What is the bad side of IUL?

Asked by: Norris Heller  |  Last update: July 21, 2025
Score: 4.5/5 (8 votes)

An IUL is a very bad option for retirement planning. As with any investment tied to an index fund, your returns will be mediocre at best. About the most you can expect the cash value to do is beat inflation over time—and even that's iffy.

Can you lose money in an IUL?

While you may not lose any money in the account if the index goes down, you won't earn interest. If the market turns bullish, the earnings on your IUL will not be as high as a typical investment account. The high cost of premiums and fees makes IULs expensive and considerably less affordable than term life.

Is it a bad idea to have an IUL?

Some of the drawbacks include caps on returns and no guarantees as to the premium amounts or market returns. An IUL insurance policy may be canceled if you stop paying premiums. IUL policies are generally best for those with large up-front investments who want options for a tax-free retirement.

What is the catch with IUL?

This type of life insurance offers permanent coverage as long as premiums are paid. Some of the drawbacks include possible limits on annual returns and no guarantees as to the premium amounts or future market returns. An IUL policy may be canceled if you stop paying premiums.

What is the 7 pay rule for IUL?

What Is the 7-Pay Rule for IUL? The 7-pay rule is a federal tax qualification test applied to life insurance policies, including Indexed Universal Life policies, to determine how much in policy premiums you can pay in policy premiums over its first seven years (or seven years after a material change).

This Is Why Universal Life Insurance Is CRAP!

15 related questions found

Why do rich people use IUL?

Indexed universal life (IUL) insurance offers several compelling advantages for estate planning: Large, Tax-Free Death Benefit: The money paid to your beneficiaries is generally tax-free, allowing for the efficient transfer of a greater portion of your wealth.

Can I cash out my IUL?

Can you withdraw money from your IUL Account? You have the option to borrow against your cash value through a policy loan or withdraw cash value.

Is an IUL better than a 401k?

IUL contracts protect against losses while offering some equity risk premium. IRAs and 401(k)s do not offer the same downside protection, though there is no cap on returns. IULs tend to have have complicated terms and higher fees.

Can I cancel my IUL policy?

If you have a whole life or universal life insurance policy, you can also cancel the policy at any time. You won't get back any premiums you paid for the policy, but you may receive a payout from the cash value, if one has accrued. However, bear in mind that there may be surrender fees taken from your cash value.

How much money do you need to start an IUL?

The minimum amount you need to start an IUL life insurance policy varies between insurers and depends on your chosen coverage amount and premium payment method. Annual payments for an internationally indexed universal life policy start at around US$20,000 yearly and rise to $100,000 or more in premiums.

Who has the best IUL?

The Best IUL Companies of 2024 & Why
  • IUL with the Best S&P Strategies + Guarantees: Penn Mutual.
  • IUL with the Best Company Strength: Nationwide.
  • IUL with the Widest Selection of Strategies: Allianz Life.
  • IUL with the Best Response to Rising Rates: Columbus Life.
  • IUL with the Best Chronic Illness Rider: National Life Group.

Can you borrow money against an IUL?

Applying for an IUL Policy Loan

You can typically take a loan against your index universal life insurance policy's cash value component as soon as it exceeds your insurer's minimum requirement, making borrowing against the policy's cash a flexible option.

How to use IUL to build wealth?

You and the bank pay for an indexed universal life policy. You pay 25% of the total premiums, and the bank pays 75%. After 15 years, the cash value builds up enough to repay the bank for its contribution and interest. Then, you have a paid-up life insurance policy to use however you want.

What is better than an IUL?

IUL vs.

Indexed universal life (IUL) policies have flexible payments with cash accumulation pegged to the performance of an equity index. Whole life insurance is safer and simpler. IUL has higher upside potential, but is riskier and takes more work to manage.

What is the max fund for IUL?

A max-funded Indexed Universal Life (IUL) policy is designed to build maximum cash value by funding the policy up to legal premium limits. This structure enhances cash growth potential without triggering tax penalties, making it a strategy for those seeking life insurance with significant tax-advantaged savings.

What are the disadvantages of IUL?

Complexity and Costs

IUL policies are usually complex and often come with higher costs compared to other retirement savings options. The fees associated with IULs, such as administrative fees, cost of insurance and surrender charges, can eat into the cash value, reducing overall return on investment.

What happens to cash value in IUL at death?

When you die, the insurance company will pay the death benefit. No matter how much cash value you may have had in the policy the moment before you died, your beneficiaries can collect no more than the stated death benefit.

Is it illegal to have an IUL?

It is illegal to market Index Universal Life (IUL) as an "investment security", as defined by the Securities Act of 1933 & the Securities Act of 1934. These Acts of Congress gave birth to the SEC, in reaction to the stock market crash of 1929 that preceded the Great Depression.

Can I move my 401k to a IUL account?

An IRA Rollover to IUL is the process of withdrawing money from an IRA or 401k over a period of time and contributing the net amount to an IUL. A Roth conversion, which is a process of moving money from a qualified account to a new tax-free Roth IRA account are both very similar processes.

Which is better, Roth, IRA or IUL?

They also provide tax-free income in retirement. Therefore, investors concerned about their family's welfare after they're gone may prefer an IUL, while those who want a tax-free income stream during retirement can opt for a Roth IRA.

What is the average return on an IUL?

IUL policies typically allow you to grow a portion of your premiums through allocation to an index. Insurers often offer a growth cap of 8-9% and floor of 0%. This allows for upside potential with downside protection.

What are the safest funds for 401k?

Bond funds, money market funds, index funds, stable value funds, and target-date funds are lower-risk options for your 401(k).

How soon can I borrow money from my IUL?

You can generally borrow money from your life insurance policy once the cash value component has met a certain minimum threshold. However, to take the loan you want, the cash value balance must also reach an adequate level to provide collateral for the loan size you want.

Can I use my IUL to buy a house?

IUL Policy Loans

For example, you may take a policy loan from the cash value account to help buy a property, pay school fees, or expand your business. Keep in mind, if you take a policy loan you are borrowing from issuing insurance company with your own money.

What is the maximum you can put in an IUL?

In contrast, IUL policies can offer greater flexibility and control, with no contribution limits, no early withdrawal penalties, and no required minimum distributions.