Do I pay excess if someone hits me?
You generally do not have to pay an excess (or deductible) if someone else hits you and is proven to be entirely at fault, though you may be asked to pay it upfront in certain situations.
When You Might Not Pay
- Full Liability Accepted: If the other driver's insurance admits full fault, you typically pay nothing.
- Details Provided: Most insurers waive the excess upfront if you provide the full name, contact details, address, and license plate number of the at-fault driver.
- Third-Party Claim Only: If you do not make a claim on your own policy and instead have the other person's insurance pay out directly, you do not pay an excess.
When You Might Have to Pay Upfront
- Upfront Payment: Some insurance policies require you to pay the excess initially when you lodge a claim, which is later refunded once your insurer recovers the costs from the at-fault driver's insurance.
- Missing Details: If it is a hit-and-run, or you cannot identify or track down the other driver, you will usually have to pay your excess.
- Shared Fault: If fault is split (for example, you are deemed even 10% responsible), the excess will usually apply.
- Uninsured Driver: If the other driver has no insurance, your insurer may still repair your car under your own policy, but you might have to cover the excess while they attempt legal recovery.
Do I have to pay my excess if someone hits me?
You may have to pay your car insurance excess upfront, even if another driver hits you.
How It Works When You Are Not at Fault
- Initial payment: Many insurers require you to pay your policy excess when you first file a claim to get your car repaired.
- Getting your money back: If your insurance company proves the other driver caused the crash and recovers the full cost from their insurer, your excess should be refunded to you.
- Waived excess: Some insurers might waive the excess immediately if the other driver's insurance admits liability right away, but this depends on your specific policy.
- Bypassing your insurer: If you claim directly through the at-fault driver's insurance company instead of your own policy, you generally do not pay an excess at all.
Do I pay excess if I'm not at fault?
You generally do not pay an excess if you are not at fault, provided you can identify the other driver and your insurer confirms they can recover the costs.
When You Don't Pay an Excess
- Details are provided: You have the other driver's full name, address, phone number, and vehicle registration.
- Clear liability: Your insurance company agrees the other driver is 100% at fault and accepts liability tracking.
When You Might Have to Pay Initially
- Missing details: The other driver drove off (a hit-and-run) or refused to give their information.
- Uninsured driver: The person who hit you does not have car insurance.
- Unresolved fault: It is unclear who caused the crash, so your insurer asks for the fee upfront while they investigate. If they later prove you were not at fault, they usually refund this money.
How much does insurance increase if you hit someone?
On average, your car insurance premium will increase by 30% to 50% after an at-fault accident. According to major automotive and insurance data studies, this percentage translates to an average annual premium hike of $740 to over $1,000.
Your exact rate increase is calculated at your next policy renewal and depends on several critical factors:
Key Factors Determining the Increase
- Severity of the Crash: A minor parking lot fender-bender will result in a much smaller rate hike than an accident involving bodily injuries or severe vehicle damage.
- Your Driving History: If you have a clean record, your insurer may be more lenient. However, if you already have tickets or prior claims, you will be flagged as high-risk, resulting in a much steeper penalty. You may also instantly lose your "good driver" discount, driving the price up further.
- State Regulations: Insurance laws vary heavily by location. For example, in California, an at-fault accident can spike your rates by over 70%, whereas states like Arizona average closer to 40% to 60%.
- Your Insurance Provider: Every company assesses risk differently. Providers like State Farm, USA National, and AAA historically offer some of the lowest post-accident rate options.
How Long Does the Hike Last?
An at-fault accident will typically impact your car insurance rates for 3 to 5 years. The surcharge is usually highest during the first year and will gradually decrease each year you maintain a clean driving record. After 5 years, most insurance companies stop factoring the accident into your premium entirely.
Exceptions and Mitigation
- Accident Forgiveness: If you purchased or earned an "accident forgiveness" benefit through providers like Progressive or GEICO before the collision, your rate may not increase at all for your first minor accident.
- Out-of-Pocket Option: If the damage to the other person's vehicle is exceptionally minor (e.g., less than $500–$1,000), paying for the repairs out of pocket without involving insurance can sometimes save you thousands of dollars in long-term premium surcharges.
Do I need to pay excess if I wasn't at fault?
You generally do not need to pay an insurance excess if you are not at fault, provided you can supply your insurer with the at-fault driver's full name, address, and vehicle registration number.
When You Don't Have to Pay
- Full details provided: You give your insurer the correct contact and vehicle information for the other driver so they can recover costs directly.
- Liability confirmed: Your insurer is confident the other driver is 100% at fault and accepts your claim under those terms.
- Waived excess policy: Your AAMI Comprehensive Car Insurance or similar policy explicitly waives the excess for clear not-at-fault incidents.
When You Might Have to Pay (Initially or at All)
- Missing details: If the other driver is a hit-and-run or refuses to provide their registration and contact info, you will likely have to pay the excess upfront. (It may be refunded later if they are identified).
- Uninsured driver: If the other driver is uninsured and cannot pay, your insurer might ask you to cover the excess while they pursue legal recovery.
- Shared fault: If your insurer decides you share even a small percentage of the blame, the excess will apply.
- Upfront payment: Some insurers require you to pay the excess when lodging the claim, which they later refund once they successfully recover costs from the at-fault party.
