Never admit fault, apologize, or downplay your injuries when speaking to an insurance adjuster after an accident.

Statements to Avoid

  • "I'm sorry" or "It was my fault": Insurers treat apologies as a legal admission of liability, which can reduce or eliminate your compensation.
  • "I'm fine" or "I'm not hurt": Adrenaline can mask severe conditions like internal bleeding or traumatic brain injuries that appear days later. Early statements that you are fine are used to deny later claims.
  • Guesses or speculation: Never estimate speeds, distances, or timing. Stick strictly to objective facts you know for certain.
  • Recorded statements: You can decline requests for a recorded interview until you consult legal counsel, as adjusters use these recordings to trap you in inconsistencies.

Safe Communication Guidelines

  • Provide only basic facts like the date, time, location, and your contact or policy details.
  • Refer the adjuster to a qualified Car Accident Lawyer to manage further discussions and protect your rights.

How much will my insurance go up after a non-fault accident?

Your car insurance may increase by an average of about 10% to 16% after a non-fault (not-at-fault) accident, though many drivers see no increase at all.

Why Rates Change After a Non-Fault Accident

  • Statistical risk: Insurance companies use data showing that drivers involved in any crash—even if they did not cause it—are statistically more likely to file future claims.
  • State laws: Some states (such as California and Oklahoma) legally prohibit insurance companies from raising your rates for an accident you did not cause.
  • State insurance systems: In no-fault states (like Michigan or Florida), your own insurance often pays for your medical bills or damages first, which makes a rate bump more common.
  • Company policies: Specific insurers treat non-fault claims differently. For example, some companies raise rates slightly for any claim, while others (like State Farm) do not penalize not-at-fault drivers.
  • Multiple claims: Having multiple non-fault claims or recent tickets within a 3-to-5-year window raises your overall risk profile.

How to Handle a Rate Increase

  • Shop around: Compare quotes from different auto insurers at renewal time to find a better rate.
  • Check state rules: Review your local department of insurance regulations to see if rate hikes for non-fault crashes are restricted where you live.
  • Ask about discounts: Bundle policies or apply safe-driving and low-mileage discounts to offset any adjustment.

How long do minor accidents affect insurance?

Minor car accidents typically affect your insurance rates and stay on your record for three to five years.

Impact Duration

  • Timeframe: Most rate surcharges last for 36 to 60 months.
  • Fading Effect: Surcharges often decrease gradually as the incident date gets older.
  • State Rules: Local laws change how long records count. For example, California DMV records clear minor incidents after 3 years, while Insurify notes New York tracks them for the current year plus three years.

Key Factors

  • Fault: You usually see a rate hike only if you are found at fault.
  • Cost: Very small claims might not raise rates if they fall below state minimum thresholds.
  • History: A clean record before the event helps your rates return to normal faster.

What happens after a car accident that is not your fault?

After a car accident that is not your fault, you must document the scene, notify insurers, and decide whether to file through your own or the other driver's policy.

🚨 Immediate Scene Actions

  • Call 911 for police and medical help.
  • Photograph vehicle damage, road signs, and skid marks.
  • Collect driver names, phone numbers, and insurance details.
  • Get contact information from any available witnesses.
  • Obtain the official police report number from the officer.

🗓️ Insurance Claim Options

OptionProsCons
At-Fault InsurerNo upfront deductible owedSlower verification and liability checks
Your Own InsurerFaster repairs and communicationPay deductible upfront (reimbursed later via subrogation)

💡 Managing Medical Care and Expenses

  • See a doctor immediately, as adrenaline masks hidden injuries.
  • Save all medical bills, receipts, and repair estimates.
  • Keep a written log of missed workdays and lost wages.
  • Decline quick, lowball cash settlement offers from adjusters.