What are the benefits of Costco car insurance?
Costco car insurance, provided through CONNECT by American Family Insurance, offers exclusive member discounts and unique perks.
Key Member Benefits & Perks
- Exclusive Member Discounts: Save on auto insurance simply by providing your Costco membership number.
- Glass Repair Deductible Waiver: Deductibles are waived if a damaged windshield can be repaired instead of fully replaced.
- Additional Savings: Qualify for multi-vehicle discounts, bundling (home, renters, or umbrella), defensive driver courses, good student rates, and vehicle safety feature discounts.
- 24/7 Claims & Support: Access round-the-clock claims reporting online or via phone.
Executive Member Perks
If you hold a Costco Executive Membership, policies often include extra benefits at no additional cost:
- 24-Hour Roadside Assistance: Covers flat tires, dead batteries, and emergency fuel delivery.
- Lifetime Renewability: Ensures your policy can always be renewed as long as you maintain your Executive status and meet basic eligibility rules (exclusions apply in certain states).
Important Limitations
- Availability: Not available in Alaska, Maine, North Dakota, Rhode Island, West Virginia, and Wyoming.
- New Policies Paused: The insurer is currently not writing new auto policies in states like California and Florida.
- Membership Requirement: You must be an active Costco member to purchase or hold a policy.
Most users on Reddit agree that the bundling and Executive member perks offer great value, though availability and exact savings heavily depend on your driving history and location.
Is Costco car insurance worth getting?
Costco car insurance can be worth getting if you have a clean driving record, good credit, and want competitive rates on full coverage.
The insurance is offered through American Family Insurance (via the CONNECT program) in 43 states, providing exclusive member discounts and unique perks. However, it may not be ideal for everyone.
The Pros
- Lower Average Rates: Many members with clean records report saving money compared to traditional providers.
- Executive Perks: Executive members get added benefits like complimentary 24-hour roadside assistance and lifetime renewability (which prevents unexpected cancellations after an accident, though unavailable in CA, MD, or MI).
- Extra Benefits: All policies include a glass repair deductible waiver for windshield fixes and road trip accident accommodation.
The Cons
- Limited Features: There is no official mobile app for managing policies, and options like rideshare endorsements or usage-based tracking programs are missing.
- Strict Eligibility: High-risk drivers, those with recent DUIs, or drivers with poor credit scores often face high premiums or denied coverage.
- Mixed Support: Customer service and claims handling experiences vary widely by state, and some users report difficulties during major claim events.
What are people saying about Costco Connect car insurance?
People share mixed reviews about CONNECT by American Family Insurance, the auto insurance partner for Costco members, highlighting competitive initial pricing and helpful customer service alongside steep rate hikes and higher-than-average regulatory complaints.
What People Like
- Lower Initial Rates: Many drivers report finding initial quotes that beat competitors like Progressive or State Farm. Full-coverage averages around $183 per month, which sits roughly 10% below the national average.
- Executive Member Perks: Customers appreciate exclusive benefits for Executive Members, such as free roadside assistance, accident forgiveness after three clean years, and a lifetime renewability option that prevents unexpected cancellations after claims.
- Helpful Service Adjusters: Online reviewers frequently praise individual claims adjusters and customer service agents for being professional, communicative, and friendly.
Common Complaints and Downsides
- Significant Premium Jumps: Opinions on Facebook groups and forums note that while initial pricing is great, premiums often jump significantly after the first year.
- Higher Complaint Volume: According to an analysis by NerdWallet, policyholders submit more complaints to state regulators than expected for an insurer of this size.
- Strict Eligibility: The company tailors its pricing toward low-risk preferred drivers, meaning those with recent violations or claims often face high rates or lack of availability. It is also unavailable in certain states or regions (like new policies in California).
Do you really save money with the Costco Auto Program?
Yes, the Costco Auto Program can save you money, but it does not always guarantee the absolute lowest price compared to aggressive, independent negotiation.
How the Savings Work
- Prearranged pricing: You get a set, low-stress member price through an approved dealer, avoiding standard showroom markups and high-pressure haggling.
- Stackable incentives: You can combine the prearranged price with public manufacturer rebates and limited-time member promotions (which often range from $1,000 to $3,000 off select models).
- Service discounts: Members receive 15% off parts, service, and accessories (up to $500 per visit) at participating service centers.
The Catch
- Dealer add-ons: Dealerships can still try to tack on extra fees, accessories, or add-ons that eat into your savings unless you inspect the final out-the-door price.
- Limited dealer network: The program works with only one designated participating dealer per brand in a given geographic area, meaning you cannot easily pit local competing dealers of the same brand against each other.
- Negotiation power: A skilled negotiator who collects competing quotes from multiple independent dealerships can sometimes beat the set Costco price.
What company does Costco use for car insurance?
Costco uses CONNECT, which is powered and underwritten by American Family Insurance (formerly Ameriprise Auto & Home), to provide car insurance to its members.
Key Details About Costco Car Insurance
- Underwriter: Policies are officially underwritten by American Family Connect Property and Casualty Insurance Company, American Family Connect Insurance Company, or Midvale Indemnity Company.
- Membership Requirement: You must be an active Costco member to purchase or maintain a policy.
- Executive Perks: Executive members get extra benefits like roadside assistance, home lockout assistance, and lifetime renewability.
- Availability: Coverage is offered in most U.S. states, though availability and specific underwriting companies vary by location.
You can check rates or request a policy directly through the American Family Insurance Costco Portal.
Should You Get Auto Insurance Through Costco?
Is Costco car insurance better than Progressive?
Costco auto insurance (provided via CONNECT by American Family) often provides lower full-coverage rates for drivers with clean records, while Progressive offers more robust policy customization, tool features, and wider state availability.
