What is the Medicaid improper payment rate by state?
The national Medicaid improper payment rate is 6.12% (or approximately $37.39 billion), as reported in the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Fiscal Year 2025 Improper Payments Fact Sheet.
How State-Specific Rates Work
- Rotational Cycle: CMS does not audit every state every year. Instead, states are divided into three groups, and each state is audited once every three years via the Payment Error Rate Measurement (PERM) program.
- National Rolling Rate: The official national rate is a rolling average calculated from the most recent three cycles of states (roughly 17 states reviewed per cycle).
- State-Specific Reports: Individual state improper payment rates are sent privately and published state-by-state through specific CMS Error Rate Notifications and cycle reports rather than released as a single universal annual leaderboard.
- Not a Fraud Rate: Around 77.17% of reported Medicaid improper payments stem from insufficient documentation or administrative/paperwork omissions rather than intentional fraud or abuse.
What is the Medicaid improper payment rate?
The national Medicaid improper payment rate is 6.12% (representing an estimated $37.39 billion), according to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Fiscal Year 2025 Improper Payments Fact Sheet.
Understanding the Rate
- Not Fraud: An "improper payment" means a payment did not meet exact program rules or paperwork standards. It is not a measure of fraud or intentional misspending.
- Paperwork Gaps: Roughly 77.17% of these improper payments happen because of insufficient documentation or missing administrative steps (such as a missing signature or form), not because an enrollee was completely unqualified.
- How It Is Measured: CMS tracks these errors using the Payment Error Rate Measurement (PERM) program, which looks at fee-for-service claims, managed care, and eligibility records on a rotating state schedule.
- Recent Trends: The rate was 5.09% in 2024 and rose to 6.12% in 2025, largely driven by post-pandemic eligibility redeterminations as states resumed normal operations.
Which states have the worst Medicaid coverage?
Texas, Mississippi, and Georgia frequently rank among the states with the worst overall healthcare coverage, limited Medicaid access, and high uninsured rates.
According to analyses by organizations like WalletHub and the Commonwealth Fund, state Medicaid and low-income coverage vary heavily based on policy choices, funding, and eligibility.
States with the Poorest Coverage and Access
- Texas: Ranks near or at the bottom for healthcare access, has the highest uninsured rate in the nation, maintains strict adult eligibility limits, and has not adopted Medicaid expansion.
- Mississippi: Consistently ranked low in overall health system performance, quality of care, and resident health outcomes.
- Georgia: Ranked low in overall Medicaid metrics, combining low provider reimbursement, limited enrollment reach, and a lack of full historical expansion.
- Other Low-Ranking States: Oklahoma, Arkansas, Louisiana, and West Virginia regularly appear at the bottom of state health scorecards due to coverage gaps, high chronic disease burdens, or restrictive eligibility rules.
Key Factors Causing Poor Medicaid Performance
- No Medicaid Expansion: The biggest dividing line between top and bottom states is whether they expanded Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act to cover low-income adults. States that refuse expansion leave hundreds of low-income residents in a "coverage gap".
- Strict Eligibility Rules: Low income thresholds for adults make it difficult to qualify unless a person is pregnant, a parent of young children, or disabled.
- Procedural Disenrollment: Post-pandemic eligibility redeterminations ("unwinding") led to massive coverage drops in states with outdated administrative systems or high procedural denial rates.
Which state has the highest Medicaid rate?
Louisiana has the highest rate of Medicaid enrollment as a share of its population at roughly 43.4%, while Alaska pays the highest Medicaid reimbursement rates to providers compared to Medicare.
Depending on whether you mean enrollment percentage or reimbursement payment rates, the top states differ:
Highest Enrollment Rate (Share of Population)
- Louisiana: Ranks highest with approximately 43.4% of its residents enrolled in Medicaid.
- New Mexico: Follows closely with about 41.8% of the population enrolled.
- California: Has the highest overall number of total enrollees (over 12 million people), representing roughly 33.1% to 37.6% of its population depending on the specific reporting period.
Highest Provider Reimbursement Rates (Payment to Doctors)
- Alaska: Pays the highest Medicaid rates to healthcare providers, averaging a median of 166.9% of the national Medicare payment amount. Large rural states often rank higher here to ensure basic healthcare access.
- Pennsylvania: In contrast, ranks near the bottom for provider payment rates at around 55.5% of Medicare.
You can review a broader performance and coverage breakdown using WalletHub's Medicaid Report or check specific medical reimbursement benchmarks at ProviderSignal Rankings.
Which states have the lowest Medicaid reimbursement rates?
Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, and Maine consistently rank as having the lowest overall Medicaid physician and specialty reimbursement rates compared to Medicare benchmarks.
Lowest States by Reimbursement Ratio
- Pennsylvania: Lowest nationally, paying base rates around 32% of Medicare and 46% of the national average.
- Rhode Island: Second-lowest nationally, paying roughly 47% of Medicare rates.
