Can you sue your insurance company for more than the policy limits?

Asked by: Gabriella Welch  |  Last update: February 11, 2022
Score: 4.5/5 (61 votes)

Unfortunately, you cannot make an insurance company pay beyond its policy limit. You do, however, have the right to sue the at-fault driver for more than the value of his or her insurance policy. ... In most cases, your lawyer will pursue compensation for you through negotiations with the insurance company.

What happens if damages exceed policy limits?

Suing the Insurance Company

If it is determined that your damages are worth more than the policy limits, yet the insurer refuses to pay the limit, you may have legal grounds to file a bad faith insurance lawsuit.

Can I recover compensation above the insurance policy limits?

California law entitles car accident victims to seek damages for their injuries against at-fault parties. ... Can you recover more than the insurance policy limits after a car accident? The short answer is yes, you can.

What happens if claim exceeds coverage?

When a car accident claim happens to exceed the insurance limits usually one of three things result: (1) the claim will result in a settlement with a personal contribution over the policy limits by the at-fault driver; (2) a jury will return an “over limits” verdict against a collectible defendant; or (3) a bad faith ...

How often do auto accident settlements exceed the policy limits?

Although auto accident settlements do not often exceed the policy limits, suing beyond policy limits is possible. However, you will likely have to look to other sources to obtain more compensation. Here are a few ways to collect extra damages if your claim exceeds your policy limits.

How a Lawyer Can Get You More Than the Insurance Policy Limit

37 related questions found

What happens when car accident claim exceeds insurance limits California?

If your claim exceeds policy limits, you may seek to ultimately sue the driver at fault for additional damages not covered by the policy limits. Whether you should take this approach rather than settling for the policy limits will depend on whether the at-fault driver has assets from which you could collect a judgment.

Can someone sue you after insurance pays?

Many people involved in car accidents feel a sense of relief when the insurance settlement is paid out, as they perceive this to mean there is no possibility of further litigation. Though this is typically true, it is still possible for someone to sue you even after insurance pays.

What is the maximum limit on how much an insurance company will cover?

A limit is the highest amount your insurer will pay for a claim that your insurance policy covers. Think of it this way: It's like filling up a fishbowl. If you file a covered claim, your insurance policy will pay up to a certain amount. You're responsible for any expenses that exceed the limit.

How do policy limits affect settlement?

An insurance company may also be subject to a bad faith claim when they fail to settle a settlement for damage that goes beyond the policy limits. Once the case proceeds to trial, the jury may award an amount that exceeds the policy limit, which may place the company on the hook to settle the whole amount.

Do insurance companies have to disclose policy limits?

11. Disclosure mandatory. An insurer must disclose the coverage and limits of an insurance policy within 30 days after the information is requested in writing by a claimant.

Is pain and suffering included in policy limits?

The two most common types of auto insurance coverage are bodily injury (BI) and uninsured/underinsured (UM) motorist coverage. Both BI and UM can be used to cover pain and suffering, but only up to the amount of the policy limits.

Why do lawyers take so long to settle a case?

Once a case gets filed in court, things can really slow down. Common reasons why a case will take longer than one would hope can include: Trouble getting the defendant or respondent served. The case cannot proceed until the defendant on the case has been formally served with the court papers.

Can you sue the other person's insurance company?

A lawsuit filed in relation to your crash will generally be filed against the at-fault party. In other words, you do not sue the other driver's insurance company. ... The reason that you typically cannot sue the other driver's insurance company directly is that the insurer has no legal obligation to you.

What is a typical personal injury settlement?

The median payout for a personal injury lawsuit is approximately $52,900. For most victims with moderate injuries, like broken bones, sprains, and whiplash, the payout ranges from $3,000 to $10,000. However, extreme injury and mental suffering has helped some victims earn millions.

How often do insurance companies settle?

Plaintiffs and defendants (and their insurers and lawyers) settle over 90% of cases to avoid unexpected results and control their risks. In most cases, especially when liability and damages are pretty clear cut, there is no need to roll the dice and pay for an expensive trial.

What is a demand for policy limits?

A 'policy limit demand' in a personal injury case requests the insurance company to pay the full policy limits or risk their insured's financial stability.

Why do attorneys ask for policy limits?

A demand for policy limits information often occurs shortly after an accident or "occurrence" in which someone suffers harm, blames another, and seeks compensation. Usually, an attorney or public adjuster contacts the insurance company asking for policy limits.

How do I increase my personal injury settlement?

How To Maximize Your Settlement
  1. Seek medical treatment immediately.
  2. Collect and preserve all evidence.
  3. File your personal injury claim as soon as possible.
  4. Aim for the full value of your claim.
  5. Do not accept the first offer without review.
  6. Include past, current, and future damages.

How do you find out someone's policy limits?

How Can You Learn the Other Driver's Policy Limits When the Insurance Company Won't Tell You?
  1. Ask the driver. The police report will have the contact information for the negligent driver. ...
  2. Send a demand letter. ...
  3. Get help from your insurance company. ...
  4. Sue the negligent driver.

What are the 3 limits in a typical auto insurance policy?

Auto liability coverage limits are typically written out as three numbers like 25/50/25. That means you have a $25,000 limit per person for Bodily Injury in an accident, a $50,000 total limit per accident for Bodily Injury, and a $25,000 limit per accident for Property Damage.

What is excess limit in insurance?

An excess limits premium is the amount paid for coverage beyond the basic liability limits in an insurance contract. If there's a possibility that losses incurred will exceed the amount of basic coverage, the insured may use an excess coverage rider, which only triggers during incidents of high damage.

What is cover multiple in insurance?

A multiline insurance contract is a type of insurance policy that bundles different exposures to risk and covers them under a single contract. These policies provide additional income for the providers, while simultaneously offering increased convenience and premium discounts to policyholders.

Is reversing driver always at fault?

Reversing a vehicle and the law

In an insurance liability setting, the driver who is driving in reverse is automatically deemed to be the at fault driver, regardless of other circumstances (ie: other vehicle illegally parked, forward moving driver moving at speed, etc).

Do I pay excess if I damage another car?

Do I have to pay an excess? Most policies require that you pay an excess unless the cost of the excess can be recouped from the other driver who caused the accident. So basically if it wasn't your fault and you got the driver who was at fault's details.

What happens when someone sues you after an accident?

If you are getting sued for a car accident, it means that the other driver believes you are at fault for the accident. ... Regardless of what happens, if you are found to be responsible for the accident, you will need to compensate the victim for any damages they may have sustained.