Is UMR or Anthem better?

Editorial team Published on

Whether Anthem or UMR is better depends on whether you are looking for an individual/family health plan or an employer-sponsored plan, as they operate quite differently.

  • Anthem (a major Blue Cross Blue Shield licensee) is a traditional health insurance company offering individual, family, small business, and Medicare plans across 14 states.
  • UMR is not an insurance company itself; it is a Third-Party Administrator (TPA) owned by UnitedHealthcare (UHC) that manages employer-funded health plans. UMR claims are typically processed through the massive UnitedHealthcare Choice Plus network.

Core Differences

FeatureAnthemUMR (UnitedHealthcare)
TypeTraditional Health Insurance CarrierThird-Party Administrator (TPA) for self-funded plans
AvailabilityIndividual marketplace, Medicare, and group plansPrimarily employer-provided group health plans
NetworkBlue Cross Blue Shield networkUnitedHealthcare Choice Plus network

Which One Should You Choose?

  • Choose Anthem if: You are buying an individual or family plan (such as through an ACA marketplace) or want a widely recognized traditional insurer with standard HMO/EPO/PPO options and multi-state Blue Card travel coverage.
  • Choose UMR if: It is offered as an option through your employer's health benefits. Because UMR utilizes the UnitedHealthcare network, you get access to one of the largest provider networks nationwide. (As a consensus among online health communities, your specific doctor network availability matters more than the brand name itself).

You can check specific plan details and resources on the official UMR Member Site or compare provider options directly on Shortlister.

Which is better, Anthem or UnitedHealthcare?

Neither UnitedHealthcare is universally better than Anthem; the right choice depends on your location, needed plan type, and budget.

Availability and Reach

  • UnitedHealthcare: Operates in all 50 states and serves nearly 50 million people, making it much easier to keep your coverage if you move or travel frequently.
  • Anthem: Operates as a Blue Cross Blue Shield affiliate in only 14 states (though coverage extends nationally through the BCBS network if you travel).

Costs and Plans

  • UnitedHealthcare: Often has higher general plan costs, but offers strong availability for Medicare Advantage and AARP supplemental plans.
  • Anthem: Frequently offers competitive or lower pricing and good options for individual or family marketplace plans in its service areas.

Customer Experience

  • Customer Feedback: Mixed opinions exist for both. Some users praise UnitedHealthcare for large networks, while others report frustrations with claim denials. Anthem users experience similar variations depending on local state networks.

Where does UMR rank in health insurance?

UMR is a third-party administrator (TPA) and a wholly-owned subsidiary of UnitedHealthcare, which ranks as the largest health insurance company in the United States.

How UMR Works

  • Role: UMR does not sell insurance policies directly to individuals. Instead, it manages claims and administrative services for large employers who fund their own employee health plans (called self-funded plans).
  • Network: Because UMR is part of UnitedHealthcare, members use the massive UnitedHealthcare Choice Plus provider network.

Market Position and Size

  • Parent Company: UnitedHealthcare is the nation's biggest health insurer by revenue, membership, and market share.
  • TPA Status: UMR is the largest third-party administrator in the United States, managing benefits for millions of workers across the country.

Pros and Cons

  • Pros: Huge nationwide doctor network, accepted by most major hospitals, and backed by UnitedHealthcare's infrastructure.
  • Cons: Customer satisfaction scores mirror general industry challenges with health plan navigation, and specific coverage rules are set by the individual employer rather than UMR.

Is UMR health insurance good?

UMR is not technically a health insurance company; it is the nation's largest third-party administrator (TPA) owned by UnitedHealthcare that manages self-funded employer health plans.

How UMR Works

  • Role: UMR does not fund care or sell insurance policies directly. Your employer designs and funds the actual health plan, while UMR handles the paperwork, processes claims, and manages customer service.
  • Network: Because it is owned by UnitedHealthcare, UMR uses the large national UnitedHealthcare provider network (typically the Choice Plus network), making it easy to find in-network doctors across the country.

Pros and Cons

  • Pros:
    • Access to the broad UnitedHealthcare provider network.
    • Online member portal and mobile app through UMR Home to track claims and view digital ID cards.
    • No requirement for specialist referrals on standard network plans.
  • Cons:
    • Coverage quality depends entirely on what your specific employer chooses to fund and include in their custom plan design.
    • Public consumer reviews and customer feedback for TPAs like UMR often highlight long customer service wait times and frustrations with denied or delayed claims processing.

Is Anthem as good as Blue Cross Blue Shield?

Anthem is a Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) company, meaning Anthem is not separate from BCBS, but rather the largest for-profit affiliate operating in 14 states.

Because Anthem operates under the BCBS umbrella, comparing them is often a matter of looking at specific state plans rather than two entirely different health insurance systems.

The Relationship Between Anthem and BCBS

  • The Network: Anthem is part of the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association. This gives Anthem members access to the nationwide "Blue Card" network for out-of-state emergency or routine care.
  • Independent Operation: The Blue Cross Blue Shield Association consists of 36 independent companies. Anthem runs its own business operations in 14 states (such as California, New York, and Indiana), while other states have entirely separate BCBS companies.

