Do over-the-counter orthotics work?

Asked by: Milan Walsh  |  Last update: September 28, 2023
Score: 4.1/5 (30 votes)

Over the counter orthotics definitely provide one important thing: instant pain relief. Placing a gel massage insert into your shoes will cushion the foot immediately, letting you feel a difference right away. Custom-made orthotics, however, takes some more time to be effective.

Do OTC orthotics work?

Despite the wide array of choices, OTC orthotics primarily add extra cushioning inside your shoe. While they can provide relief from foot pain, they won't correct existing problems in your feet or ankles.

Are OTC insoles worth it?

Custom Insoles Offer Highest Foot Support

While OTC insoles are inexpensive, they are not as durable as custom insoles and will require routine replacement. The best insoles for flat feet and other foot problems are fully customised and highly durable which last for years with minimal wear and tear.

Do over the counter arch supports work?

Shoe inserts or arch supports can't always change the center of path pressure in the right direction. It is not evidence-based to prescribe higher cushioning heels or pronation control shoes solely based on the arch type. Accommodative orthotics were proven to be ineffective in preventing lower-limb injuries.

How long do OTC orthotics last?

Custom Orthotics Are Built to Last

But compared to the cheap, flimsy insoles you can buy over the counter—which may only last a couple of months—almost all custom orthotics will serve you well for at least a year, and typically more like 3-5 on average.

Custom Orthotics vs Over-the-Counter Insoles

31 related questions found

What are signs you need orthotics?

7 Signs You Need Orthotics
  • You have foot pain or swelling. ...
  • You have sharp heel pain. ...
  • You have a flat foot or high arch. ...
  • You're having problems with balance or are falling over. ...
  • Your shoes are wearing unevenly. ...
  • You've had a lower limb injury. ...
  • You have diabetic foot complications.

How many hours a day should you wear orthotics?

Wear your ICON ORTHOTICS a total of 2 - 4 hours today, and increase the time you wear them by 1 – 2 hours a day. It usually takes one to two weeks to become completely used to wearing your orthotics but this time can differ from person to person. Most people can wear the orthotics full time in 3-5 days.

Are custom orthotics better than over the counter?

In the end, the difference is simple: custom made orthotics will help your ailments in the long run while over the counter options are used more to provide relief to certain symptoms.

What is the difference between arch supports and orthotics?

One significant difference is that orthotics are custom-made to address your foot's biomechanical faults or provide advanced arch support. A basic arch support insert is often easy to find at your local drugstore at inexpensive costs.

Do podiatrists recommend arch support?

Flex Orthotic Insoles

"If you have a flatter arch type foot, increased arch support can help to reduce the likelihood of plants fasciitis and offer pain relief," Sutera says, adding, "Sometimes, however, custom-made orthotics may be necessary, which can be made by your podiatrist."

How much can I expect to pay for orthotics?

There are many types of custom orthotics, and they can cost anywhere from $300 to $800. Semi-custom orthotics cost between $60 and $300, and basic off-the-shelf inserts are available for as little as $10 to $20. Some health insurance plans won't pay for custom-made orthotics.

Do podiatrists recommend insoles?

Podiatrists use orthotics to treat foot problems such as plantar fasciitis, bursitis, tendinitis, diabetic foot ulcers, and foot, ankle, and heel pain. Clinical research studies have shown that podiatrist-prescribed foot orthotics decrease foot pain and improve function.

Why are foot orthotics so expensive?

Unlike over-the-counter insoles, which are generic and can be easily purchased by walking into a store, different types of custom orthotics are specially designed to fit a particular foot and address specific foot conditions. Because of this, they tend to be more expensive compared to over-the-counter orthotics.

Should I wear orthotics all the time?

For example, if you are planning to use your orthotics primarily for sports or a specific activity, it may be most beneficial to wear them for shorter periods. In contrast, if you've been diagnosed with an issue like flat feet that affects you all the time, it may be recommended to wear them all the time.

Are off the shelf orthotics good?

Off the shelf orthotics can provide temporary relief but they won't provide the long term benefits and support needed if your feet have biomechanical problems, or if you have an underlying medical condition that needs attention.

Do custom orthotics really work?

Custom foot orthoses or orthopedic footwear or modifications may be helpful for specific medical situations, but it's probably only truly reliable for a single condition: painful pes cavus (high arches).

What are the two types of orthotics?

Wearing orthotics may help to restore ankle function, in addition to correcting foot deformities, such as flat feet. Many patients who have bunions, hammertoes, arthritis, or diabetes may benefit from wearing orthotics as part of their treatment plan. There are two types of orthotics, rigid and accommodative.

What is an OTC orthotics?

Over-the-counter orthotics are generic — meaning they fit any type of shoe or foot bed. You can get them in stores, and they can provide some comfort and cushioning for your feet. You don't need to get a prescription for these inserts, but they're not customized to your feet.

Why do my feet still hurt with custom orthotics?

If you are still feeling pain or discomfort after 2-3 weeks, visit your podiatrist to adjust your orthotics. If you have generic store-bought variations, perhaps consider visiting a podiatrist for a complete gait analysis and some custom-made orthotics. Take proper care of your orthotics.

What to look for when buying orthotics?

Look for an orthotic that is inflexible with good arch support. Push down on the arch. If it collapses under finger pressure, it is not rigid enough. Note that this type of orthotic may feel strange when first worn because of its rigidity and shape.

Should I wear orthotics in the house?

Custom 3-arch orthotics restore healthy foot function to decrease pain and fatigue, support the entire body correctly and lessen their risk for injury. But for that to occur, they need to be worn continuously, indoors and out. Like a pair of prescription eyeglasses, the correction is gone when they're not being worn.

Should I wear my orthotics around the house?

It is more important to wear your insoles when your feet will be working hard, standing for long periods, or exercising. It is less important to wear them when you are sitting for an extended time, like at your desk or in front of the TV.

Do orthotics correct your feet?

But they're not custom-made for your feet. They can provide arch support or extra cushioning on the heel, around the toes, or for your entire foot. Inserts might make your shoes more comfortable but aren't designed to correct foot problems.