What are people saying about AMI Insurance?

Editorial team Published on

People generally report mixed to negative feedback regarding AMI Insurance, citing frustrations with customer service, claim handling, and recent updates to their pricing systems.

⚠️ Common Complaints & Negatives

  • Customer Service Delays: Users on Trustpilot report long hold times, repetitive questioning, and difficulty canceling policies.
  • Claim Pushback: Reviewers express frustration over claim denials or insurers focusing heavily on what is excluded rather than offering support.
  • System & Pricing Changes: Users on Reddit note a consensus that a new risk-assessment system has driven up premiums and removed multi-policy discounts.
  • Less Competitive Pricing: Independent reviews point out that premiums can be higher than newer challenger alternatives.

✅ Positive Aspects & Coverage Pros

  • Comprehensive Travel Cover: Reviewers on MoneyHub NZ highlight wide medical limits and coverage for specific adventure activities.
  • Rental Excess Protection: Travel policies offer strong rental vehicle excess coverage up to $10,000.

Is AMI Insurance any good?

AMI Insurance (primarily operating in New Zealand as AMI Insurance and distinct from Australia's AAMI) offers comprehensive auto, home, and contents policies, but customer feedback is mixed.

Coverage and Benefits

  • Strong value awards: AMI won a Canstar Outstanding Value Home & Contents Insurance Award.
  • Perks: Comprehensive car insurance includes free, 24/7 unlimited roadside rescue.
  • Local trades: Home policyholders in major NZ centers can access their dedicated HomeHub tradesperson repair network.

Customer Feedback and Complaints

  • Low public ratings: On platforms like Trustpilot, the company holds a low score (around 1.9 out of 5 stars).
  • Common issues: Reviewers frequently cite long phone hold times, frustrating automated support loops, and delays from case managers.
  • Positive notes: A smaller group of customers reports that policy setup is fast and individual staff members can be friendly and efficient.

What are people saying about American Income Life insurance?

Public sentiment regarding American Income Life Insurance (AIL) is largely mixed to negative from consumers and current/former employees, though the company maintains solid financial strength ratings (such as an AA- from Fitch Ratings).

Customer Complaints and Negative Feedback

  • Aggressive Sales and Marketing: Reviewers on platforms like Trustpilot, Yelp, and the Better Business Bureau frequently cite unwanted, persistent phone calls, uninvited home visits, and high-pressure tactics aimed at getting customers to upgrade or re-sign policies at much higher costs.
  • Cancellation Difficulties: Many customers report facing significant administrative hurdles, continuous bank drafts after requesting cancellation, and prolonged back-and-forth communication when attempting to cancel their policies.
  • Legal and Data Issues: The company and its parent organization, Globe Life, faced scrutiny and a class-action data breach settlement finalized in mid-2026. Publications like Business Insider have historically advised consumers to exercise caution.

Employee and Agent Perspectives

  • Work Environment: Reviews from field agents on sites like Indeed are polarized. Some agents praise the compensation model, weekly training opportunities, and provided leads.
  • High Turnover and Pressure: Conversely, many former agents describe the role as a stressful 100% commission job that relies on aggressive scripts, demanding hours, and difficult cold-to-warm calling structures.

Is AAMI car insurance good?

AAMI car insurance is a popular, award-winning option in Australia that balances solid coverage features with competitive pricing.

✅ Pros of AAMI Car Insurance

  • Strong Coverage: Includes new car replacement for cars under two years old, hire cars after not-at-fault accidents, and a lifetime repair guarantee.
  • Safe Driver Rewards: Offers up to a 15% discount for consecutive claim-free years.
  • Recognized Value: Winner of the 2026 Canstar Outstanding Value Car Insurance award.
  • Easy Management: Highly rated online and in-app tools for lodging and tracking claims.

⚠️ Cons and Limitations

  • No Choice of Repairer: AAMI chooses the repair shop, meaning you cannot pick your own mechanic.
  • Extra Costs for Roadside Assist: Roadside assistance is an optional add-on rather than a free inclusion.
  • Mixed Customer Feedback: While internal surveys and Finder/Canstar score them well, independent review platforms like ProductReview show mixed customer complaints regarding phone wait times and premium increases.

📊 Coverage Comparison

FeatureAAMI Comprehensive
Accidental DamageCovered (Market or Agreed Value)
Third-Party PropertyUp to $20 million
Hire Car (Not-at-fault)Included (up to 21 days)
Choice of RepairerNo (AAMI-assigned network only)

Who is AMI Insurance owned by?

AMI Insurance is owned by IAG New Zealand Limited, a business division of the Australian general insurance company Insurance Australia Group (IAG).

Ownership Details

  • Parent Company: Insurance Australia Group (IAG), an insurance group listed on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX).
  • Local Operations: Operated locally in New Zealand as a division of IAG New Zealand Limited.
  • History: Founded in 1926 as a mutual company owned by its policyholders, AMI was acquired by IAG in 2012 following the Christchurch earthquakes.

