Is Highmark good insurance?

Editorial team Published on

Highmark insurance is a solid regional carrier with an excellent provider network, though customer service and billing complaints are common.

You can learn more about their offerings directly on the Highmark Official Site.

Pros of Highmark Insurance

  • Provider Network: Highmark consistently scores near the top for provider network strength, giving you wide access to doctors, specialists, and hospitals.
  • Customer Satisfaction: Industry surveys place Highmark in the upper tier for overall member satisfaction and loyalty.
  • Medicare Advantage: Their Medicare Advantage plans receive above-average star ratings in core regions like Pennsylvania, Delaware, and West Virginia.

Cons of Highmark Insurance

  • Geographic Limits: Coverage is primarily focused on Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia, and parts of New York and Ohio.
  • Administrative and Billing Issues: Many policyholders report frustration with claim denials, unexpected medical bills, and slow customer service responses, reflected in low consumer review scores on platforms like ConsumerAffairs.
  • High Deductibles: Routine care can carry steep out-of-pocket costs before comprehensive coverage begins.

Is Highmark the best health insurance?

Highmark is not universally the "best" health insurance, but it ranks as a top-tier regional choice, particularly known for its strong provider network and high Medicare Advantage quality ratings.

Whether it is the best fit depends entirely on your location and healthcare needs.

Pros of Highmark

  • Strong Provider Network: Highmark consistently scores near the top for provider access, making it easy to find in-network doctors and specialists.
  • High Medicare Ratings: Its Medicare Advantage plans average well above the industry standard in government quality ratings from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS).
  • Blue Cross Affiliation: As part of the Blue Cross Blue Shield family, members get national and international coverage for urgent or emergency care through the BlueCard program.

Cons of Highmark

  • Geographic Limits: Highmark operates primarily as an independent licensee in Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia, and parts of New York. It does not offer full nationwide ACA (Affordable Care Act) coverage.
  • Midrange Pricing: While competitive, its premiums and out-of-pocket costs generally fall in the middle of industry rankings rather than being the absolute cheapest.
  • Customer Service Inconsistencies: While general satisfaction is high, some policyholders report frustrations regarding claim processing and billing transparency.

Is Highmark the same as Blue Shield?

Highmark is not the same thing as Blue Shield nationwide, but Highmark is a specific regional licensee of the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association.

How They Relate

  • Blue Cross Blue Shield Association (BCBSA): This is a national federation of 36 independent, locally operated health insurance companies that cover one-third of all Americans. "Blue Shield" (and Blue Cross) are brand names and service marks owned by this association.
  • Highmark Inc.: This is one of those independent regional companies. It operates as a licensee of the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association, providing health plans in states like Pennsylvania, Delaware, New York, and West Virginia.
  • The Name: Because Highmark holds the license to use the "Blue" brand in its specific regions, it often names its regional entities Highmark Blue Shield or Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield.

Key Differences

  • Not National: "Blue Shield" can refer to completely different independent companies in other states (such as Blue Shield of California, which has no corporate connection to Highmark).
  • Independent Operations: Highmark manages its own network of doctors, pricing, and specific plan designs independently from other Blue Shield or Blue Cross plans across the country. You can learn more about their regional structure directly on the Highmark About Us page.

What is the best health insurance there is?

Kaiser Permanente is named the best overall health insurance company for 2026 due to high customer satisfaction scores and affordable individual plans.

Top Health Insurance Companies of 2026

  • Kaiser Permanente: Best overall and best for individual plans. It offers low average premiums and high marks in customer satisfaction, though it is only available in select states.
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield: Best for families and PPO network variety. It operates across all 50 states and Washington, D.C.
  • UnitedHealthcare: Best for customer service complaints and large provider networks.
  • Molina: Best for low complaint ratings and budget-friendly pricing.

Key Factors to Consider

  • Network Type: Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) plans require you to see doctors within a specific network. Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) plans allow out-of-network visits at a higher cost.
  • Costs: Look at the monthly premium (what you pay to stay enrolled) alongside the deductible (what you pay before insurance kicks in) and maximum out-of-pocket limits.
  • Prescriptions: Check the plan's drug list, called a formulary, to ensure your medications are covered.

Which is better, UnitedHealthcare or Highmark?

Neither UnitedHealthcare nor Highmark is universally "better," as choice depends entirely on your location, needed doctors, and whether you prioritize nationwide availability or regional customer satisfaction.

UnitedHealthcare Overview

  • Coverage: Operates nationwide across all 50 states and serves nearly 50 million people.
  • Strengths: Best-in-class large provider network (close to 1 million providers) and robust digital tools.
  • Weaknesses: Ranked lower for overall customer satisfaction and experience in recent national and regional industry surveys.

Highmark Overview

  • Coverage: Operates as a regional Blue Cross Blue Shield insurer serving Pennsylvania, Delaware, and West Virginia.
  • Strengths: Higher customer service rankings, strong member satisfaction, and broad specialist acceptance within its core service footprint.
  • Weaknesses: Limited geographic availability compared to national carriers.

Highmark Health Insurance Review - Usage Experience

9 related questions found

What's better, Aetna or Highmark?

Whether Highmark is better than Aetna depends heavily on your location and what type of plan you need, as Highmark is a regional insurer and Aetna operates nationally.

