Is there car insurance that offers breakdown cover?
Yes, many car insurance companies offer roadside assistance or towing coverage as an optional add-on, though mechanical repair coverage works differently.
π‘ Roadside Assistance vs. Mechanical Breakdown
- Roadside Assistance Add-on: Available through many standard auto insurers (like Progressive or Allstate) to cover towing, flat tires, dead batteries, and lockouts.
- Mechanical Breakdown Insurance (MBI): Offered by select insurers (like GEICO or Mercury) to help pay for unexpected car part failures (like engine or transmission breakdown), similar to an extended warranty.
- Standard Policy Exclusion: Standard auto insurance policies do not cover routine maintenance, wear and tear, or mechanical failure unless caused by a covered accident.
π οΈ Common Options and Providers
- π Roadside Assistance: Most major auto insurers let you add 24/7 towing and roadside help for a small monthly fee.
- π§ Mechanical Breakdown Insurance (MBI): Available from companies like GEICO and Mercury, usually requiring the car to be new or have very low mileage.
- π Standalone Plans: Dedicated providers (like AAA or specialized motor clubs) offer alternative or more comprehensive breakdown memberships.
Is breakdown cover worth it on car insurance?
Yes, breakdown cover as a car insurance add-on is usually worth it for the convenience and peace of mind, but standalone policies or comparison shopping often provide better or cheaper comprehensive options.
β Comparing Your Breakdown Options
- π Insurance Add-on
- Convenient to bundle with your annual policy.
- Often limited to basic roadside assistance.
- May exclude home starts or onward travel.
- π’ Standalone Provider (e.g., RAC, AA)
- Provides more comprehensive tiers (Home Start, Recovery).
- Easier to haggle and lower renewal rates.
- Usually offers unlimited callouts compared to basic add-ons.
- π³ Bank Accounts or Bundles
- Check packaged bank accounts for existing coverage.
- May already be included with new car warranties.
- Verify the exact level of protection matches your needs.
π‘ How to Decide
- Check existing perks: Ensure you aren't already covered via a manufacturer warranty, bank account, or joint family policy.
- Assess vehicle reliability: Older or high-mileage cars benefit greatly from full-service or home-start options.
- Weigh emergency costs: A single un-insured motorway recovery can easily exceed several years of membership fees.
How much does car breakdown insurance cost?
The cost of car breakdown protection depends entirely on whether you are looking for roadside assistance (towing, jump-starts, flat tires) or mechanical breakdown insurance (which functions like a car warranty to cover major parts and engine repairs).
1. Roadside Assistance (Emergency Services)
If you want coverage for towing, lockout services, fuel delivery, and flat tires, the pricing varies by how you purchase it:
- As an Insurance Add-On: $12 to $60 per year. Most major auto insurers (like GEICO, Progressive, or State Farm) allow you to add this directly to your premium for just a few dollars a month.
- Standalone Auto Clubs: $33 to $125 per year. Providers like AAA or the Better World Club offer tiered membership plans depending on how many miles of free towing you want.
2. Mechanical Breakdown Insurance (MBI / Car Repair Insurance)
If you are looking for insurance that pays for actual parts and mechanical failures (like a blown transmission or a broken A/C unit), it typically costs:
- Average Annual Premium: $30 to $100 per year (when added directly to an active auto insurance policy).
- Standalone Policies: $33 to $122 per month if purchased through specialized third-party providers.
Note: MBI policies require you to pay a deductible (usually $100 to $250) per repair, and they are typically only available for newer or low-mileage vehicles.
Cost Comparison Overview
| Coverage Type | What it Covers | Average Annual Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Roadside Assistance Add-On | Towing, jump-starts, flat tires, lockouts | $12 β $60 |
| Standalone Auto Club (e.g., AAA) | Upgraded roadside care, travel perks, longer towing limits | $33 β $125 |
| Mechanical Breakdown Insurance (MBI) | Large mechanical repairs (Engine, Transmission, Electrical) | $30 β $100 (plus deductible) |
| Extended Dealership Warranty | Comprehensive mechanical fixes for older vehicles | $1,000 β $3,000 total (upfront/financed) |
Key Factors That Impact Your Price
- Vehicle Age and Mileage: Older cars cost more to protect under mechanical breakdown insuranceβor may be disqualified entirely.