Tips and tricks - AMI Insurance

9 related questions found

Who is the underwriter for AMI?

AMI Insurance is underwritten by IAG New Zealand Limited (IAG), a subsidiary of the Australia-based Insurance Australia Group.

Key Details

  • Parent Company: Insurance Australia Group (IAG).
  • Exceptions: AMI Travel insurance is administered by Cover-More NZ Ltd and underwritten by Zurich Australian Insurance Limited (trading as Zurich New Zealand).
  • Financial Strength: IAG New Zealand holds an AA (very strong) financial strength rating.

Who is the most trusted insurance company?

USAA is widely ranked as one of the most trusted insurance companies in the United States, particularly for auto and home insurance among military members and their families.

For the general public, top-rated and highly trusted insurers vary by category based on customer satisfaction surveys and financial strength:

  • Auto Insurance: Travelers and State Farm consistently score high for reliability and customer trust.
  • Home Insurance: Amica and State Farm rank near the top for claims handling and customer satisfaction.
  • Life Insurance: Northwestern Mutual and New York Life lead industry trust and financial stability rankings.
  • Health Insurance: Kaiser Permanente is nationally recognized as top-ranked for member satisfaction.

What is the lawsuit against American Income Life?

American Income Life Insurance Company and its parent company, Globe Life, face a $3.4 million class action settlement regarding a data breach that occurred in October 2024.

The 2024 Data Breach Lawsuit

  • The Issue: The lawsuit (In re American Income Life Ins. Co. and Globe Life Inc. Data Breach Litig.) states that the companies failed to protect private consumer data.
  • Impacted Data: The incident exposed names, Social Security numbers, addresses, phone numbers, health data, and policy details of over 532,000 people.
  • Settlement Details: The companies deny wrongdoing but agreed to a $3.4 million fund.
  • Key Deadlines: Affected individuals must submit claims by October 19, 2026. The final approval hearing is set for December 14, 2026. Claims can be filed at the American Income Life Data Settlement site.

Other Notable Recent Lawsuits

  • Robocalls ($14M Settlement): American Income Life settled a $14 million lawsuit (Fuld v. American Income Life Insurance) in late 2025 over automated sales calls made to numbers on the National Do Not Call Registry.
  • Labor and Wage Claims: Past lawsuits have targeted the company for failing to properly compensate sales trainees or provide accurate overtime and breaks.

How much does a $100,000 life insurance policy cost a month?

For a healthy non-smoker, a $100,000 term life insurance policy typically costs between $8 and $30 per month, while a $100,000 whole life insurance policy averages between $75 and $230 per month.

Your exact price depends heavily on your age, gender, health status, and whether or not you smoke.

Average Monthly Cost by Policy Type

Age & ProfileTerm Life (10 to 20-Year Term)Whole Life (Permanent)
Age 30 (Healthy Non-Smoker)$8 – $12 / month$75 – $88 / month
Age 40 (Healthy Non-Smoker)$11 – $29 / month$110 – $135 / month
Age 50 (Healthy Non-Smoker)$15 – $34 / month$175 – $230 / month
Smokers (Any Age)2x to 3x more than non-smokersSignificantly higher premiums

Key Factors That Affect Your Rate

  • Term vs. Whole Life: Term life is highly affordable because it only covers you for a set window of time (e.g., 10, 20, or 30 years) and does not build cash value. Whole life covers you permanently and builds equity, making it much more expensive.
  • Age: Rates rise as you get older. Locking in a policy while you are young ensures the lowest possible payment.
  • No-Exam Policies: Opting for a simplified or "no medical exam" policy provides faster approval but typically increases the monthly cost by a few dollars compared to fully underwritten policies.

To compare exact prices for your situation, you can use online comparison tools like the Policygenius Quote Engine or view coverage assessments on Aflac.

Which life insurance company is the most reliable?

Northwestern Mutual and MassMutual are widely considered the most reliable life insurance companies because they earn top financial strength ratings and have very few customer complaints.

Top Reliable Life Insurance Carriers

  • Northwestern Mutual: Holds an A++ rating from AM Best for financial stability. It is the largest life insurer in the U.S. and consistently reports the lowest customer complaint ratio relative to its size.
  • MassMutual: Earns an A++ rating for financial strength. As a mutual company owned by its policyholders, it has a long history of paying out steady dividends.
  • New York Life: Operates with an A++ rating and has more than 180 years of experience. It is known for long-term stability and dependable payout options.
  • Guardian Life: Maintains an A++ AM Best rating and an extremely low complaint rate with the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).

What Makes an Insurer Reliable?

  • Financial Strength Ratings: Look for an A++ or A+ rating from agencies like AM Best. This score means the company has enough money to pay out claims even during a major economic downturn.
  • Complaint Index: Check the NAIC complaint ratio. A lower score means the company receives fewer official grievances from policyholders.
  • Mutual Structure: Companies owned by policyholders rather than outside shareholders often focus more on long-term stability and paying consistent dividends.