Am I liable if my car is stolen?

Asked by: Georgette Volkman  |  Last update: June 28, 2025
Score: 4.3/5 (24 votes)

Many people think that if their car is stolen, they are automatically responsible for any accidents that occur. This is not usually the case. Car owners are typically not held liable for accidents caused by thieves.

Do you still have to pay for a car that is stolen?

Easy answer. You still owe the money. Your theft insurance should cover most of the replacement cost. All loans require collision and theft insurance for the vehicle that you DO NOT own but are paying for.

Does insurance pay you if your car is stolen?

Stolen vehicles are protected by comprehensive coverage

If someone steals your vehicle and it's not recovered, your insurer will cut you a check for your car's current value if you have comprehensive coverage. This may be true even if the car was stolen with the keys in it.

What happens when someone steals your vehicle?

If the individual that stole your vehicle has been located, they can pursue criminal charges against them for the vehicle theft. As part of the criminal case they could also be ordered to pay restitution which would include repaying you for the impound fees and any other damages to your vehicle.

Does your insurance go up after your car is stolen?

Claiming a stolen vehicle becomes a part of your insurance claim history. While comprehensive claims are generally not viewed as negatively as at-fault accidents, multiple claims, including theft claims, can still affect your premiums. Location Matters: The area where your car was stolen may influence your rates.

How insurance works when your car is stolen: 2 Wants to Know

33 related questions found

What happens if your car gets stolen and you don't have full coverage?

Unfortunately, if your car is stolen and you don't have insurance coverage, you may be responsible for the full cost of replacing your vehicle. When a car is stolen, the owner typically files a police report and notifies their insurance company.

How long does insurance wait for a stolen car?

To give you a short and sweet answer: Insurance companies typically wait 30 days before issuing a payout for a stolen vehicle, in case it is recovered by police before then. However, if you've experienced a vehicle theft, there's a few more things you should know.

Who is responsible if your car is stolen?

Explanation of Liability

When your car is stolen, the thief usually takes on the liability for any accidents they cause. However, certain situations might complicate this general rule, making it essential to know the specifics.

Can I sue someone if they stole my car?

If you have to buy a new vehicle or make repairs to your stolen vehicle upon its return, you can sue for compensation for those damages. You might also sue for damages if you had to take time away from work or pay for a rental vehicle while your car was missing.

How long does it usually take to recover a stolen car?

If you report your car as stolen immediately to police, there's a better chance it will be recovered. In fact, according to NICB data, 35% of recovered stolen vehicles are recovered on the same day as the theft, and 45% are recovered within two days.

What happens if your car gets stolen from a dealership?

The dealer's insurance should cover this loss. While the car is in their possession they must take care to prevent damage or theft. So, Monday morning make a claim to their insurance and if they do not offer a reasonable settlement then you will have to sue them.

What happens if your car gets stolen and you have full coverage state farm?

If you have collision or comprehensive coverage, your auto insurance policy may cover a totaled or stolen car. In the case of a covered loss, you will typically be paid the actual cash value of your car minus your deductible.

How does GAP insurance work if your car is stolen?

So, if you took out a loan or leased a car, and the car is totaled or stolen before you can pay off the loan, GAP insurance will cover the difference between what you owe on the loan and the car's resale value.

Do you get reimbursed if your car is stolen?

Yes, insurance will cover a stolen car if you carry comprehensive coverage on your policy. If the car is a total loss, which means it is either not found or it is found damaged to the point where it would cost more to repair than to replace, insurance will pay the actual cash value of the vehicle.

Do police do anything about stolen cars?

Once the police receive the report, they will investigate and check for any leads or surveillance footage that could help identify the thief. They may also notify surrounding law enforcement agencies and other organizations specializing in stolen vehicle recovery, such as the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB).

How do I track my car if it's stolen?

How to Find a Stolen Car: 10 Effective Ways
  1. File a “Car Stolen” Report to the Police. ...
  2. Track Stolen Car with VIN Number. ...
  3. Use GPS Device to Track Your Stolen Car. ...
  4. Check Security Camera Footage to Find Your Stolen Car. ...
  5. Contact Your Insurance Company. ...
  6. Inform Your Leasing Company If Your Rented Car Is Stolen.

What happens if your car gets stolen and you have full coverage?

Downey drivers whose cars are stolen in Califonia will have car theft insurance if they have comprehensive coverage. That should cover you up to the Actual Cash Value (ACV) of your vehicle. If your car is damaged due to a break-in, you'll also be covered.

Can someone sue me and take my car?

If you've been sued for a debt and you're worried about whether the judgment creditor can take your car, here's the short answer: It's possible, but very rare. Creditors usually only pursue a car if it has significant value and isn't already tied to a loan.

What happens when someone steals your car?

After you've filed a report with the police, the next call you need to make is to your insurance company. They will guide you through the process of filing a claim. Be prepared to provide them with information such as your policy number, the police report number and any other relevant details they may require.

What do thieves do after stealing a car?

Chopping up cars and selling the parts

Many criminals send stolen cars to chop shops, which provide lucrative opportunities for car thieves. Once a car is stolen, chop shop operators strip them for parts and sell them to other people who need parts for crashed cars.

What happens if my financed car is stolen?

Unless you take out GAP insurance when financing a car, you will have to continue making monthly payments when the vehicle is stolen. However, you will be free to sign a new agreement once you have paid off the remaining balance on your auto loan.

Can you sue someone who steals your car?

If your insurance does not fully compensate you for this issue, then you can sue the person who stole the car from you. You can sue for up to $12k in small claims court in your state. If you need to sue for more, you would sue in state court, which is a similar procedure, just a different court.

Should I call my insurance if my car was stolen?

If you have a tracking device on your vehicle, this could help you recover it, but after contacting the police, you'll want to call your car insurance company next.

How long does it take police to find a stolen car?

Generally, if a stolen car is not found within 30 days of being reported, it's unlikely to be found at all. Thieves will often change license plates illegally before selling the car on, making it impossible to trace.

Does insurance investigate a stolen car?

Insurance companies investigate stolen property claims with scrutiny and skepticism. Insureds must jump through many hoops to prove they played no role in the theft or loss of their own property.