What are some examples of false claims?

Editorial team Published on

A false claim is a demand for government money or property based on a material falsehood or fraud, most commonly regulated under the federal False Claims Act.

Common Examples in Healthcare

  • Billing for Services Not Rendered: Charging Medicare or Medicaid for patient appointments, tests, or procedures that never took place.
  • Upcoding: Submitting bills for a more expensive medical procedure or diagnosis code than the service actually performed.
  • Kickbacks: Paying or receiving bonuses, cash, or gifts in exchange for patient referrals in federal healthcare programs.
  • Unnecessary Procedures: Performing and billing for medical treatments that a patient does not need to increase reimbursement.

Common Examples in Government Contracting

  • Substandard Goods: Delivering cheaper, lower-quality, or counterfeit materials while promising high-grade or tested equipment.
  • False Certification: Lying about compliance with safety standards, labor laws, or regulatory rules to keep receiving government contract funds.
  • Double Billing: Charging the government more than once for the same service, or shifting costs improperly between different contracts.

Reverse False Claims

  • Underpaying Obligations: Using false records or concealment to hide money owed to the government, such as underpaying customs duties on imported goods.

Can you give me an example of a False Claims Act?

A common example of a False Claims Act violation is a healthcare provider billing Medicare for medical services that were never provided.

Healthcare Fraud Examples

  • Billing for services not rendered: A clinic charges the government for patient visits or tests that did not happen.
  • Upcoding: A provider uses a billing code for a costly medical procedure when they only performed a basic, cheaper one.
  • Unnecessary care: A doctor performs and bills for medical treatments that a patient does not need.

Government Contractor Fraud Examples

  • Substandard materials: A company sells equipment to the military that fails to meet required safety or quality standards, but certifies it is compliant.
  • Inflated costs: A contractor charges the government for inflated prices or labor hours that were never worked.

You can read more about definitions and details on the Civil Division False Claims Act page. You can also review additional False Claims Examples provided by The Anti-Fraud Coalition.

What are false claims?

A false claim is an untrue statement or a fraudulent demand for money, property, or services, most commonly referring to an illegal attempt to cheat the government out of funds.

General Definition

In everyday language, a false claim is a statement that is incorrect, untrue, or deceptive. It means asking for something—like credit, ownership, or compensation—using facts that are made up or wrong.

Legal Definition: The False Claims Act

In a legal context, a false claim falls under the Department of Justice False Claims Act, a law first passed in 1863 during the Civil War to stop fraud by military contractors.

You can learn more about how courts define these actions through What Is a False Claim? guides. Under this law, a false claim occurs when an individual or business knowingly asks the federal government to pay money it does not owe.

Common Examples

  • Healthcare Fraud: Billing Medicare or Medicaid for medical services that were never provided or exaggerating the level of care given to get higher pay.
  • Contractor Fraud: Charging the government for top-quality building materials while secretly delivering cheap or broken supplies.
  • False Records: Using altered timesheets or fake receipts to influence a government payment.

What are some examples of false claims in healthcare?

Common examples of false claims in healthcare involve billing government or private insurance programs for services, equipment, or diagnoses that were never provided or falsified.

You can review a broader overview of illegal billing practices through False Claims Examples - The Anti.

Common Types of False Healthcare Claims

  • Phantom Billing: Submitting bills for medical visits, tests, or supplies that a patient never actually received.
  • Upcoding: Charging insurance for a more expensive, complex service or a higher level of care than what was actually performed.
  • Unbundling: Breaking a single medical procedure down into separate, individual billing codes to falsely increase the total payout.
  • Medically Unnecessary Services: Performing and billing for diagnostic tests, surgeries, or treatments that a patient does not need.
  • Kickbacks: Accepting or paying money to induce patient referrals, which then leads to fraudulent or unnecessary claims submitted to federal programs like Medicare.
  • Double Billing: Submitting multiple claims for the exact same service to an insurer, Medicaid, or the patient.

What are some famous False Claims Act cases?

Famous False Claims Act (FCA) cases involve major corporate settlements, particularly in the pharmaceutical and healthcare industries, where whistleblowers (qui tam relators) exposed systemic fraud against government programs like Medicare and Medicaid.

Some of the most notable cases include:

GlaxoSmithKline ($3 Billion)

  • Year: 2012
  • Details: Drug maker GlaxoSmithKline pleaded guilty and agreed to pay $3 billion to resolve violations. The company marketed antidepressants Paxil and Wellbutrin for unapproved uses and failed to report critical safety data regarding its diabetes medication Avandia.

Pfizer ($2.3 Billion)

  • Year: 2009
  • Details: Pharmaceutical giant Pfizer settled with the Department of Justice for $2.3 billion to resolve whistleblower lawsuits. The case targeted the off-label marketing of drugs like Bextra, Geodon, Zyvox, and Lyrica, alongside illegal kickbacks offered to doctors to induce prescriptions.

Tenet Healthcare ($900 Million / Historical Impact)

  • Details: Tenet Healthcare Corp has faced multiple major FCA actions over the years, including massive state and federal settlements involving physician kickback allegations regarding improper financial arrangements and referrals.

General Electric ($3.5 Million / Landmark Qui Tam Revival)

  • Year: 1984
  • Details: A historic whistleblower lawsuit alleged that GE defrauded the Department of Defense by misallocating and falsely billing for jet engine work. This case catalyzed major 1986 amendments to modernize and strengthen the federal False Claims Act, empowering modern qui tam whistleblowers.

False Claims Act

9 related questions found

What are examples of false claims?

A false claim is a fraudulent request or demand for government money, property, or services based on lies or material misrepresentations. Under the federal False Claims Act, these violations defraud taxpayers and waste public funds.

