Is Cigna HealthSpring a good plan?

Editorial team Published on

HealthSpring (formerly Cigna) Medicare plans hold an overall rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars from NerdWallet for its Medicare Advantage plans.

Plan Ratings Breakdown

  • Medicare Advantage (CMS Quality): Averaged 3.76 to 3.68 out of 5 stars from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), which is slightly below the industry average. However, roughly 67% of members are enrolled in plans rated 4 stars or higher.
  • Medicare Part D (Prescription Drug): Earned 3.5 out of 5 stars from NerdWallet, with an average CMS star rating of 2.5 stars.
  • Medicare Supplement (Medigap): Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars by NerdWallet.
  • U.S. News & World Report: Scored 3.5 out of 5 stars for its Medicare Advantage options.
  • Financial Strength: Backed by an A (Excellent) or higher financial strength rating from AM Best.

Pros and Cons

  • Pros: High availability of $0-premium monthly plans (about 77% of its Advantage plans) and lower-than-average out-of-pocket maximum caps.
  • Cons: Government CMS quality ratings sit below industry averages, and departing members sometimes report network coverage issues with local doctors and hospitals.

Is HealthSpring different from Cigna?

HealthSpring is the new brand name for what used to be Cigna's Medicare business, which was sold and is now operated by Health Care Service Corporation.

The Relationship Between HealthSpring and Cigna

  • The Sale: In March 2025, Health Care Service Corporation (HCSC) bought Cigna’s Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, Medicare Part D, and CareAllies businesses.
  • The Rebrand: Starting in 2026, those former Cigna Medicare plans officially operate under the independent HealthSpring name.
  • Cigna Today: Cigna Healthcare still exists and operates its commercial, individual, and employer-sponsored health insurance lines separately; it just no longer owns or manages the Medicare products.

What This Means for Members

  • Plan Continuity: Benefits and provider networks for existing plans transitioned over during the rebrand.
  • Branding Changes: Members see the HealthSpring name and logo instead of Cigna on plan materials, websites, and new ID cards.

Is Cigna health insurance good or bad?

Cigna health insurance has mixed reviews, offering strong customer service and digital tools, but facing criticism for high costs and automated claim denials.

The Good (Pros)

  • Customer Service: High satisfaction ratings place Cigna near the top for member support compared to major competitors.
  • Digital Experience: Strong mobile and online tools make it easy to manage accounts and find in-network care.
  • Low Deductibles: Some plans feature relatively low deductibles, reducing upfront out-of-pocket costs before coverage starts.

The Bad (Cons)

  • Affordability: Premiums can be higher than average compared to competitors like Humana or Kaiser Permanente.
  • Claim Denials: Users and legal actions note that Cigna heavily uses automated algorithms for pre-authorizations and claim processing, which can lead to frequent errors or rejections that require appealing.
  • Network Limits: Depending on your region, finding local doctors who accept specific Cigna plans can sometimes be harder than with larger networks like Blue Cross Blue Shield.

Opinions on Quora are mixed, as satisfaction often depends heavily on your specific location, employer plan design, and local doctor network.

Is HealthSpring better than United Healthcare?

Neither HealthSpring (formerly Cigna) is universally better than UnitedHealthcare; choice depends on whether you prefer lower costs or a larger network.

Cost and Availability

  • HealthSpring excels at low-cost options, offering a higher percentage of $0-premium plans and lower average monthly costs. However, it is only available in about 29 states and the District of Columbia.
  • UnitedHealthcare is available in nearly every state and features lower maximum out-of-pocket limits on average, though it tends to have higher premiums or higher initial costs for certain supplemental plans.

Network and Ratings

  • UnitedHealthcare stands out for its massive provider network of over 1.3 million physicians and generally scores higher on customer satisfaction and prevention measures in national ratings.
  • HealthSpring offers strong extra benefits like dental and over-the-counter allowances, but ranks lower in overall customer satisfaction in some national surveys.

Why are doctors dropping Cigna insurance?

Doctors and medical groups are dropping or considering dropping Cigna Healthcare primarily due to its controversial automatic downcoding policy for office visits and ongoing reimbursement and contract disputes.

Automatic Downcoding Policy

  • Lower Payments: Cigna implemented a policy that automatically "downcodes" higher-level Evaluation and Management (E/M) office visits (such as levels 4 and 5) to lower levels without reviewing the actual medical records.
  • Administrative Burden: Instead of getting paid appropriately by default, physicians are forced to file tedious, time-consuming written appeals with full documentation to reverse the downcoding, taking time away from patient care.
  • Regulatory Pushback: Medical associations and state regulators—such as the Maryland Insurance Administration—have pushed back or ordered halts on these types of automated underpayment practices, citing legality and fairness concerns.

Contract and Reimbursement Disputes

  • Profit Pressures: Major for-profit insurers face pressure to improve margins, leading to aggressive utilization of automated claims adjustments, strict prior authorizations, and low reimbursement rates.
  • Network Terminations: Health systems and independent physician groups frequently clash with Cigna during annual contract renewals over fair compensation, resulting in some regional networks dropping Cigna coverage entirely.

Welcome to HealthSpring Medicare | Your Key Benefits and How to Use Them

9 related questions found

Is HealthSpring a good insurance?

HealthSpring (formerly part of Cigna's Medicare business and now owned by HCSC) offers affordable Medicare Advantage and supplement plans, but satisfaction varies depending on costs, ratings, and local networks.

You can review official plan options directly on the HealthSpring official site.