How Quality and Plans Compare

  • Coverage Quality: User experiences and quality ratings vary by region. According to a NerdWallet Medicare Comparison, Anthem plans offer flexible options and extra perks like "Essential Extras," but some regions report below-average government quality ratings or higher out-of-pocket costs.
  • General Perception: As discussed by users on Reddit Healthcare, the overall value depends heavily on whether your local doctors and hospitals accept your specific Anthem/BCBS tier.
  • Plan Options: Anthem typically offers HMO, PPO, and EPO plans, making it competitive on pricing and network breadth compared to other local non-profit BCBS or Kaiser options.

Are High Deductible Health Insurance Plans a Better Choice?

9 related questions found

How good is Anthem insurance?

Anthem insurance is a large and widely accepted nationwide provider, but customer experiences vary from mixed to poor.

Pros of Anthem Insurance

  • Large Provider Network: As part of the Blue Cross Blue Shield association, Anthem gives members access to an extensive network of doctors, hospitals, and specialists.
  • Nationwide & Travel Coverage: Many plans (like EPOs) include the Blue Card network, which helps cover routine or emergency care when traveling out of state.
  • Variety of Plans: They offer multiple plan types—such as HMOs and EPOs—along with easy add-ons for vision, dental, and life insurance.
  • Perks & Preventive Care: Standard ACA Marketplace plans feature $0 annual physicals and online doctor visits.

Cons of Anthem Insurance

  • Customer Service Complaints: Public review platforms (like WalletHub and Trustpilot) frequently feature complaints about long hold times, difficult website navigation, and unhelpful support.
  • Claim and Medication Denials: Like many major insurers, policyholders often report frustrating prior-authorization hoops or denied claims for specific medicines and procedures.
  • Network Discrepancies: Some users report that certain local providers listed as "in-network" on directories may not actually accept specific Anthem plans.

You can review specific plan structures and costs directly through the Anthem Individual and Family Plans portal.

Is UMR better than Blue Cross?

Neither UMR nor Blue Cross is universally "better," because the quality of your coverage depends entirely on your specific employer's plan design, costs, and the local providers who accept them.

UMR is a third-party administrator (TPA) owned by UnitedHealthcare that processes claims for employer-funded plans using the UnitedHealthcare provider network. Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) is a network of independent regional companies that often feature extensive local and national provider networks.

Key Differences to Compare

  • Provider Network: BCBS is often praised for having large, straightforward PPO networks in many states. UMR uses the UnitedHealthcare network, meaning doctors who take UnitedHealthcare generally accept UMR.
  • Plan Customization: UMR plans are usually self-insured by employers, meaning your specific deductibles, copays, and rules are tailored by your company rather than a standard insurance package. BCBS offers both fully insured and self-insured options with varying regional rules.
  • Costs: Your out-of-pocket expenses—such as monthly premiums, deductibles, and co-pays—depend on what your specific employer negotiates. One plan might be cheaper for prescriptions while the other is better for doctor visits.

Which insurance denies the most claims?

Oscar Health denied 25.3% of in-network claims in 2024, representing the highest denial rate among major national ACA marketplace health insurers.

Health Insurance Denial Rates

  • Oscar Health: Denied 25.3% of marketplace claims.
  • Molina Healthcare: Denied 22% of claims.
  • Ambetter (Celtic): Denied 21% of claims.
  • UnitedHealthcare: Denied 20% of claims (down from 33% the previous year).
  • Kaiser Permanente: Recorded the lowest national rate at approximately 6%.

Homeowners and Auto Insurance Denial Rates

  • Allstate and USAA: Frequently flagged by public reports and consumer data for closing roughly 40% to 50% of property and homeowners claims without payment in high-risk regions.
  • State Farm: Reported home insurance denial rates exceeding 41% to 59% in catastrophe-heavy markets like Florida.

What is the #1 health insurance in America?

UnitedHealth Group is the #1 health insurance company in America by size, market share, and enrollment.

Largest Insurers by Size

  • UnitedHealth Group (UnitedHealthcare): The largest overall provider in the U.S., controlling over 16% of the market with tens of millions of enrolled members.
  • Elevance Health (formerly Anthem): The second-largest health insurer by enrollment, managing major Blue Cross Blue Shield plans in multiple states.
  • CVS Health (Aetna): A massive national carrier offering diverse employer, individual, and group coverage.

Top Rated for Customer Satisfaction

If "number one" means quality and member satisfaction rather than sheer size, Kaiser Permanente is frequently ranked as the #1 best overall health plan by publications like Insure.com and Investopedia for its high customer satisfaction, integrated care model, and affordability. Another major top-tier network with massive nationwide coverage is Blue Cross Blue Shield.

Is UMR part of Blue Cross Blue Shield?

No, UMR is not part of Blue Cross Blue Shield; it is a subsidiary and third-party administrator owned by UnitedHealthcare Group.

Key Details About UMR

  • Parent Company: UMR is part of UnitedHealth Group, making it a sister organization to UnitedHealthcare and Optum.
  • What UMR Does: It functions as a third-party administrator (TPA) that processes claims and manages benefits for employers who self-fund their health plans.
  • Network Connection: While not affiliated with Blue Cross Blue Shield Association, UMR-administered plans often utilize UnitedHealthcare provider networks (such as the Choice Plus network).