Check your specific Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) or log in to your provider portal (such as RACV or Suncorp) to confirm how your specific policy handles not-at-fault claims.
Breaking Down Car Insurance Excess in 90 Seconds with @InvestWithQueenie
Can I refuse to pay excess?
You cannot legally refuse to pay an insurance excess, as it is a binding part of your policy contract agreed to when you purchased coverage.
Why You Must Pay
- Contractual agreement: Your insurance policy sets out the combined compulsory and voluntary excess amounts you owe per claim.
- Upfront requirement: Most insurers require you to pay this fee before repairs begin or deduct it directly from your final settlement payout.
- Refusal consequences: If you refuse to pay, your insurer can halt your claim, refuse to authorize vehicle repairs, or cancel your policy for breach of terms.
Exceptions and Refunds
- Non-fault accidents: If another driver is completely at fault, your insurer may try to recover the excess from the liable party's insurance.
- Reimbursement: Once the other insurer accepts liability and pays out, your provider should refund your paid excess. However, you usually still have to pay it initially.
- Uninsured driver promises: Some comprehensive policies waive or refund the excess if you provide the exact details of an uninsured driver who hit you.
How does insurance work if it's not your fault?
When an accident is not your fault, you can file a claim with the other driver’s insurance company or your own.
Filing Options
- Third-party claim: File directly with the at-fault driver's insurance. Their liability coverage pays for your car repairs and medical bills without an upfront deductible. However, the process can take longer while they investigate and verify fault.
- First-party claim: File with your own insurance company using your collision or medical coverage. This is usually faster, but you must pay your deductible upfront. Your insurer will later try to get your money back from the other driver's company through a process called subrogation.
How Medical Bills Work
- Fault states: The at-fault driver's bodily injury liability insurance pays for your medical costs and lost wages.
- No-fault states: Your own Personal Injury Protection (PIP) covers your medical bills and lost income regardless of who caused the crash. You may still sue the other driver if your injuries are severe.
Steps to Take
- Get a police report: Official reports help prove the other driver was at fault.
- Save evidence: Take photos of vehicle damage, road signs, and the scene.
- Notify your insurer: Most policies require you to report any accident promptly, even if you did not cause it.
You can review a detailed breakdown of options and steps from State Farm.
What not to tell your insurance company?
Never admit fault, apologize, or downplay your injuries when speaking to an insurance adjuster after an accident.
Statements to Avoid
- "I'm sorry" or "It was my fault": Insurers treat apologies as a legal admission of liability, which can reduce or eliminate your compensation.
- "I'm fine" or "I'm not hurt": Adrenaline can mask severe conditions like internal bleeding or traumatic brain injuries that appear days later. Early statements that you are fine are used to deny later claims.
- Guesses or speculation: Never estimate speeds, distances, or timing. Stick strictly to objective facts you know for certain.
- Recorded statements: You can decline requests for a recorded interview until you consult legal counsel, as adjusters use these recordings to trap you in inconsistencies.
Safe Communication Guidelines
- Provide only basic facts like the date, time, location, and your contact or policy details.
- Refer the adjuster to a qualified Car Accident Lawyer to manage further discussions and protect your rights.
Is it better to pay excess on insurance?
Choosing a higher voluntary excess (the amount you agree to pay toward a claim on top of your mandatory compulsory excess) lowers your regular insurance premium, but it means you pay more out-of-pocket if an accident happens.
How Excess Works
- Compulsory excess: A fixed, mandatory amount set by your insurer based on factors like your age and experience.
- Voluntary excess: An optional amount you choose to add on top to show you accept more risk.
- Total excess: The sum of both compulsory and voluntary amounts, which you must pay (or have deducted from your payout) during a claim.
When a Higher Excess is Better
- You are a safe driver: If you rarely or never make claims, you save money on your yearly bill without ever paying the higher excess.
- Lower premiums: Opting for a higher excess reduces your upfront policy costs, which can be helpful if your quotes are very high.
- You have emergency savings: If you have cash set aside to cover the total excess immediately if an accident occurs.
When a Higher Excess is a Bad Idea
- You cannot afford the cash payout: If a crash happens and you do not have enough money to pay the total excess, your insurer will not release the repair funds or process your claim.
- Small claims: If the damage cost is lower than your total excess, you cannot claim anything at all.
- Diminishing returns: Raising your voluntary excess past a certain point (like £250 or £500) stops lowering your monthly price significantly.
For more comparisons on finding the right balance, check the guide at GoCompare or read the insights on Total Loss GAP.
Do I file a claim with my insurance if someone hit me?
You can file a claim with either your own insurance company or the at-fault driver's insurance company.
Filing with Your Own Insurance (First-Party Claim)
- Fast repairs: Your car can get fixed faster using your collision coverage.
- Deductible required: You must pay your deductible upfront, though your insurer may try to get it back from the other driver later.
- Contract rule: Most policies require you to report any accident anyway, even if you are not at fault.
- You can learn more or start a process through a provider like State Farm or Progressive.
Filing with the Other Driver's Insurance (Third-Party Claim)
- No deductible: You generally do not pay an upfront deductible.
- Slower process: The other company must investigate and verify fault with their driver before paying, which takes more time.