Cost and Pricing
- Costco (CONNECT): Tends to offer competitive full-coverage rates that average below national benchmarks, but minimum-coverage policies can be relatively pricey.
- Progressive: Pricing varies heavily by driver profile, but it frequently scores better for diverse discount varieties and feature flexibility.
Coverage and Perks
- Costco (CONNECT): Exclusive to members. Executive Members get unique perks like lifetime renewability and free roadside assistance. However, it lacks options like gap insurance or rideshare coverage, and is not active or writing new policies in certain states (including California and Florida).
- Progressive: Offers extensive policy add-ons (like rideshare, gap coverage, and custom parts value) alongside the Name Your Price tool and robust mobile app management.
What not to tell your insurance company?
Never admit fault, apologize, or downplay your injuries when speaking to an insurance adjuster after an accident.
Statements to Avoid
- "I'm sorry" or "It was my fault": Insurers treat apologies as a legal admission of liability, which can reduce or eliminate your compensation.
- "I'm fine" or "I'm not hurt": Adrenaline can mask severe conditions like internal bleeding or traumatic brain injuries that appear days later. Early statements that you are fine are used to deny later claims.
- Guesses or speculation: Never estimate speeds, distances, or timing. Stick strictly to objective facts you know for certain.
- Recorded statements: You can decline requests for a recorded interview until you consult legal counsel, as adjusters use these recordings to trap you in inconsistencies.
Safe Communication Guidelines
- Provide only basic facts like the date, time, location, and your contact or policy details.
- Refer the adjuster to a qualified Car Accident Lawyer to manage further discussions and protect your rights.
How much does Costco car insurance cost?
The average cost of Costco car insurance (underwritten by CONNECT, powered by American Family Insurance) is roughly $183 per month for full coverage and $79 per month for minimum coverage.
Because rates are highly individualized, actual premiums vary significantly depending on your driving history, location, age, and vehicle type. Costco members save an average of $587 when switching to CONNECT.
Costco Car Insurance Cost Breakdown
| Coverage Type | Average Monthly Premium | Average Annual Premium | Compared to National Average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum Coverage | $79 | ~$948 | ~29% higher than national average ($61) |
| Full Coverage | $183 | ~$2,196 | ~10% lower than national average ($203) |
How Driving History Affects Costco Rates
Costco's insurance plans are generally tailored for "preferred risk" drivers (those with clean records). If you have violations on your record, monthly premiums will increase:
- Clean Record: ~$67 to $79 per month
- Speeding Ticket: ~$282 per month
- At-Fault Accident: ~$288 per month
- DUI Conviction: ~$320 per month
Membership Perks & Discounts
You must have an active Costco Membership to purchase a policy and receive the associated price breaks.
- Gold Star Members ($65/year): Receive an exclusive member premium discount.
- Executive Members ($130/year): Receive the premium discount plus free major perks, including roadside assistance (up to $75 per occurrence) and lifetime renewability (meaning the policy cannot be canceled due to multiple claims or minor accidents).
- Additional Discounts: CONNECT offers standard discounts for bundling with homeowners/renters insurance, completing defensive driving courses, maintaining good grades (for students), and having vehicle safety features.
Note: CONNECT auto insurance is currently available in most states, but availability varies by region (for example, it is not accepting new customers in California).
Does Costco provide good insurance?
Costco insurance—provided through CONNECT, powered by American Family Insurance—earns mixed reviews, offering strong member discounts and Executive perks alongside complaints about rate hikes and higher-than-average regulatory complaints.
The Pros
- Competitive Pricing: Full-coverage auto insurance averages about $183 per month, which is roughly 10% below the national average.
- Executive Member Perks: Executive members get extra benefits like lifetime renewability (policies cannot be unexpectedly canceled after claims in most states) and free roadside assistance.
- Financial Strength: Underwriter American Family holds an A (Excellent) financial strength rating from A.M. Best, meaning it has a solid ability to pay out major claims.
- Discounts: Multiple savings options are available for bundling policies, safe driving, good students, and safety features.
The Cons
- Mixed Customer Satisfaction: User forums and review platforms show divided experiences; some praise initial savings, while user discussions on platforms like Reddit highlight frustration over sharp premium increases after the first year or difficulties managing claims.
- Higher Complaint Index: National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) data shows the underwriting company receives more consumer complaints than expected for an insurer of its size.
- Limited Availability: Auto and home policies are unavailable in several states (such as AK, ME, ND, RI, WV, and WY), and new policies are restricted in states like CA and FL.
- Fewer Digital Tools: The provider lacks a dedicated, highly rated mobile app, meaning policy management is mostly handled via phone or website.
Is $200 a month expensive for car insurance?
Paying $200 a month for car insurance is right around the national average for full coverage, but it is considered expensive if you only carry basic minimum liability.
When $200 a Month is Reasonable
- Full Coverage: The nationwide average for full coverage is roughly $194 to $209 a month.
- Higher-Risk Profiles: It is a normal or good rate if you are a younger driver, live in a crowded city or high-risk weather area, drive a new car, or have a minor blemish on your driving record.
When $200 a Month is Too Expensive
- Minimum Coverage: State minimum liability coverage typically averages $56 to $61 per month. Paying $200 for basic liability means you are overpaying.
- Clean Record and Old Car: If you drive an older vehicle that is paid off and have a clean driving history in a low-cost state (like Idaho or Vermont), $200 a month is too high.
As noted in a discussion on Reddit Personal Finance, a common consensus for lowering a high monthly bill is to increase your deductible if you can afford the out-of-pocket cost during a claim. You can also CNBC for more context on regional rate differences.