Should you file a claim if you weren't at fault?

Editorial team Published on

Yes, you should report an accident to your insurance company even if you were not at fault, but you can choose whether to file a formal repair claim with them or the other driver's insurer.

✅ Filing with the Other Driver’s Insurance (Third-Party Claim)

  • No upfront deductible: You do not pay anything out of pocket before repairs begin.
  • Slower process: They must investigate and contact their insured driver before approving.
  • Communication hurdles: They may drag out the process or dispute liability.

✅ Filing with Your Own Insurance (First-Party Claim)

  • Faster repairs: Your insurer handles the damage immediately using your collision coverage.
  • Upfront deductible: You must pay your deductible first, which gets refunded later through subrogation.
  • Subrogation recovery: Your insurer fights the other driver's company to get your money back.

💡 How to Choose Your Next Step

FeatureFiling with Your InsurerFiling with Other Insurer
SpeedFast (Days)Slow (Weeks)
Out-of-PocketDeductible required upfront$0 deductible
WorkloadLow (Insurer handles it)High (You manage calls)

Should I file a claim if it wasn't my fault?

You should generally report an accident to your own insurance company even if it wasn't your fault, though you can choose whether to file a formal repair claim with them or the other driver's insurer.

Reporting vs. Filing a Claim

  • Report the accident: Most insurance policies require you to notify your insurer promptly after an incident. Failing to report can risk your coverage or leave you unprotected if the other driver changes their story or sues you later.
  • Filing a claim: You have two main paths for getting your car fixed or medical bills paid.

Option 1: File Through Your Own Insurance (First-Party Claim)

  • Pros: The process is usually faster because your insurer handles your repairs immediately and deals with the paperwork.
  • Cons: You typically have to pay your deductible upfront. Your insurer will later try to recover this money (and your deductible) from the other driver through a process called subrogation, which can take several weeks or months.

Option 2: File Through the Other Driver’s Insurance (Third-Party Claim)

  • Pros: You generally do not have to pay an upfront deductible.
  • Cons: The process can be slower. The other insurance company must complete a liability investigation and contact their driver before they approve and pay for your damages.

For official step-by-step guidance on managing these choices, you can review State Farm's Auto Claim Guide. If the other party or insurer attempts to shift blame incorrectly, resources like Don Marcari's Legal Insights offer advice on protecting your interests.

Does your insurance go up after a claim that is not your fault?

Yes, your car insurance rates can still go up after a claim that is not your fault, depending on your state and insurance company.

Why Rates Can Increase

  • Risk assessment: Insurers look at any claim as a sign that you might be a higher risk for future claims, even if you did not cause the crash.
  • Payout involvement: If your own insurance company has to pay out money for your repairs or medical bills (and then try to get it back from the other driver later), your rates may go up.
  • Loss of discounts: Filing a claim can cause you to lose a "claims-free" or "accident-free" discount, which makes your overall price go up.

State Laws and Rules

  • State protections: Some states do not allow companies to raise your rates if an accident is not your fault. For example, California and Oklahoma have laws that protect drivers from rate hikes in these situations.
  • Company policies: Different insurance companies have different rules. Some companies, like State Farm, choose not to raise rates for drivers who are not at fault, while others might raise them by a small percentage.

Can insurance penalize you for accidents that are not your fault?

Yes, an insurance company can sometimes raise your rates or penalize you for an accident that is not your fault.

Why Your Rates Can Increase

  • Filing a Claim: If you file a claim through your own insurance policy (such as for uninsured motorists, collision coverage, or personal injury protection), your insurer pays out money. This payout makes you statistically riskier in their eyes, even if you did nothing wrong.
  • State Laws: Regulations vary by location. Some states explicitly ban companies from raising rates after a not-at-fault crash, while other states allow it.
  • No-Fault States: In true no-fault states, your own insurer handles your medical bills regardless of who caused the crash, which can still trigger a rate adjustment depending on the company.
  • Claim History: Multiple past claims—even if none were your fault—signal a higher overall frequency of losses to an insurance provider.