- Make and Model: Luxury or electric vehicles that require specialty parts and labor carry higher premiums.
- Towing Mileage Limits: For roadside policies, packages that cover up to 100 or 200 miles of towing will cost more than basic packages that limit you to 5 or 20 miles.
Is there car insurance that covers breakdowns?
Yes, standard car insurance does not cover mechanical breakdowns, but you can buy a specific add-on called Mechanical Breakdown Insurance (MBI) or opt for roadside assistance.
Mechanical Breakdown Insurance (MBI)
- What it does: MBI pays for unexpected repairs to major mechanical parts, such as your engine, transmission, steering, and electrical systems.
- How it works: It acts much like an extended warranty, but it is regulated as insurance and sold as an optional add-on by some auto insurers.
- Limitations: It usually requires your car to be new or have very low mileage when you first buy the policy (often under 15,000 miles and less than 15 months old), and it does not cover normal wear-and-tear parts like brake pads, tires, or oil changes.
- Where to find it: Major companies like GEICO and Mercury Insurance offer MBI options in certain states.
Roadside Assistance Add-On
- What it does: If your car breaks down on the side of the road, roadside assistance covers the logistical headache of the breakdown itself.
- What it includes: It typically pays for towing services, changing a flat tire, jump-starting a dead battery, or delivering emergency fuel.
- What it excludes: It pays to transport your car to a repair shop, but it does not pay for the actual mechanical parts or repair labor.
Who is best for car breakdown cover?
The best car breakdown cover in the UK depends on your budget and whether you want a specialized budget provider like Start Rescue or a top-performing network like AXA and Green Flag.
Top Providers & Performance
- AXA: Ranked best overall by Which? and industry surveys for fast arrival times (under 1 hour for 72% of calls) and high roadside fix rates (82%).
- Green Flag: Offers strong value, a large local garage network, and a price-match guarantee against The AA or RAC renewals.
- Start Rescue: A budget-friendly, highly recommended choice with policies starting around Β£55 with high customer satisfaction scores.
- The AA & RAC: The largest nationwide networks with extensive patrols and EV-specific charging support, though buying direct can be expensive unless you haggle or use cashback sites.
Types of Cover & Saving Tips
- Check Existing Perks: Look at packaged bank accounts (like Nationwide FlexPlus) or new car warranties, which often include inclusive breakdown assistance.
- Haggle on Renewal: Major names like the AA and RAC have high success rates for haggling; customers frequently cut over Β£100 off their renewal quotes with a short phone call.
- Choose the Right Tier: Basic roadside assistance covers you over a quarter-mile from home, while Home Start and National Recovery add extra peace of mind for longer trips.
Breakdown cover explained: Plus what to do if your car breaks down
Which breakdown cover is the most reliable?
According to independent reliability and performance data from industry surveys (such as What Car? and Which?), AXA and AutoAid rank highest for operational reliability and speed, while The AA and Green Flag score highest for large dedicated patrol fleets and fix rates.
Because "reliability" can mean roadside speed, high roadside repair rates, or large network coverage, reliability varies by provider:
Top Providers for Reliability & Speed
- AXA: Ranked best overall in recent industry performance data, showing the fastest arrival times (under 1 hour for 72% of calls) and a high roadside fix rate of 82%.
- AutoAid: Ranked second for swift response times (combined sub-30 minute and 1-hour arrivals at 78%), offering highly cost-effective independent garage-backed cover.
- The AA: Operates the largest dedicated patrol fleet in the UK (around 2,900 patrols), consistently scoring high for extensive coverage, EV breakdown support, and top results in What Car? reliability surveys.
- Green Flag: Utilizes a vast network of over 3,000 independent technicians across the UK, offering reliable coverage and a price-match guarantee against competitor renewals.
