What are the disadvantages of Medigap Plan N?

Editorial team Published on

Medigap Plan N requires out-of-pocket cost-sharing for doctor visits, emergency room copays, and leaves you responsible for Part B excess charges and the annual Part B deductible.

⚠️ Key Disadvantages of Medigap Plan N

  • 🏥 Office Visit Copayments: You pay up to $20 for certain doctor office visits.
  • 🚑 Emergency Room Copays: You pay up to $50 for ER visits if you are not admitted as an inpatient.
  • 📈 Part B Excess Charges: You must pay any excess charges if a doctor does not accept Medicare assignment (up to 15% above the approved amount). (Note: Excess charges are banned in CT, MA, MN, NY, OH, PA, RI, and VT).
  • 📅 Part B Deductible: You must pay the annual Medicare Part B deductible ($283 in 2026) out of pocket before coverage begins.
  • 💊 No Extra Benefits: Like most Medigap policies, it does not cover prescription drugs (Part D), vision, dental, or hearing care.

Is Medigap plan N worth it?

Medigap Plan N is generally worth it if you want lower monthly premiums and do not visit the doctor frequently enough for copays to outweigh those savings.

📊 Plan N vs. Plan G Comparison

Feature✅ Medigap Plan N📌 Medigap Plan G
Monthly PremiumLower ($20–$50 less)Higher
Part B Deductible ($283 in 2026)Out-of-pocketOut-of-pocket
Office Visit CopayUp to $20$0 (Covered)
ER Visit CopayUp to $50$0 (Covered)
Excess ChargesNot coveredCovered

✅ When Plan N Is Worth It

  • < 20 doctor visits per year (savings beat $20 copays)
  • Living in a state banning excess charges (CT, MA, MN, NY, OH, PA, RI, VT)
  • Using providers who accept Medicare assignment

⚠️ When Plan N Is Not Worth It

  • Frequent or unpredictable medical appointments
  • Preference for zero surprise bills or copays at checkout
  • Using doctors who routinely add Part B excess charges

Which is better, Medicare plan G or plan N?

Neither Plan G nor Plan N is universally "better"; Plan G offers total cost predictability with higher monthly premiums, while Plan N offers lower monthly premiums in exchange for small copays and no coverage for excess charges.

Key Differences

  • Monthly Premium: Plan G costs more each month, while Plan N costs roughly $20 to $50 less per month.
  • Doctor and ER Copays: Plan G has zero copays after you meet your deductible. Plan N requires up to a $20 copay for office visits and up to a $50 copay for emergency room visits (if you are not admitted).
  • Part B Excess Charges: Plan G covers Part B excess charges (extra fees a doctor can charge above Medicare's approved amount). Plan N does not cover excess charges, though these are rare and illegal in some states.
  • Part B Deductible: Both plans require you to pay the annual Medicare Part B deductible ($283 in 2026) out of pocket before coverage starts.

Which One Should You Choose?

  • Choose Plan G if: You visit the doctor often, want complete peace of mind, and prefer not to worry about individual visit copays or unexpected extra fees.
  • Choose Plan N if: You are generally healthy, don't visit the doctor often, and want to pocket the monthly premium savings.

Which Medigap plan N is best?

Medigap Plan N is best if you want lower monthly premiums than Plan G and do not mind paying small copayments for certain visits.

Coverage and Costs

  • Monthly Premiums: Plan N costs less each month than Plan G.
  • Deductibles: You must pay the Medicare Part B deductible ($283 in 2026) out of pocket.
  • Copayments: You pay up to $20 for some doctor visits and up to $50 for emergency room visits that do not lead to an inpatient admission.
  • Excess Charges: Plan N does not cover Part B excess charges (extra fees some doctors charge above the Medicare-approved amount). However, these fees are rare and illegal in some states.

Top Insurance Companies

Top-rated providers for Medigap policies include State Farm for slow price increases, HealthSpring (formerly Cigna) for low rates, and AARP/UnitedHealthcare for wide availability.

Should I switch from plan G to plan N?