How to Protect Yourself

  • File with the At-Fault Driver: When possible, file a third-party claim directly with the other driver's liability insurance rather than your own to help avoid premium spikes.
  • Shop Around: Insurance rules vary widely by provider. For instance, as discussed on Reddit, opinions and experiences differ, and companies like State Farm may handle not-at-fault claims differently than competitors like Progressive. If your rates go up, you can compare insurance quotes with other companies.
  • Check State Rules: Look up your specific state's department of insurance guidelines to see if rate increases for not-at-fault accidents are permitted.

When not to file a car insurance claim?

Avoid filing a car insurance claim when the cost to repair the damage is less than or close to your policy deductible, or when the out-of-pocket fix is cheaper than your expected multi-year rate increase.

🛑 When Not to File a Claim

  • 🏷️ Below Deductible: Repairs cost less than your out-of-pocket deductible.
    • Example: $450 scratch with a $500 deductible.
    • Result: Insurance pays nothing, but the incident still hits your record.
  • 🚗 Minor Single-Car Damage: You dented your own bumper or hit your own mailbox.
    • Example: Nominal damage under $1,000.
    • Result: Cheaper to pay a local shop directly than risk a rate hike.
  • 📉 High Rate Hike Risk: Premium increases cost more over three years than the repair itself.
    • Example: An at-fault claim can raise rates by an average of $2,000 over 3 years.
  • 🚙 Older Cosmetic Damage: The car has high mileage and low resale value.
    • Example: Minor hail dents on a 12-year-old commuter car.
    • Result: Fixing the cosmetic look does not increase the car's practical value.

📊 Cost Comparison Example

ScenarioOut-of-Pocket CostFiling a Claim CostBest Choice
Damage under deductible ($400 repair / $500 deductible)$400 one-time$400 + potential rate increasePay out-of-pocket
Slightly above deductible ($800 repair / $500 deductible)$800 one-time$500 deductible + 3-year rate hike ($1,500+)Pay out-of-pocket
Major structural damage ($6,000 repair / $500 deductible)$6,000 one-time$500 deductible + rate hikeFile a claim

⚠️ Hidden Risks of Skipping a Claim

  • 👥 Other People Involved: Never settle privately if another car or person is involved.
    • Result: The other driver can sue you later for hidden damages or delayed medical bills.
  • 🏥 Injuries Present: Any sign of bodily harm requires immediate formal reporting.
    • Result: Adrenaline masks pain; minor stiffness can turn into costly medical claims weeks later.
  • 📋 State Rules: Some regions mandate reporting accidents past a specific dollar threshold to the DMV or police.

What Happens If You Are Not At Fault for An Car Accident?

9 related questions found

How much will my insurance go up after an at-fault claim?

Your car insurance rates will typically increase by 40% to 50% on average nationwide after a single at-fault accident.

Key Factors That Change the Amount

  • Cost and Severity: Minor fender-benders cause smaller bumps, while severe crashes with injuries or totaled cars push rates up much higher.
  • Driving History: Clean records see smaller jumps, while multiple recent claims or tickets can cause rates to double.
  • State Rules: Local laws affect how much and how long an insurer can raise your rates.
  • Loss of Discounts: You may lose claim-free or safe-driver discounts, adding to your overall costs.

Duration of the Increase

  • Surcharge Length: Extra fees stay on your insurance record for 3 to 5 years.
  • Gradual Decrease: Rates often drop back down after three years of safe driving, disappearing completely after five years.

Ways to Lower Your Costs

  • Accident Forgiveness: Check if your provider, like Progressive or GEICO, waived your first accident.
  • Shop Around: Compare new quotes at renewal time to find a cheaper carrier.
  • Defensive Driving: Take an approved driving course to earn a discount.
  • Adjust Policies: Raise your deductible or drop unused coverage.

