What is better, total loss or repair?

Asked by: Dorothea O'Hara  |  Last update: July 30, 2025
Score: 4.9/5 (56 votes)

The only time it would be worth repairing is if it's an older vehicle with very low mileage and in great condition except for the damage caused by the accident because the actual damage may not be serious but substantial enough to total it cause the vehicle has a low resale value to begin with and therefore it doesn't ...

Is it better for a car to be totaled or repaired?

On vehicles which have bottomed out in value (under $1500) and then suffer a cosmetic damage which does not affect driveability, it may be better to have the vehicle totaled. This is especially true if you are the one at-fault.

Can you negotiate total loss payout?

Insurers will typically make an initial total loss settlement offer based on their own ACV calculation. However, policyholders can often negotiate for a higher payout. The key is for the policyholder to independently research their vehicle's worth using sites like Kelley Blue Book and NADA Guides.

How much money will I get if my car is totaled?

A typical insurance payout for a totaled car will be for its actual cash value. It's generally determined by factors such as year, make, model and mileage. Simply put, it's what your car could have been reasonably sold for before the damages.

What if the repairs are more than the estimate?

What happens when the amount exceeds the expected repairs? Customers cannot be charged more than the estimate given without prior written or oral consent. Unfortunately, you might have to work with the other driver's insurance company. They may agree to a specific price but refuse to pay for repairs over that amount.

Total Loss? What do I do?

24 related questions found

What if the insurance check is more than the repairs?

You can consult your policy and/or hire an attorney to help you better understand whether or not you can keep recoverable depreciation. In most cases, if the insurance check exceeds repair costs, you will need to return the extra money.

Can you negotiate a car repair estimate?

If you find out that the quote is excessive, it's time to haggle! Politely tell the auto technician about your findings and explain why you think their estimate is too high. If they don't lower the price, let them know you'll be shopping around with other mechanics.

How to get more money out of a total loss?

To get the most money from your insurance for a totaled car, research your car's value independently, document its condition with supporting records, and provide evidence for a higher payout.

How long does it take to get money for a totaled car?

If your car is totaled, you'll receive a check for its total value minus your deductible, which can help you buy a new car. It can take a few days to a month (or longer) to receive a check after a total loss settlement.

What happens if your car gets totaled and you still owe money?

Here's the bad news: if you have a loan or lease out on a totaled car, you're still responsible for paying off the remaining balance. Usually, the insurer pays the lender or leaseholder first and gives you the rest of the settlement money if there's any leftover.

What happens if you don't agree with a total loss adjuster?

Sometimes, insurance adjusters and policyholders disagree on the car's value. When you don't agree with the settlement amount, you can negotiate with your adjuster. They assess the damage and determine how your coverage applies to damages and injuries. to get a better insurance payout.

How can I maximize my insurance payout?

Document Every Detail: Keep detailed records from the initial incident to follow-up conversations. Taking photos, saving receipts, and recording interactions with the insurance adjuster will strengthen your claim. Stay Organized: Keep all claim-related documents in one place.

Can a total loss be reversed?

If the total loss claim has already been finalized and the payout issued, reversing the process is almost impossible. However, there are rare exceptions: Fraud or Mistakes: If you believe there was an error in the valuation or the claim was mishandled, you can dispute the claim.

Is it worth fixing my car after an accident?

If the cost of repairing your current vehicle is minor then there's no need to purchase a new car. However, It might cost you more to repair a car that's been heavily damaged in a collision. The initial repair might not cost as much as a new car but some cars are never the same after a major car accident.

Is it hard to insure a totaled car?

Once a car is declared a total loss, it's destined for the scrapyard — unless it's sufficiently repaired and rebuilt. If you want to insure a vehicle that's been declared a total loss, you'll first need to make sure it has a rebuilt title status — and even then, you may have limited coverage options.

Is it better to repair or replace a car?

Investing in repairs for an old vehicle may not always be the best move for your finances. Repairing an old vehicle can help you avoid high new and used car prices — and high interest rates. If you're facing expensive repairs on an older vehicle, buying a new vehicle may save you money over the long run.

Is it better to have a car totaled or repaired?

Repairing your vehicle is cheaper than taking out a loan or paying monthly payments on a brand-new vehicle. It is often in the best interest of the insurance company to total a car, so you will need to look out for your own best interests.

When a car is totaled, who gets the check?

If you own the car without any loans or liens, you will receive a check for the value assessed by the insurance company. If there is a loan, the check usually goes first to the leasing company or the lender. If you owe money on the vehicle, you should notify the lending company that your car has been totaled.

How long do I have to fix my car after a claim?

Most insurance companies don't set a strict deadline for when repairs must be completed, but they often require you to file a claim within a specific timeframe after the accident. Once your claim is approved, your coverage for vehicle repair may remain valid indefinitely, but it's a good idea not to delay repairs.

Can you negotiate a total loss amount?

Frequently Asked Questions about Total Loss Negotiations

Absolutely, negotiating a settlement offer is not only possible but often necessary to ensure you receive a fair payout. Insurance companies may initially provide a low offer, hoping you'll accept it without question.

Does a total loss affect credit?

A total loss alone won't affect your credit. However, if you still owe payments on your car, you should continue paying your loan until the claim is settled. Not paying and getting behind on payments could impact your credit.

What happens when your car is totaled but still drivable?

Rebuilt/Reconstructed Title: Once a salvage vehicle has been repaired and inspected, the California Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) will issue a "rebuilt" or "reconstructed" title for the vehicle. Once you obtain this, you can legally drive the vehicle.

At what point is it too expensive to repair a car?

When a repair estimate is provided by a mechanic, it's essential to evaluate whether the cost is reasonable in relation to the car's current market value. If the repair costs are approaching or exceeding the vehicle's worth, it may be a sign that it's too expensive to repair.

Are dealership repairs worth it?

The pros and cons of dealership service are numerous. In favor are technicians who are skilled in your brand, up-to-date repairs and methods, and manufacturer-backed warranties, while the cons include higher prices, limited parts choice and less personalized service.

How do you negotiate repairs?

7 tips for negotiating after a home inspection
  1. Hire an experienced real estate agent. ...
  2. Only focus on the major repairs. ...
  3. Opt for a credit or price reduction instead. ...
  4. Think long term. ...
  5. Provide supporting documents. ...
  6. Ask for a home warranty. ...
  7. Be reasonable.