Switching from Medicare Plan G to Plan N can lower your monthly premium, but you must pass medical underwriting in most states and risk out-of-pocket copays and excess charges.

The Medicare Family outlines the real trade-off between predictable costs and lower fixed monthly payments. Opinions are mixed on Reddit, where some users note large savings while others warn about excess charges.

Key Differences in Costs and Coverage

  • Monthly Premiums: Plan N costs about $30 to $50 less per month than Plan G.
  • Copayments: Plan N requires up to a $20 copay for doctor office visits and up to $50 for emergency room visits. Plan G has zero copays.
  • Excess Charges: Plan G covers Part B excess charges (extra amounts doctors can charge above Medicare-approved limits). Plan N does not cover them.
  • State Rules: Eight states—Connecticut, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, and Vermont—ban excess charges entirely, making Plan N more attractive there.

Important Rules for Switching

  • Medical Underwriting: You must answer health questions to switch in most states, meaning an insurer can deny you if you have health issues.
  • Keep Current Plan: Never cancel your Plan G coverage until your new Plan N policy is officially approved and active.

As outlined by Senior65, you should compare total annual savings against your expected doctor visits before applying.

Does Medicare Supplement Plan N Stand Up to Plan G? | Pros and Cons of a Medicare Supplement Plan N

9 related questions found

What does Plan N not cover?

Medicare Supplement Plan N does not cover several out-of-pocket medical costs, including deductibles, excess charges, and routine non-medical care.

Out-of-Pocket Costs Not Covered

  • Medicare Part B deductible: You must pay this annual deductible yourself ($283 in 2026) before the plan starts paying for Part B services.
  • Part B excess charges: If a doctor does not accept Medicare assignment, they can charge up to 15% more than the approved amount, and Plan N leaves you to pay this extra fee.
  • Office and ER copayments: You must pay up to a $20 copay for certain doctor visits and up to a $50 copay for emergency room visits that do not lead to an inpatient hospital stay.

General Exclusions (Not Covered by Any Medigap Plan)

  • Prescription drugs: You need a separate Medicare Part D plan for medications.
  • Routine dental, vision, and hearing: This includes cleanings, glasses, contacts, and hearing aids.
  • Long-term care: Extended nursing home care or personal home assistance is not included.

Can I switch from Plan N to Plan G without underwriting?

Switching from Medigap Plan N to Plan G generally requires medical underwriting in most states.

Plan N has fewer out-of-pocket benefits (copays and no coverage for Part B excess charges) compared to Plan G. Upgrading to a more comprehensive plan like Plan G usually means you must answer health history questions and get approval from the insurance company.

When You Can Switch Without Underwriting

You can switch without medical underwriting only in specific situations:

  • Your Initial Open Enrollment Period: If you are within your first 6-month window of enrolling in Medicare Part B, you can pick any plan with no health questions.
  • Guaranteed Issue Rights: If you experience specific qualifying events—such as losing secondary employer coverage or your Medicare Advantage plan leaving your area—you have a guaranteed right to buy a policy.
  • State-Specific Rules: A few states have unique laws. For example, Washington state allows you to switch between Medigap plans without health questions. States with continuous year-round open enrollment or specific "birthday rules" (like New York, Connecticut, Massachusetts, and others) may also let you switch without underwriting depending on local guidelines.

Opinions and rules on upgrading without underwriting vary by carrier and state regulations, as discussed on platforms like Reddit. You can learn more about general eligibility guidelines through Boomer Benefits or check details via Kiplinger.

How much does Medicare Plan N cost per month?

The monthly premium for a Medicare Supplement Plan N (Medigap) generally ranges between $100 and $180 per month for an individual turning 65. However, because these policies are sold by private insurance companies, prices vary widely based on your specific age, location, gender, tobacco use, and the carrier you choose. Depending on these factors, national premium ranges can span from as low as $60 to over $400 per month.

Because Plan N benefits are completely standardized by the government, a Plan N from one insurance company provides the exact same medical coverage as a Plan N from another company—meaning you can shop primarily based on price and company reputation.