What not to tell your insurance company?

Never admit fault, apologize, or downplay your injuries when speaking to an insurance adjuster after an accident.

Statements to Avoid

  • "I'm sorry" or "It was my fault": Insurers treat apologies as a legal admission of liability, which can reduce or eliminate your compensation.
  • "I'm fine" or "I'm not hurt": Adrenaline can mask severe conditions like internal bleeding or traumatic brain injuries that appear days later. Early statements that you are fine are used to deny later claims.
  • Guesses or speculation: Never estimate speeds, distances, or timing. Stick strictly to objective facts you know for certain.
  • Recorded statements: You can decline requests for a recorded interview until you consult legal counsel, as adjusters use these recordings to trap you in inconsistencies.

Safe Communication Guidelines

  • Provide only basic facts like the date, time, location, and your contact or policy details.
  • Refer the adjuster to a qualified Car Accident Lawyer to manage further discussions and protect your rights.

How much should I expect my car insurance to go up after a claim?

You can expect your car insurance to go up by an average of 20% to 50% (and sometimes up to 80% depending on the state and insurer) after an at-fault accident claim.

Key Factors Impacting Rate Increases

  • Fault: At-fault accidents trigger the largest rate hikes. Not-at-fault accidents or comprehensive claims (like weather, theft, or hitting an animal) cause smaller increases or may not raise rates at all, depending on your state.
  • Severity: Minor fender-benders result in smaller hikes, while major crashes with severe property damage or injuries cause massive premium spikes.
  • Loss of Discounts: Even if your base rate doesn't get a direct surcharge, you may lose your "claims-free" or "accident-free" discount.
  • Duration: Rate increases (surcharges) typically stay on your policy for 3 to 5 years before dropping off, assuming you maintain a clean record.

You can check guidance from Progressive on how accidents impact coverage, or review insights from State Farm regarding claims and savings eligibility.

What happens after a car accident that is not your fault?

After a car accident that is not your fault, you must document the scene, notify insurers, and decide whether to file through your own or the other driver's policy.

🚨 Immediate Scene Actions

  • Call 911 for police and medical help.
  • Photograph vehicle damage, road signs, and skid marks.
  • Collect driver names, phone numbers, and insurance details.
  • Get contact information from any available witnesses.
  • Obtain the official police report number from the officer.

🗓️ Insurance Claim Options

OptionProsCons
At-Fault InsurerNo upfront deductible owedSlower verification and liability checks
Your Own InsurerFaster repairs and communicationPay deductible upfront (reimbursed later via subrogation)

💡 Managing Medical Care and Expenses

  • See a doctor immediately, as adrenaline masks hidden injuries.
  • Save all medical bills, receipts, and repair estimates.
  • Keep a written log of missed workdays and lost wages.
  • Decline quick, lowball cash settlement offers from adjusters.

What's the biggest mistake people often make when dealing with an insurance claim?

The biggest mistake people often make when dealing with an insurance claim is giving too much information too soon—such as providing a recorded statement or casually saying "I'm fine" to an adjuster. Insurance adjusters often call quickly to get statements that they can use to lower or deny your payout.

Other Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Admitting Fault Prematurely: Saying "I'm sorry" or guessing about what happened at the scene can be twisted into an admission of liability before all facts are known.
  • Accepting the First Offer: The initial settlement check is usually a low-ball offer meant to close the case cheaply before you realize the true cost of repairs or medical bills.
  • Delaying Medical Care or Filing: Waiting too days to see a doctor or report the incident gives insurers an opening to argue your injuries or damages didn't happen during the event.
  • Poor Documentation: Failing to take photos, keep receipts, or track medical visits makes it hard to prove the real value of your claim.
  • Posting on Social Media: Sharing photos or details online gives the insurance company evidence to claim you are less injured or damaged than you state.