Can you negotiate gap insurance at a dealership?


Editorial team Published on

Yes, you can negotiate gap insurance at a dealership, and you should always push back on their initial price. Dealerships often start with a price as high as $900 to $2,000, but the actual fair market value is usually between $350 and $550.

πŸ’‘ Negotiation Strategies

  • Focus on cash price: Negotiate the total flat cost, not your monthly payment.
  • Use outside quotes: Tell the finance manager your personal auto insurer or credit union offers it for $200 or less.
  • Set a firm cap: Offer a fair flat rate, such as $400, and be ready to walk away.

πŸ“Š Cost Comparison

ProviderAverage CostPayment Type
Dealership$400 - $900+Rolled into loan (adds interest)
Credit Union$200 - $400Rolled into loan
Auto Insurance$20 - $60 per yearAdded to monthly policy