What is the downside to a cash balance pension plan?

Asked by: Prof. Dedrick Nienow Jr.  |  Last update: December 2, 2025
Score: 4.9/5 (53 votes)

Top Cash Balance Pension Plan Disadvantages: Plan administration is expensive, although the plan benefits are high for the business owner. An excise tax could be assessed if minimum contributions are not met. But the actuary can help monitor the risk and benefit accruals.

Are cash balance pensions good?

Cash balance plans are a great way to save for retirement while reducing taxes. As a business owner or self-employed individual, if you are making a lot of money, and you are already contributing the maximum allowed to a 401(k) ($69,000 +$7,500 if age 50+), this could be a good option to consider.

What happens to my cash balance pension if I quit?

If you leave your job after the vesting period (usually 3 years), you can roll over the balance into an IRA or a 401K at your new job if they'll allow it. Unlike a 401K, most companies don't allow you to withdraw funds early for personal use, aka not roll them over into a qualified plan.

What are the risks of investing in a cash balance plan?

Investment Risks - The investments of cash balance plans are managed by the employer or an investment manager appointed by the employer. The employer bears the risks of the investments. Increases and decreases in the value of the plan's investments do not directly affect the benefit amounts promised to participants.

How does a cash balance pension plan pay out?

In a typical cash balance plan, a participant's account is credited each year with a "pay credit" (such as 5 percent of compensation from his or her employer) and an "interest credit" (either a fixed rate or a variable rate that is linked to an index such as the one-year treasury bill rate).

Cash Balance Pension Plan: Overview, Pros and Cons, and FAQ

16 related questions found

Do you pay taxes on cash balance plan?

A cash balance plan is an employer-funded retirement plan, which grows by the employer's annual contributions plus interest. As with other retirement plans, the amounts in a cash balance plan grow tax deferred (that is, they are not taxed until distribution).

What is the penalty for early withdrawal from cash balance plan?

To distribute funds from your cash balance plan, you'll must wait until you are age 59 1/2. If you take an early distribution prior to retirement age, you must pay taxes on the withdrawal, plus a 10% penalty.

What are the disadvantages of a cash balance plan?

Top Cash Balance Pension Plan Disadvantages:

An excise tax could be assessed if minimum contributions are not met. But the actuary can help monitor the risk and benefit accruals. The plans are permanent in nature. You don't have to have them forever, but you should at least have them open for at least several years.

Can I rollover a cash balance pension plan?

You can also opt for annuitizing your cash balance plan, which means you'll get smaller payments over time. If you'd prefer a lump sum payment, you can also choose to roll it over to your IRA or to your new employer's plan.

What is the target return for a cash balance plan?

Diversified savings options: While cash balance plans target moderate returns (usually 4% to 6%), investment options inside a 401(k) can include more growth-oriented investments like stock mutual funds.

What is the lifetime limit for the cash balance plan?

What is the lifetime limit? Even though cash balance plans may have minimum contributions and maximum contributions, they also have a lifetime limit or a lifetime cap as it is sometimes called. We actually established what this lifetime limit is in the previous section. It is $3.5 million for 2025.

Does cashing out pension count as income?

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) classifies pension distributions as ordinary income.

Should I move my pension into cash?

You can, however, transfer to a new provider at any time. But if you're 55 or older, you can move your pension into your bank account. Even then, though, it is unlikely to be a good idea to take all of your pension in one go. This is because it will prevent your pension from benefiting from investment growth.

What happens to cash balance pension when you leave a job?

Generally, these plans offer four different options, which can vary based on your former employer. Option 1: Annuitize the cash balance pension, turning it into a monthly income stream. This works similarly to creating your own “traditional pension.” Option 2: Roll the balance over into an IRA.

How much does it cost to set up a cash balance plan?

Your #1 Tax Strategy

But as the plan gets more complex with numerous employees and testing requirements, cost can certainly go up. But nevertheless, an average plan should cost around $2,000 to $4,000 to set up. With annual administration and tax filing to be around the same amount.

Do cash balance pension plans have separate accounts?

This means that while employees can see a balance that grows over time, the actual funds are not set aside in individual accounts. Based on the credits, the employer contributes and funds money into investments on behalf of employees. The employer, therefore, bears the investment risk.

Is cash balance pension better than 401k?

If you want to make contributions below $50,000, then stick with a 401(k) plan. But if you want to make higher contributions, then usually a cash balance plan is your best bet. Here are some of the main advantages of cash balance plans: They offer large, tax-deductible contributions as high as $300,000.

Do you have to take an RMD from a cash balance plan?

Are RMDs Required for Defined Benefit Plans and Cash Balance Plans? So now you have the answer. RMDs are required but they are subject to vesting and other special considerations. But remember – in most cases for small business owners they will be rolled over into IRAs before RMDs are required.

Can you terminate a cash balance plan?

It is important to consult with a qualified attorney or benefits consultant before terminating a cash balance plan to ensure compliance with all applicable laws and regulations. The process to terminate a cash balance plan can vary depending on the specific plan and the regulations that apply to it.

Can you cash out a cash balance pension plan?

A 10% additional tax is applied if you withdraw or use Cash Balance Pension Plan assets before you reach age 59 ½, unless an exception applies. For example, unreimbursed medical expenses that exceed 7.5% of your adjusted gross income may be exempt from the tax.

What are 2 disadvantages of paying with cash?

Disadvantages of cash payments
  • Security risks. Carrying or storing large amounts of cash can sometimes be risky. ...
  • Lack of traceability and records. ...
  • Inconvenience for large transactions. ...
  • Risk of counterfeiting. ...
  • Cash not always accepted. ...
  • Less convenient for remote transactions. ...
  • International transactions. ...
  • No earned rewards.

What happens when you freeze a cash balance plan?

Usually, when a plan is frozen in this manner, no new participants are allowed to enter the plan as of the date of the freeze. If no new participants are allowed to enter the plan, new hires do not need any information about the plan. A soft freeze occurs when a certain aspect of the plan is frozen.

What are the negatives of a cash balance plan?

Potential cons to consider include:
  • Employee contributions: You will contribute not only toward your account but also toward your employee accounts—generally 5–8% of their salary. ...
  • Expenses: Cash balance plans have higher costs than 401(k) plans.

Can I put my pension in a savings account?

As you know, to move your savings to your bank account you would need to withdraw them from your pension. Any money you withdraw from your pension, after your tax-free cash allowance, is taxable as income and taking your whole pension in one go would push you into a higher tax bracket and result in a large tax bill.

Can a company take away your vested pension?

“Vesting” in a retirement plan means ownership. This means that each employee will vest, or own, a certain percentage of their account in the plan each year. An employee who is 100% vested in his or her account balance owns 100% of it and the employer cannot forfeit, or take it back, for any reason.