Factors Influencing Your Plan N Premium

  • Location: Premiums differ heavily by state and ZIP code. For example, a 65-year-old might find plans starting around $95–$175 in Texas, while the same plan in New York could range from $220 to $400 per month due to different state-level pricing laws.
  • Age-Pricing Structure: Insurance companies price plans using one of three methods, which determines how your premium changes over time:
    • Community-rated: Everyone in the same area pays the same premium regardless of age.
    • Issue-age-rated: The premium is based on the age you are when you buy the policy; it will not increase just because you get older.
    • Attained-age-rated: The premium starts lower but increases automatically as you age.
  • Discounts: Many carriers offer rate reductions for non-smokers, women, multi-policy holders, or household members living together.

Additional Out-of-Pocket Costs for Plan N

While Plan N is known for having a lower monthly premium than Plan G, it requires you to pay small out-of-pocket amounts when you receive care:

  • Part B Deductible: You must pay the annual Medicare Part B deductible ($283) out of pocket before the plan begins covering your outpatient services.
  • Office Visit Copays: You will pay up to $20 for certain doctor's office visits.
  • Emergency Room Copays: You will pay up to $50 for emergency room visits if you are not admitted to the hospital as an inpatient.
  • Part B Excess Charges: Plan N does not cover Part B "excess charges" (up to an extra 15% a provider can charge if they do not accept Medicare assignment). Note: Excess charges are rare and completely banned by law in Connecticut, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, and Vermont.

Do doctors prefer Medicare Advantage or Medigap?

Most doctors strongly prefer Medigap (Medicare Supplement) over Medicare Advantage because Medigap works directly with Original Medicare, avoiding private insurance red tape.

Why Doctors Prefer Medigap

  • Fewer paperwork delays: Medigap pairs with Original Medicare, meaning doctors bill one central system and receive automatic secondary payments.
  • No prior authorizations: Medigap plans do not require pre-approval from private insurance companies to deliver necessary medical treatments.
  • Zero network restrictions: Patients can see any doctor or specialist nationwide as long as they accept Original Medicare.

Why Doctors Dislike Medicare Advantage

  • Administrative burdens: Medicare Advantage plans are run by private insurers with varying rules, billing portals, and payment schedules.
  • Prior authorization friction: Studies from groups like the American Medical Association show that a vast majority of physicians feel Advantage prior authorization rules delay care and frustrate clinic staff.
  • Care denials: Private insurers often deny or delay coverage for specific treatments, forcing doctor offices to spend valuable time fighting appeals.

Which Medicare Part G plans are the best?

State Farm, AARP/UnitedHealthcare, and Cigna (HealthSpring) are rated as the top providers for Medicare Supplement Plan G.

Because federal law standardizes Medigap plans, every company's Plan G covers the exact same medical costs. This includes all Original Medicare Part A and Part B out-of-pocket costs, except for the annual Part B deductible.

The best choice depends on pricing, customer service, and discounts in your area. You can review detailed market analysis on NerdWallet or compare broader carrier overviews at MedicareGuide.com.

Top-Rated Plan G Providers

  • State Farm (Best Overall):
    • Known for very low customer complaint rates.
    • Features slow, steady year-over-year price increases.
  • AARP / UnitedHealthcare (Best Availability):
    • The largest Medigap insurer in the United States.
    • Available nationwide with top-tier digital tools and stable member support.
  • Cigna / HealthSpring (Best for Low Prices):
    • Offers some of the lowest average monthly premiums and stacking discount programs.
    • Tends to have slightly higher member complaint volumes than State Farm.
  • Mutual of Omaha (Best for Discounts):
    • Offers generous household discounts if multiple people in a home enroll.
    • Provides widely available high-deductible Plan G options.

How to Choose the Right Plan

  • Check your ZIP code: Rates vary drastically depending on where you live.
  • Get multiple quotes: Ask for rates from at least three different carriers.
  • Look at rate history: Ask an agent how much a company typically raises its rates each year as you age.