Reliability & Performance Comparison
| Provider | Average Arrival Speed / Performance | Key Reliability Strength | Estimated Annual Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| AXA | Fast arrivals (<1 hr for 72% of calls); 82% fix rate | Highest overall roadside fix rate | Β£25 β Β£95 |
| AutoAid | Fast combined sub-30min/1hr arrivals (78%) | Excellent value and speed via agent network | Β£40 β Β£60 |
| The AA | Large dedicated fleet; strong mobile servicing | Largest dedicated patrol size and EV support | Β£60 β Β£170+ |
| Green Flag | 3,000+ specialized technicians | Broad garage network and consistent callouts | Β£45 β Β£110 |
Can I add breakdown cover to my car insurance?
Yes, you can add breakdown cover to your car insurance as an optional extra with many providers, or buy it as a standalone policy.
How Adding It Works
- When to add: You can select it when buying a new car insurance policy or add it mid-term through your online account or by calling your insurer.
- Important rule: You cannot buy cover and use it immediately for an existing breakdown; policies usually start 24 to 48 hours after purchase.
- No-claims bonus: Breakdown cover is separate from your car insurance, so using it will not affect your no-claims discount.
Things to Check First
- Existing cover: Check your current policy documents, as some comprehensive car insurance policies include breakdown cover as standard.
- Level of cover: Insurers often offer basic roadside assistance. You may need to pay more to include home start, national recovery, or onward travel.
- Compare prices: Adding it to your insurance is convenient, but standalone policies from providers like the RAC or Green Flag or adding it via Admiral can sometimes offer better features or lower prices.
Who has the best roadside assistance insurance?
AAA is the best overall provider for standalone roadside assistance, while Geico and State Farm offer the best and cheapest options when added to an existing auto insurance policy.
Top Standalone Motor Clubs
- AAA: Recognized as the gold standard, covering the person rather than the car with extensive towing (up to 100 miles on higher tiers) and travel perks. Annual plans start around $58 to $139.
- Better World Club: Ranked high for customer satisfaction and eco-friendly, carbon-neutral towing services, with plans starting around $63β$66 per year.
- Good Sam: The top choice for RV owners and long-distance travelers, offering coverage across the U.S., Canada, and Mexico starting near $50 per year.
Top Insurance Add-Ons
- Geico: Offers one of the cheapest add-on plans at around $14 per year, though it requires collision or comprehensive coverage and ties assistance to the specific vehicle.
- State Farm: Known for robust emergency road service coverage that includes standard services plus extra perks like labor for minor fixes, available for a very low monthly cost.
- Travelers: Stands out for premier packages that include winching and up to 100 miles of towing, which is rare for insurance-bundled plans.
What do I do if my car breaks down and I have no money?
Move your car to a safe spot, turn on your hazard lights, and call local community help or roadside programs if you cannot pay for a tow or repair.
Immediate Safety
- Move the car off the road or onto the shoulder.
- Turn on your flashing hazard lights.
- Stay inside the car if you are on a busy highway.
- Check if you have free AAA Roadside Assistance or coverage bundled with your car insurance.
Find Free or Low-Cost Help
- Call 211 or visit 211.org to find local groups that help with emergency transport.
- Ask local vocational schools or non-profit garages if students can fix the car for free or cheap while you only pay for parts.
- Contact local churches or charities that offer crisis support or benevolence funds.
Handle the Repair Shop
- Ask the mechanic for a clear, written estimate.
- Ask if you can pay in stages or set up a payment plan.
- Check if the broken part falls under a car warranty, recall, or insurance claim.
Is AAA cheaper than roadside assistance?
No, AAA is generally more expensive than roadside assistance plans offered by standard auto insurance companies.
Cost Comparison
- Car Insurance Roadside Assistance: Typically costs between $5 and $20 per year (or about $1 to $4 a month) added directly to your policy.
- AAA Membership: Typically costs between $62 and $125+ per year, depending on your location and the tier you choose (Classic, Plus, or Premier).
Key Differences to Consider
While insurance is cheaper, the coverage works differently:
- Insurance coverage is tied to the car: It only covers the specific vehicle listed on your policy. If you drive multiple cars or ride in a friend's car, you are not covered.
- AAA coverage is tied to the person: Your membership follows you into any vehicle, whether you are driving or just a passenger. AAA also bundles extra perks like hotel, travel, and retail discounts.
- Insurance claims risk: As users on Reddit discuss, using your insurance roadside assistance too often can sometimes count as a claim or impact your policy rates. Using AAA does not affect your auto insurance rates.