What auto insurance has gap coverage?

Editorial team Published on

Many major auto insurance companies offer gap insurance or a similar loan/lease payoff endorsement as an optional add-on to comprehensive and collision coverage.

✅ Major Insurers That Offer Gap Coverage

  • State Farm: Offers true gap insurance as an affordable policy endorsement.
  • Travelers: Provides loan/lease payoff coverage for original owners purchasing through new car dealers.
  • Nationwide: Offers optional loan/lease gap coverage add-ons.
  • Allstate: Provides optional loan/lease gap coverage for new vehicles.
  • Liberty Mutual: Offers gap coverage for original owners with a financed vehicle.
  • Amica & USAA: Both provide gap protection/loan coverage options (USAA restricted to military members).

⚠️ Important Alternative: Progressive's Capped Payoff

  • Progressive: Does not offer traditional unlimited gap insurance.
  • Instead, they offer Loan/Lease Payoff coverage, which limits the payout to a maximum of 25% of your vehicle's actual cash value.

❌ Insurers That Do NOT Offer Gap Coverage

  • GEICO does not offer gap insurance in most regions.
  • Country Financial and Bristol West do not provide gap endorsements.

💡 Requirements & Tips

  • Prerequisite: You must carry physical damage protection (comprehensive and collision coverage) on your policy to qualify.
  • Cost: Buying gap coverage through your insurance carrier typically costs only $2 to $5 a month—significantly cheaper than rolling a $500–$700 flat fee into a dealership financing contract.

Can I purchase just gap insurance by itself?

Yes, you can purchase gap insurance by itself through third-party providers or lenders, but traditional auto insurance companies generally require you to have comprehensive and collision coverage with them to add it.

Where to Buy Standalone Gap Insurance

  • Third-Party Providers: Specialty online and stand-alone companies (such as AutoPay) sell gap coverage as a completely separate product.
  • Lenders or Credit Unions: Banks and credit unions often sell gap insurance directly to their auto loan customers outside of an auto insurance policy.
  • Car Dealerships: You can buy gap coverage at the dealership when you purchase or lease your vehicle. However, this is typically the most expensive option.

Limitations of Traditional Insurers

  • If you want to buy gap insurance through a standard auto insurance company (like Progressive, State Farm, or Allstate), they almost always require you to hold active comprehensive and collision coverages on that same policy.
  • You generally cannot buy a standalone gap-only policy from a standard auto insurance carrier if your main car insurance is held elsewhere.

What is the best gap insurance to have?

The best gap insurance type is Vehicle Replacement GAP for new cars if you worry about rising replacement costs, while Return to Invoice (RTI) GAP is the best overall value for balancing cost and protection.

Best Types of GAP Insurance

  • Vehicle Replacement GAP: Covers the difference to buy a brand-new equivalent today if replacement prices go up.
  • Return to Invoice (RTI) / Back to Invoice: Pays the difference between your insurer's payout and your original purchase price or outstanding finance.
  • Contract Hire / Lease GAP: Covers remaining payments on a leased vehicle when you do not own the car.

Where to Buy

  • Standalone Providers: Buying online from specialized independent providers like ALA Insurance or Total Loss Gap is usually much cheaper than buying from a car dealership.
  • Auto Insurers: Adding loan/lease gap coverage directly onto your primary auto insurance policy (through carriers like Travelers or Progressive) is often convenient and affordable.

Learn more about your options with MoneySavingExpert's Gap Insurance Guide or read a detailed explanation on Which? Gap Insurance.

Is gap insurance actually worth it?

Gap insurance is worth it if you owe more on your car loan or lease than the vehicle is currently worth.

When Gap Insurance is Worth It

  • Small down payment: You put down less than 20% when buying the vehicle.
  • Long loan terms: Your financing stretches past 60 months, meaning you pay down the principal slower than the car depreciates.
  • Fast depreciation: You drive a brand-new car or a make and model that loses value quickly.
  • Leased vehicles: Most leasing companies require you to carry gap coverage.
  • High mileage: You drive significantly more than the average annual mileage, reducing the car's value faster.

When to Skip Gap Insurance

  • Positive equity: You paid cash or made a large down payment, so your car's market value is higher than your remaining loan balance.
  • Paid-off loans: You do not have an active auto loan or lease.
  • Low-value vehicle: The remaining loan balance and the actual cash value are very close.

Cost Comparison

  • Through your auto insurer: Typically costs around $20 to $60 per year as an add-on policy.
  • Through a car dealer or lender: Often sold as a flat fee or waiver ranging from $500 to $700 upfront.

How much should gap insurance cost on a car?

Gap insurance typically costs between $20 and $100 per year if added through your auto insurance provider, but ranges from $400 to $1,000+ if bought upfront from a dealership.

Cost by Purchase Option

  • Through your auto insurer: $20 to $100 per year (about $2 to $10 per month) when added to an existing comprehensive and collision policy. Some insurers price it as 5% to 6% of your collision and comprehensive premium.
  • Through a credit union or bank: $200 to $500 as a one-time flat fee.
  • Through a car dealership: $400 to $1,000+ as a one-time lump sum. If you roll this fee into your auto loan, you will also pay extra interest on it over time.

