Is State Farm or Progressive cheaper?


Editorial team Published on

Progressive is often cheaper on average for standard or high-risk profiles, but State Farm frequently offers lower rates depending on your driving record and demographics.

Average Cost Comparison

  • Progressive: Tends to have lower national average annual premiums overall for standard drivers, good credit, and certain high-risk violations like DUIs.
  • State Farm: Often beats Progressive for specific groups, including teen drivers, senior drivers, and drivers with speeding tickets or at-fault accidents.

You can review a full breakdown of coverage and average costs on U.S. News.

When Progressive is Cheaper

  • Drivers with clean records in many states.
  • Drivers with past DUIs or lower credit scores.
  • Tech-friendly policyholders utilizing tools like Progressive's Snapshot program.

When State Farm is Cheaper

  • Teen and young adult drivers.
  • Drivers with a speeding ticket or an accident on their record.
  • Drivers utilizing State Farm's Drive Safe & Save program (which guarantees rates will not increase due to driving habits).