Should I get a lawyer for a car accident that was my fault?

Editorial team Published on

Generally, you do not need to hire your own private lawyer if a car accident was your fault and the other party's damages are fully covered by your auto insurance policy. Your insurance company provides a defense attorney for you if a lawsuit is filed.

When Your Insurance Company Handles It

  • Policy Coverage: As long as the damages and injuries do not exceed your policy limits, your insurance adjuster and company-provided lawyers manage the claims process, negotiations, and any legal defense.
  • Cooperation: Cooperate with your insurance company, provide an honest account, and let them handle the communication with the other driver's insurance.

When You Should Consider Hiring Your Own Lawyer

You may want to consult or hire a private attorney (at your own expense) if:

  • Exceeding Policy Limits: The other party's medical bills or property damage are much higher than your coverage limits, meaning you could be personally sued for the remainder.
  • Severe Personal Exposure: You have significant personal assets (such as a home or savings) that are at risk because the claim exceeds what your insurer will pay.
  • Criminal Charges: You are facing criminal or serious traffic charges (such as reckless driving or driving under the influence) tied to the accident.
  • Insurance Denial/Bad Faith: Your insurance company wrongfully denies coverage or refuses to defend you properly.

What happens when you are at fault in a car accident?

When you are at fault in a car accident, you are legally and financially responsible for the resulting property damage and injuries.

Immediate Steps and Fault Determination

  • Stay at the scene: Never leave the area after a crash. Pull over safely, check for injuries, and call 911.
  • Avoid admitting fault: Do not apologize or say the accident was your fault. Police and insurance adjusters determine liability based on evidence.
  • Exchange information: Share names, contact details, insurance info, and license numbers with the other driver.

Financial and Insurance Consequences

  • Insurance payouts: Your liability insurance (Progressive Insurance Guide) covers the other driver's medical bills and vehicle repairs up to your policy limits.
  • Out-of-pocket costs: If damages exceed your coverage limits, you must pay the remaining balance yourself. Your own vehicle repairs require collision coverage, if you purchased it.
  • Higher rates: Your car insurance premiums typically increase after an at-fault accident. Your insurer might also drop your coverage or refuse to renew your policy.

Legal Risks

  • Lawsuits: The injured parties can sue you for medical expenses, lost wages, and pain. If a judgment exceeds your insurance, a court can target your personal assets or savings.
  • Criminal charges: Severe violations like reckless driving or driving under the influence lead to criminal charges, fines, license suspension, or jail time.

Should I get a lawyer after a car accident that was not my fault?

Yes, you should get a lawyer if you suffered serious injuries, if fault is disputed, or if the insurance company offers a low settlement.

Even when an accident is not your fault, insurance companies often try to reduce payouts, shift blame, or downplay your medical needs.

When You Need a Lawyer

  • Severe injuries: You have broken bones, required surgery, or need long-term medical care.
  • Disputed fault: The other driver or the insurance company claims you share the blame.
  • Low offers: The insurer offers a settlement that does not cover your medical bills or lost wages.
  • Complicated coverage: The other driver is uninsured, underinsured, or it is a hit-and-run.

When You Might Not Need a Lawyer

  • Property damage only: There are no injuries, and vehicle damage is minor.
  • Fair treatment: The insurance company accepts full liability and pays for your repairs and quick medical visits promptly.

Most personal injury attorneys offer a free initial consultation to review your case, and many work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they only get paid if you win money.

Is it worth hiring an attorney for a car accident?

Hiring an attorney for a car accident is generally worth it if you suffered significant injuries, missed work, or face a dispute over who was at fault.

When It Is Worth Hiring an Attorney

  • Severe injuries: Accidents involving broken bones, surgeries, hospital stays, or permanent impairment require professional help to account for current and future medical bills.
  • Disputed liability: If the other driver or insurance adjuster claims you caused the crash, an attorney can gather police reports, witness statements, and expert testimony to prove negligence.
  • Lowball insurance offers: Adjusters often try to settle quickly for far less than a claim is worth before the full scope of medical care is clear.
  • Lost wages: If you missed time at work or face long-term earning difficulties, a lawyer can accurately calculate and demand those lost funds.

When You Might Not Need an Attorney

  • No injuries: Everyone involved is completely uninjured.
  • Minor property damage: There is only minor cosmetic damage to vehicles in a simple fender bender.
  • Clear, undisputed fault: The other party’s insurance immediately accepts full liability and offers a fair settlement that covers all your verified expenses.

Costs and How They Work

Most personal injury attorneys offer a free initial consultation and work on a contingency fee basis. This means you pay nothing upfront, and the lawyer only takes an agreed-upon percentage (typically 30% to 40%) if they successfully recover money for you. Many users on Reddit also note that a good attorney can negotiate down medical liens, which helps offset their legal fee.

Is it worth suing after a car accident?

Suing after a car accident is usually worth it if you have severe injuries, mounting medical bills, or an insurance company that refuses to offer a fair settlement.

When Suing is Worth It

  • Severe or permanent injuries: If you suffered broken bones, traumatic brain injuries, surgery, or long-term disability, insurance payouts often fail to cover the true cost.
  • Lowball insurance offers: When an insurer denies responsibility, delays payment, or offers far less than your medical bills and lost wages, a lawsuit can force fair compensation.
  • Liability disputes: If the other driver blames you, a lawsuit opens up a formal discovery process to uncover evidence and police reports.

When Suing Might Not Be Worth It

  • Minor property damage or no injuries: If damages are low and resolved quickly by insurance, litigation costs and time may outweigh the payout.
  • The at-fault driver has no assets or insurance: Winning a judgment against an uninsured driver who has no money rarely results in actual recovery.
  • High legal costs: Personal injury lawyers typically work on contingency (taking around 33% to 40% of the settlement), which can reduce your net recovery.

