Is it better to pay out of pocket or claim car insurance?

Asked by: Elisha Howell II  |  Last update: March 3, 2025
Score: 4.1/5 (49 votes)

According to LendingTree auto insurance expert and licensed insurance agent Rob Bhatt, paying for minor repairs and saving insurance for the big stuff is generally best, especially if you cause the damage. “A claim for an at-fault accident almost always increases your rates,” he says.

Does insurance go up if you pay out of pocket?

Will my car insurance go up if I pay for accident damage out of pocket? Even if you choose not to file a claim and pay for accident damage out of pocket, your insurance rates could still go up following an accident.

What is the downside of filing an insurance claim?

It could increase your premiums

When determining your premiums, insurance companies consider your likelihood of filing a future claim — which could cost them money. The higher your perceived risk, the more likely you are to pay more in premiums. Your claims history tends to play a direct role.

Should I file an insurance claim if I am not at-fault?

Always File a Claim, Regardless of Who Was At-Fault

One of the primary questions we receive from clients who have been in an accident is whether they should report the accident to their own auto insurance carrier, particularly when the accident was not their fault. And the answer to that question is: always.

Is it worth going through insurance for minor damage?

For vehicle damage: Yes. If your vehicle received minor damage, it might be worth filing a collision claim with your insurance if the damage costs more than your deductible. If the other driver caused the accident, then you could file a claim with their insurance company instead.

Should You Pay a Claim Out of Pocket vs Filing an Insurance Claim?

28 related questions found

Should I file an auto claim or pay out of pocket?

If you're not sure whether the damage is worth covering yourself, get a quick repair estimate. There's no point filing a claim for repairs that cost less than your collision coverage deductible — the amount you pay out of pocket toward a repair.

When should you not file a claim?

If the claim amount equals or is less than the deductible, there's not much sense in filing a claim. “Most car insurance policies have a deductible in place which you have to pay before their coverage kicks in,” says Ross. “If your damages are minor, you're much better off just paying out of pocket.”

Is it illegal to pay out of pocket for a car accident?

Strictly speaking, paying out of your pocket for a car accident isn't illegal, but accepting the offer may have unwanted consequences.

Will my insurance go up if I file a claim and its not my fault?

Some may raise your premiums by 10 percent, while others may charge you only 2 percent more. In addition, certain states, such as California and Oklahoma, don't allow insurance companies to increase rates after a non-fault claim.

When someone hits you, do you call your insurance or theirs?

You should call both, regardless of who you think is at fault. If it turns out the other driver is at fault, their insurance will pay, but it's helpful to have your insurance company involved.

What should you not say when making an insurance claim?

Eight things NOT to say to an insurance adjuster are:
  1. admitting fault,
  2. anything about your injuries,
  3. anything on the record,
  4. speculating about the crash,
  5. that you do not have a lawyer,
  6. providing unnecessary information,
  7. accepting a settlement, and.
  8. sharing medical records.

Will my insurance drop me if I file a claim?

Yes, your car insurance company can drop you if you file too many claims.

Should I file an insurance claim for bumper damage?

It may not make sense to file a claim if the bumper damage is minor and the repair cost is lower than your auto insurance deductible. If you have a low deductible, it may be worthwhile to file a claim, even for minor repairs.

Will my car insurance increase if I make a claim?

In most cases, the cost of your insurance will go up if you file a claim.

Is it illegal to pay out-of-pocket if you have insurance?

Many states have removed the penalty for those seeking medical services without insurance plans. This means that it is not illegal to not use your health insurance for medical services. Medicare patients may have different requirements.

Is it better to have a $500 deductible or $1000?

Remember that filing small claims may affect how much you have to pay for insurance later. Switching from a $500 deductible to a $1,000 deductible can save as much as 20 percent on the cost of your insurance premium payments.

Will my insurance go up if I get hit by an uninsured driver?

However, under California's proposition 103, insurance companies are not allowed to raise rates or drop a person because they made an uninsured motorist claim.

How can I lower my car insurance after an accident?

How to find cheap car insurance after an accident
  1. Raising your deductible, which is the amount reduced from a potential claim check from comprehensive or collision insurance. ...
  2. Adding discounts to your policy. ...
  3. Improving your credit.

Does your insurance go up if someone hits you?

Rate increases will go up even more if there are injuries and property damage. If you are not at fault, however, the rate increase is less severe. On average, drivers who are not at fault will only have their rates go up by about 4%.

Is it better to pay out of pocket or insurance?

Firstly, if the cost of repairs or services falls below your insurance deductible, opting out of pocket may prove more cost-effective. Additionally, choosing to pay out of pocket can help prevent potential increases in insurance premiums, especially if filing a claim would only marginally exceed your deductible.

When not to go through car insurance?

If the repair cost is lower than your insurance policy's deductible, it's probably not worth filing a claim. For instance, say your deductible is $1,000, but the cost of damage is $800. In that case, filing a claim wouldn't make much sense as your out-of-pocket cost is higher than the amount your insurer will cover.

Can I report an accident without filing a claim?

You are not required to file an insurance claim after an accident, but you may need to file a police report. Not filing a claim can be risky, especially if there are any physical injuries involved that may result in a lawsuit.

Is it better to file a claim with your insurance or theirs?

After a car accident, you should notify your insurance company and file a claim, and not deal with the other driver's insurer. Except in rare circumstances, it is not wise to contact them.

What should you not say in a claim?

Some key phrases to avoid saying to an insurance adjuster include:
  • “I'm sorry.”
  • “It was all/partly my fault.”
  • “I did not see the other person/driver.”

What happens if I don't file an insurance claim?

As a last resort, the insurance company may file a suit against you and get a ruling. You should consider that this procedure can affect your credit rating and your ability to get insured in the future.