Coverage and Availability

  • Aetna: Operates as a massive national insurer available in over 40 states. It is owned by CVS Health, giving members convenient access to CVS-related wellness perks and pharmacy benefits.
  • Highmark: Operates primarily as a regional, non-profit Blue Cross Blue Shield affiliate serving Pennsylvania, Delaware, and West Virginia. Outside of its home region, members rely on the broader Blue Cross Blue Shield network.

Cost and Plans

  • Aetna: Frequently offers a higher percentage of $0 monthly premium plans for Medicare Advantage (around 60% to 70% depending on the specific market analysis).
  • Highmark: Tends to have fewer $0 premium Medicare Advantage options in certain areas, but provides competitive pricing backed by the uniform Blue Cross network.

Customer Satisfaction and Ratings

  • Highmark: Often scores very well in localized customer satisfaction metrics, frequently earning high marks from members who prefer a regional, non-profit approach.
  • Aetna: Generally scores higher for government quality ratings (such as CMS star ratings for Medicare) due to its consistent national standardization, though individual customer service experiences can be more mixed.

What are the top 5 health insurances?

The top 5 largest health insurance companies in the United States by market share and enrollment are UnitedHealth Group, Elevance Health (formerly Anthem), [Centene Corporation, Humana], and [CVS Health (Aetna)].

Largest Health Insurers by Size and Market Share

  • UnitedHealth Group (UnitedHealthcare): The largest health insurer in the United States, serving tens of millions of members with a massive nationwide network of doctors and healthcare delivery through its Optum arm.
  • Elevance Health: Operates Blue Cross Blue Shield plans in multiple states and serves millions of members with extensive commercial and individual plan offerings.
  • Centene Corporation: Focuses heavily on government-sponsored healthcare programs, including Medicaid, Medicare, and the ACA Marketplace (Ambetter).
  • Humana: A major national player well-known for its large footprint in Medicare Advantage plans and strong customer service ratings.
  • CVS Health (Aetna): Combines traditional health coverage with retail clinic access through CVS Pharmacy and MinuteClinic locations.

Top-Rated Insurers by Customer Satisfaction

If you measure the "top" companies by customer satisfaction and quality ratings rather than sheer size, consumer guides like Insure.com and Forbes Advisor rank providers differently:

  • Kaiser Permanente: Consistently ranked highest for overall customer satisfaction, preventive care, and affordability, though it operates as an integrated HMO system in specific regions.
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS): Praised broadly for having some of the best nationwide provider networks via its independent regional licensees.
  • Aetna / Humana: Frequently score well for low complaint ratios and accessible consumer perks.

Is Highmark an HMO or PPO?

Highmark offers both HMO (Health Maintenance Organization) and PPO (Preferred Provider Organization) plans depending on your location and the specific policy you choose.

Highmark Plan Types

  • PPO Plans: These plans give you more freedom to see out-of-network doctors or visit specialists without a referral, though usually at a higher cost. Examples include Highmark's Freedom Blue PPO and Complete Blue PPO.
  • HMO Plans: These require you to use a specific network of doctors and get referrals for specialists to keep your costs lower. An example is Community Blue HMO.
  • HMO-POS Plans: Some markets also offer an HMO Point-of-Service option, which lets you go out-of-network for certain services under specific conditions.

You can review specific choices on the Highmark Health Insurance Plans page.

Is Blue Shield better than UnitedHealthcare?

Neither Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) nor UnitedHealthcare (UHC) is universally "better"; the right choice depends on your specific location, plan type (ACA, group, or Medicare), and which local doctors or hospital networks you need to access.

Network and Availability

  • Blue Cross Blue Shield: Operates as a network of independent regional companies covering all 50 states, serving over 100 million members. It is often praised for offering robust PPO networks and strong local provider access.
  • UnitedHealthcare: The nation's largest single health insurer by enrollment and revenue, serving nearly 50 million members with a massive nationwide provider network approaching 1 million providers.

Cost and Coverage

  • Medicare Advantage: According to NerdWallet, UnitedHealthcare generally offers a higher percentage of zero-premium plans and lower average non-zero premiums, but can feature higher maximum out-of-pocket (MOOP) limits compared to BCBS.
  • Customer Satisfaction: BCBS often scores slightly higher on overall customer satisfaction and experience metrics, whereas UHC scores below average in several major consumer surveys, though UHC frequently earns praise for its advanced mobile app tools.
  • Market Differences: Opinions are mixed. For example, users on Facebook report a split experience, with some satisfied with UHC coverage and others complaining about claim denials, while regional availability heavily dictates pricing.

What is the best health insurance in PA?

The best health insurance in Pennsylvania depends entirely on your specific region and which local hospital networks your doctors belong to.

Top Regional Health Insurance Providers

  • Philadelphia & Southeastern PA: Independence Blue Cross is the top choice because of its large network contracts with major systems like Penn Medicine, Jefferson Health, and Main Line Health. AmeriHealth and Oscar Health also offer strong, competitive alternatives in this area.
  • Pittsburgh & Western PA: Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield and UPMC Health Plan divide the region. Highmark connects to the Allegheny Health Network, while UPMC connects to its own hospital system. You must check if your specific doctors accept the network before choosing.
  • Central & Northeastern PA: Geisinger Health Plan is the leading choice for care tied to Geisinger facilities, while Capital Blue Cross serves a broad footprint across Central PA and the Lehigh Valley.

How to Shop and Compare Plans

You can shop and compare all available private health plans through Pennie, Pennsylvania's official health insurance marketplace. Shopping through Pennie is also the only way to qualify for federal financial assistance and tax credits that lower your monthly premium.