Key Factors That Affect Price

  • Where you buy it: Dealerships charge significantly more due to markups and commissions, while standard auto insurance companies offer the lowest rates.
  • Vehicle depreciation: Cars that lose value very fast increase the risk and potential payout gap.
  • Loan terms: Larger loan amounts, little to no down payment, or rolling negative equity from an old trade-in into a new loan can increase your exposure and overall loan risk.

Understanding Auto Insurance: What’s Gap Insurance?

9 related questions found

What are the downsides of gap insurance?

Gap insurance adds an extra ongoing or upfront expense for coverage that applies only under narrow, specific circumstances.

Coverage Limitations

  • Total loss only: It pays out only if your vehicle is declared a total loss or stolen and unrecovered. It provides zero funds for vehicle repairs, mechanical breakdowns, or routine maintenance.
  • Prerequisite rules: You typically must purchase comprehensive and collision coverage on your auto policy to even qualify for gap insurance.
  • Exclusions: Many policies do not cover your standard insurance deductible, late fees, or past rolled-over loan balances from previous vehicles.

Financial Drawbacks

  • Added costs: Even though adding it through a traditional insurer is relatively cheap, it still raises your total cost of ownership. Buying it directly at a car dealership can cost significantly more ($500 to $700+) than through an insurance carrier.
  • Interest accumulation: If you fold a dealership's flat-fee gap waiver into your auto loan, you end up paying interest on that fee over the life of the loan.
  • Temporary usefulness: Once your remaining loan balance drops below the actual cash value of your car, the coverage becomes completely redundant and useless, meaning you are paying for protection you no longer need.
  • Difficulty canceling: If bundled directly into a financing contract or lease, coverage may continue if you forget to actively request a cancellation.

Is it better to buy gap insurance from the dealer or insurance company?

Buying gap insurance from an auto insurance company is generally better and much cheaper than buying it from a car dealership.

Cost Comparison

  • Insurance Company: Usually costs about $20 to $60 a year (or adds a few dollars to your monthly bill). You can easily cancel it when you pay down your loan and no longer need it.
  • Dealership: Usually costs a flat fee of $500 to $900. If you roll this fee into your car loan, you will also pay extra interest on it over time.

Pros and Cons

Insurance Company Option

  • Pros: Lower overall cost, easy to cancel, and added directly to your existing policy.
  • Cons: Not all auto insurers offer gap coverage, and some have strict rules about vehicle age or when you must add it.

Dealership Option

  • Pros: Convenient to buy during financing, and sometimes covers your insurance deductible or higher claim limits.
  • Cons: Much more expensive, harder to cancel, and increases your loan balance if financed.

What does Dave Ramsey say about gap insurance?

Dave Ramsey says you only need GAP Insurance if you owe more on a car loan or lease than the vehicle is actually worth.

Dave Ramsey's View on GAP Insurance

  • Ideal scenario: If you follow his advice and pay cash for a used car, you will never need gap insurance because you have no loan or lease.
  • If you already have a loan: If you are "upside-down" on a car loan (owing more than the car's depreciated book value), gap insurance protects you if the car gets totaled or stolen.
  • Mandatory coverage: If your lender or leasing company requires gap coverage, you must carry it.
  • When to drop it: Once you pay down the loan and no longer owe more than the car is worth—or if you can afford to pay off the difference out of pocket—you should drop the coverage to save money.
  • Cost tip: Ramsey notes that buying gap insurance directly through a standard auto insurance policy is much cheaper ($20–$60 a year) than rolling the cost into dealership financing.

How much does Progressive gap insurance cost per month?

Progressive's version of gap insurance, known as Loan/Lease Payoff Coverage, costs about $2 to $7 per month (or roughly $20 to $100 per year) when added to your auto insurance policy.

The exact cost varies by state and is often calculated as roughly 5% of your comprehensive and collision premiums.

Key Details About Progressive's Coverage

  • The 25% Payout Cap: Unlike traditional gap insurance that covers the entire difference between your car’s actual value and your outstanding loan, Progressive's coverage is typically capped at 25% of the vehicle’s Actual Cash Value (ACV). If you have significant negative equity or rolled an old loan balance into your new one, this cap might leave you paying some money out of pocket.
  • Prerequisites: To add this coverage, Progressive requires you to carry both comprehensive and collision coverage on the vehicle.
  • Cost Advantage: Buying this add-on through an auto insurer like Progressive is significantly cheaper than buying gap insurance from a car dealership, which usually charges a flat fee of $400 to $700 upfront that rolls into your auto loan and gathers interest.

Who is the best car insurance company right now?

Travelers is currently ranked as the best overall national car insurance company for 2026, offering an average annual rate of $1,843 with strong marks in customer satisfaction and low complaint levels.

Because the "best" choice depends on your personal situation, other top providers stand out in specific categories according to data from U.S. News and NerdWallet:

  • Best for Military & Veterans: USAA provides the highest customer satisfaction and lowest average rates ($1,491/year), though availability is strictly restricted to the military community.
  • Best for Discounts: GEICO offers competitive pricing and a wide variety of policyholder discounts with an average full coverage rate around $1,925/year.
  • Best for Add-Ons & Customization: Progressive features flexible coverage options, useful self-service mobile tools, and an average annual full coverage rate of $1,911.
  • Best for Customer Service & Claims: Amica is a favorite for high customer satisfaction and low complaint volumes, though its base rates tend to be higher than budget competitors.