You can learn more about evaluating your options from the Bell Legal Group or DBJ Law.

Should I Get a Lawyer for a Car Accident That Wasn't My Fault?

9 related questions found

Will my insurance pay out if it was my fault?

Yes, your insurance will pay out if the accident is your fault, but how it works depends on the specific types of coverage on your policy.

How Payouts Work When You Are at Fault

  • Liability Coverage: This pays for the other driver's property damage and medical bills if you cause an accident. It also helps pay for legal defense if they sue you, up to your policy limits.
  • Collision Coverage: This optional coverage pays to repair or replace your own car when you cause an accident or hit an object, minus your deductible. If you do not have collision coverage, your insurer will not pay for damage to your own vehicle.
  • Deductibles: You must pay your deductible out of pocket before collision coverage kicks in to fix your car.
  • Rate Increases: Filing an at-fault claim usually causes your insurance company to raise your rates when your policy renews, unless you have accident forgiveness.

Most users on Reddit agree that your insurer handles your car repairs as long as you carry collision coverage and the crash was not intentional or fraudulent.

How to beat an at-fault accident?

To successfully dispute or overturn an at-fault accident ruling, you must quickly gather strong counter-evidence and formally contest the decision with your insurance company or the police.

Steps to Dispute an At-Fault Decision

  • Collect scene evidence: Pull together your photos, videos, dashcam footage, and witness contact details immediately.
  • Review the police report: Get a copy of the official report. If the officer made a factual mistake or missed a key detail, contact the department to request an amendment or submit a written statement.
  • Notify your insurer: Contact your insurance claims adjuster in writing right away to state that you dispute the fault determination.
  • Hire an expert: Consider bringing in an independent accident reconstruction specialist if the insurance company refuses to budge on a complex crash.
  • Fight related tickets: If you received a traffic citation tied to the accident, fight it in traffic court. Beating the ticket helps weaken the insurer's claim that you broke a law.
  • Escalate the dispute: File a complaint with your state's insurance regulatory or financial services department if your insurer acts unfairly.

Mistakes to Avoid

  • Do not admit liability: Never apologize or say things like "I didn't see you" at the scene. Insurers use casual apologies as official admissions of guilt.
  • Avoid recorded statements: Do not give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurance company without legal guidance.
  • Do not rush a settlement: Reject quick, low-ball payout offers that require you to sign a complete liability release.

Do insurance companies want you to get a lawyer?

No, insurance companies generally do not want you to get a lawyer.

Insurance providers are profit-driven businesses. Their main goal is to protect their bottom line by minimizing payouts and closing claims quickly.

Why Insurers Dislike Lawyers

  • Higher payouts: Claims handled by attorneys often result in much larger settlements because lawyers know the true value of damages.
  • Loss of control: Lawyers stop adjusters from using confusing jargon, lowball offers, or misleading statements.
  • Accountability: Attorneys can spot bad-faith practices and take cases to trial if a fair deal is not met.

When You Should Get a Lawyer

While minor claims with clear fault often do not require legal help, getting an attorney is smart if:

How much of a $25,000 settlement will I get?

You will typically take home between $10,000 and $17,000 from a gross $25,000 personal injury settlement, according to standard estimates from the Fair Settlement Guide.

The exact amount you receive depends on what is deducted from your gross total before the final check is issued.

Typical Breakdown of Deductions

A standard pre-suit settlement usually splits the $25,000 into the following approximate amounts:

  • Gross Settlement: $25,000 (The total amount paid by the insurance company)
  • Attorney Fees: Around $8,333 (Typically 33.3% if the case settles before filing a formal lawsuit, or up to 40% if a lawsuit is filed)
  • Case Costs: Around $500 to $1,500 (Expenses for filing fees, medical records, or expert reports)
  • Medical Bills and Liens: Around $3,000 to $5,000 (Repayment for hospitals, doctors, or health insurance that covered your initial treatment)
  • Your Estimated Net Take-Home: $10,000 to $12,500 (This can increase if your attorney successfully negotiates lower medical liens)

Key Factors That Change Your Payout

  • Whether You Have a Lawyer: If you handle the claim yourself and have no medical liens, you keep a much larger portion of the $25,000. However, studies show attorneys often secure higher overall settlements.
  • Litigation Status: If your case requires filing a lawsuit in court, attorney fees often rise from 33.3% to 40%, leaving less for you.
  • Medical Lien Negotiations: A skilled lawyer will often negotiate with healthcare providers to reduce your unpaid bills, which directly increases your final payout.

What not to tell the attorney?

You should never lie to, hide facts from, or mislead your own attorney, because full disclosure is protected by attorney-client privilege.

Instead of hiding crucial information from your legal team, you should avoid saying or doing things that undermine your case, insult their expertise, or waste valuable time.

What NOT to Say to Your Lawyer

  • "This case will be easy money for you": This insults your attorney's professional effort and expertise.
  • "I have already done the work for you": This inappropriately undermines their specialized legal training.
  • "I didn't think that detail was important": Leaving out minor facts can blindside your legal team when the opposing side uncovers them.
  • Asking them to lie or cover up facts: Lying to your lawyer prevents them from building an effective defense or strategy.

Information You Must NOT Hide

  • Prior criminal history or past legal issues: Your lawyer needs to know about past civil or criminal proceedings before the opposition brings them up.
  • Hidden assets or court order violations: Hiding financial details or past violations in family or civil law creates severe penalties later.
  • Social media posts or statements made to others: Admitting fault or discussing your case publicly can be used against you in court.