Common Examples of False Claims

  • Billing for unprovided services: Charging the government for medical appointments, tests, or construction work that never actually took place.
  • Double billing: Charging the government more than once for the exact same goods, services, or medical procedures.
  • Upcoding: Inaccurately coding a medical procedure or level of service to a higher-cost category to receive a larger Medicare or Medicaid reimbursement.
  • Substandard goods or materials: Promising high-quality equipment or safe materials for defense or public projects, but secretly using cheap or defective substitutes.
  • Kickbacks and referral bribes: Paying or accepting cash, gifts, or bonuses in exchange for patient or contractor referrals in federal healthcare programs.
  • False certifications: Lying about meeting legal, safety, or licensing requirements (such as employing unlicensed nurses) just to keep getting government contract payments.
  • Reverse false claims: Using false records or hiding information to illegally avoid paying money owed back to the government.

You can learn more about how the government recovers funds through the Department of Justice portal. You can also review specific False Claims Examples from the Taxpayers Against Fraud organization.

How successful are False Claims Act cases?

False Claims Act (FCA) cases are exceptionally successful when the Department of Justice (DOJ) intervenes, driving billions in annual recoveries.

📊 Overview of Success and Recoveries

  • Record Collections: Exceeded $6.8 billion in settlements and judgments in fiscal year 2025.
  • Whistleblower Driven: Relators initiated 1,297 qui tam suits out of 1,698 total FCA filings in 2025.
  • High Intervention Impact: Cases boast significantly higher success rates when the government chooses to intervene.
  • Total Historical Yield: Over $85 billion recovered between 1986 and 2025.

📈 Intervention and Win Rates

  • Government Intervention: The DOJ joins or takes over a fraction of filed qui tam suits, which heavily increases the likelihood of a settlement or favorable judgment.
  • Non-Intervened Suits: Whistleblowers may proceed independently, though success rates drop sharply without government backing.
  • Financial Leverage: The Act permits triple (treble) damages, forcing defendants into high-stakes settlements.

💡 Whistleblower Incentives

  • Reward Share: Successful relators receive between 15% and 30% of the total recovered proceeds.
  • Historical Payouts: Whistleblowers have earned over $9 billion since 1986 for exposing fraud.

What is another word for false claim?

Another word for a false claim is an unfounded assertion, fabrication, or fallacy.

Common Synonyms

  • Fabrication: Something made up or invented that is not true.
  • Baseless statement: An assertion that has no facts or proof to back it up.
  • Fallacy: A mistaken belief or a false idea based on flawed reasoning.
  • Pretense: A false show or attempt to make something seem true when it is not.
  • Misrepresentation: A false or misleading statement meant to deceive.

You can look up more related terms and phrases on Power Thesaurus.

What happens if someone makes a false claim?

When someone makes a false allegation, they can face severe legal, financial, and criminal consequences if proven that they lied intentionally.

If you are dealing with this situation, read guidance from the Innocence Legal Team on protecting your rights, or explore options for handling False Accusations via the NYC Bar.

Criminal Consequences for the Accuser

  • Filing a False Report: Lying to law enforcement or emergency services is a crime, often categorized as a misdemeanor or felony depending on the severity of the alleged offense.
  • Perjury: If the accuser lied under oath, in an affidavit, or during court testimony, they can be prosecuted for perjury, which carries heavy fines and potential prison time.
  • Perverting the Course of Justice: Intentionally trying to frame someone or manipulate an investigation can lead to major criminal charges against the accuser.

Civil Recourse for the Falsely Accused

  • Defamation (Libel or Slander): If the false claims are published or spoken to third parties and damage your reputation, you can sue for defamation.
  • Malicious Prosecution: If the accuser filed official legal or criminal charges knowing you were innocent and the case was dismissed in your favor, you can sue for malicious prosecution.
  • Emotional Distress: You may seek damages if the false accusations were extreme and caused severe mental anguish or financial ruin.

What actions are considered under the False Claims Act?

The False Claims Act (31 U.S.C. §§ 3729–3733) prohibits knowingly submitting, or causing to be submitted, false or fraudulent claims, records, or statements to the federal government to get money or property approved or paid.

Prohibited Actions and Violations

The False Claims Act covers several specific types of fraudulent conduct against government programs and contracts:

  • Submitting False Claims: Charging the government more than the actual cost of goods or services provided, or billing for items that were never delivered or performed.
  • Using False Records or Statements: Making or using a false record or statement to get a false claim paid or approved by the government.
  • Providing Substandard Goods or Services: Requesting payment for items or services that are defective, of lower quality, or fail to meet contractual or regulatory standards.
  • Fraudulent Certifications: Submitting a claim that falsely certifies compliance with a statute, contract provision, or regulatory requirement. This includes express certifications (explicitly stating compliance) and implied certifications (submitting a claim while violating a fundamental rule tied to payment).
  • Healthcare Billing Fraud: Engaging in "upcoding" (billing for a more expensive procedure than what was done), "unbundling" (billing individual components separately instead of as a bundled package), or providing medically unnecessary services billed to Medicare or Medicaid.
  • Reverse False Claims: Knowingly making or using a false record or statement to conceal, avoid, or decrease an obligation to pay or transmit money back to the government.
  • Conspiracy: Conspiring with others to violate the False Claims Act, such as plotting with vendors or providers to defraud federal programs.

The Standard of Knowledge ("Scienter")

To violate the law, a person does not need to have actual intent to defraud. Liability applies when someone acts "knowingly," which includes:

  • Having actual knowledge of the falsity of the information.
  • Acting in deliberate ignorance of the truth or falsity of the information.
  • Acting in reckless disregard of the truth or falsity of the information.