Pros of HealthSpring Insurance

  • Low Costs: It is a top-rated choice for low-cost plan availability, with roughly 80% of its Medicare Advantage plans featuring $0 monthly premiums.
  • Extra Benefits: Most plans bundle Medicare Parts A, B, and D with extra perks like routine dental, vision, hearing, fitness programs (Silver&Fit), and over-the-counter allowances.
  • Medigap Popularity: Their standardized Medicare Supplement (like Plan G) options are widely used and praised for competitive pricing through agencies.

Cons of HealthSpring Insurance

  • Lower Quality Ratings: Government CMS star ratings and overall enrollment-weighted averages tend to run below average.
  • Network Complaints: Some disenrolling members report frustrations regarding doctor and hospital network restrictions or coverage limits.
  • Brand-Name Drug Limits: Competitors sometimes offer broader or more flexible coverage for specific brand-name prescription drugs without copays.

Which pharmacies are preferred for HealthSpring?

HealthSpring's preferred home delivery pharmacy is Express Scripts Pharmacy, and its preferred retail network includes major regional and national chains.

Preferred Home Delivery & Specialty

  • Home Delivery: Express Scripts Pharmacy provides $0 or reduced copays on many generic medications with free shipping.
  • Specialty Pharmacy: Accredo Specialty Pharmacy is the preferred provider for specialty medications.

Preferred Retail and Grocery Chains

Preferred network status varies by your specific plan and location, but common preferred retail pharmacies include:

  • Walgreens
  • Wal-Mart / Sam's Club
  • Publix
  • Giant Eagle and Giant Pharmacy
  • H-E-B Pharmacy
  • Safeway and Albertson's Pharmacy
  • Wegmans
  • Hy-Vee Pharmacy

Note: A complete up-to-date list of local options can be found directly through the HealthSpring Pharmacy Networks resource page.

Why is Cigna falling?

Cigna Group shares have faced downward pressure following its late-September Investor Day and broader concerns regarding execution risk and sector valuations.

Key Reasons for the Pullback

  • Investor Day Expectations: During its September 30 Investor Day, management introduced the "Lead to One" long-term growth strategy and a $3 billion multi-year AI-driven modernization program. However, the company merely reaffirmed rather than raised its 2026 guidance, leaving investors who hoped for a near-term earnings catalyst disappointed.
  • Long-Term Execution Risks: The newly outlined 2026–2030 targets—including a 10%–14% adjusted EPS compound annual growth rate—highlighted heavy capital deployment into tech and modernization, raising short-term execution and delivery timeline concerns.
  • Medical Cost Pressures: Elevated utilization trends and medical care ratio pressures across the broader managed-care sector have kept sentiment cautious despite solid underlying quarterly performance.
  • Regulatory and Political Scrutiny: Heightened attention and legislative scrutiny regarding pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) and vertical integration have also weighed on the wider healthcare sector.

Where does Cigna rank in health insurance?

Cigna ranks No. 10 on the Insure.com list of the Best Health Insurance Companies for 2026 with an overall score of 3.96 out of 5.

Company Size and Market Standing

  • National Size: Cigna ranks in fourth place by members and revenue among health insurance companies in the United States.
  • Market Share: It holds roughly 2.50% of the U.S. health insurance market.
  • Customer Base: The provider serves about 16 million health insurance customers in the U.S. and roughly 95 million people worldwide.

Strengths and Ratings

  • Digital Experience: Cigna performs well for online tools and digital accounts, earning a No. 2 spot in recent digital experience surveys and recognition from J.D. Power.
  • Customer Service: Policyholders give Cigna strong marks for customer service and claims handling, placing it near the top of industry satisfaction surveys.
  • International and Employer Plans: Cigna is widely recognized as a top choice for international health coverage and employer-sponsored group health benefits.

Weaknesses and Limitations

  • Market Footprint: Cigna's Affordable Care Act (ACA) marketplace plans are only available in a selective number of states compared to massive nationwide footprints like Blue Cross Blue Shield.
  • Overall Value: While digital tools and customer service score high, its pricing, deductibles, and policy variety land it in the middle of the pack compared to regional leaders like Kaiser Permanente.

What was the Cigna insurance scandal?

The Cigna insurance scandal primarily refers to a major 2023 class-action lawsuit accusing the company of using an automated computer algorithm called PxDx to automatically deny hundreds of thousands of patient claims in seconds without a fair, individual medical review.

The PxDx Algorithm Lawsuit

  • The Accusation: A class-action lawsuit filed in federal court alleged that Cigna used the PxDx (procedure-to-diagnosis) algorithm to cross-reference denied claims.
  • How It Worked: Instead of having medical professionals conduct a thorough review, the system reportedly spent an average of just 1.2 seconds per claim to flag mismatches and reject large batches. Doctors then allegedly rubber-stamped these batches of denials without opening or reading the patient files.
  • The Legal Aftermath: Plaintiffs argued this practice violated California law and breach of fiduciary duties, and federal judges have allowed the core class-action claims against Cigna to move forward.

Other Major Legal and Financial Controversies

Cigna also faced other significant federal penalties and legal troubles around the same time:

  • False Claims Act Settlement: In late 2023, Cigna agreed to pay $172 million to resolve allegations that it submitted untruthful, inflated diagnosis codes for Medicare Advantage plan enrollees to fraudulently increase federal payouts.
  • Data Privacy Concerns: Cigna faced legal battles over allegations that it used hidden third-party tracking pixels on its patient portal website to intercept and misuse sensitive personal health queries.