- Maine: Pays around 49% of Medicare rates.
- Other low-paying states: Illinois, Louisiana, Ohio, and Michigan frequently fall into the bottom tier depending on the specific medical service or specialty.
Key Factors in Reimbursement Rates
- State Control: Medicaid is a joint federal-state program, but individual states set their own payment and fee schedules. This causes massive variation across state lines.
- Service Discrepancies: A state might have average hospital inpatient reimbursement while maintaining extremely low physician or specific therapy rates (such as autism/ABA services being lowest in states like West Virginia or Alabama).
- You can check specific service guidelines and updates via the Medicaid Benefits Guide.
Rep. Miller-Meeks: The Rates of Medicare/Medicaid Improper Payments Should Concern You
What is the most common issue that leads to improper Medicaid payments?
The most common issue that leads to improper Medicaid payments is insufficient documentation.
Key Facts About Insufficient Documentation
- Percentage of Errors: According to Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) data, insufficient documentation accounts for roughly 77% of all improper Medicaid payments.
- Not Necessarily Fraud: Improper payments are administrative and paperwork errors rather than intentional fraud or misspent funds. They often happen when a provider, contractor, or state misses a signature, date, or specific record-keeping step.
- Potential Validity: Many of these services were actually provided to eligible people, but the claim files simply lacked the exact paperwork needed to prove compliance during a federal review.
Other Common Contributing Issues
- Provider Screening/Enrollment Errors: Administrative noncompliance with specific rules for screening or enrolling medical providers.
- Coding and Unit Discrepancies: Mistakes in billing units, incorrect procedure codes, or mismatched dates between the service delivery and the final claim.
- Eligibility Errors: Incorrect assessments of whether a beneficiary met income or program rules at the exact time of service.
What is the percentage of people abusing Medicaid?
There is no official percentage of people who actively abuse Medicaid, as intentional beneficiary fraud is considered statistically negligible (estimated at roughly 2% or less), though opinions and data interpretations vary regarding broader system metrics.
Improper Payments vs. Fraud
- Improper Payment Rate: The federal government tracks "improper payments" (which include everything from intentional fraud to simple administrative paperwork errors or missing signatures). The national improper payment rate for Medicaid was 5.09% ($31.1 billion).
- Distinction: Government and health policy organizations like KFF emphasize that an improper payment is an accounting or documentation error, not proof of intentional fraud or personal abuse. Over 74% of these errors involve insufficient documentation rather than ineligible recipients.
Where Abuse and Fraud Occur
- Provider-Driven Fraud: According to government oversight and health data, the vast majority of substantial financial fraud in Medicaid is committed by health care providers (such as clinics, pharmacies, laboratories, and personal care agencies) rather than the patients receiving care.
- Higher Estimates: Conservative policy groups, such as the Paragon Health Institute, argue that broader definitions of waste, improper payments, and structural vulnerabilities across the past decade suggest higher overall financial leakage, pointing to an estimated improper payment rate closer to 25% over a 10-year span. However, mainstream policy analysts caution against labeling all historical improper payments as active fraud.
Which states have the most generous Medicaid benefits?
States with the most generous Medicaid benefits typically include New York, California, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and Minnesota, which lead the nation in spending per enrollee, expansive eligibility, and comprehensive coverage.
Top States for Medicaid Generosity
- New York: Leads the country in total per-capita welfare and Medicaid spending, offering high reimbursement rates, expansive optional benefits (such as extensive personal care and long-term services), and high spending per recipient.
- California (Medi-Cal): Offers broad eligibility rules, has eliminated asset tests for many adults, and includes robust benefits for low-income residents, children, and pregnant individuals.
- Massachusetts (MassHealth): Ranks near the top for per-member expenditures and provides exceptionally strong behavioral health benefits alongside near-universal coverage initiatives.
- Connecticut (HUSKY Health): Frequently scores among the best overall for Medicaid and CHIP coverage performance, high enrollment reach, and broad support for low-income families and long-term care.
- Minnesota (Medical Assistance): Outspends most states across specialized care categories, ranking number one nationally in per-person spending for individuals with disabilities and providing strong coverage for children and families.
Key Factors Defining Generosity
- Medicaid Expansion: States that adopted the Affordable Care Act's expansion generally provide much wider access to non-disabled adults earning up to 138% of the federal poverty level.
- Per-Enrollee Spending: Northern and Northeastern states often allocate higher annual budgets per recipient to cover robust provider networks and specialized services.
- Asset and Income Rules: More generous states tend to waive asset limits or use higher income caps for aged, blind, and disabled (AABD) programs. (Opinions on Reddit are mixed, however, as some users note that high generosity can sometimes be paired with managed-care bottlenecks or provider shortages).
What race is the highest on Medicaid?
In raw numbers, White (non-Hispanic) individuals make up the largest share of total Medicaid enrollees, but people of color are disproportionately enrolled relative to their share of the U.S. population.
Total Enrollment Distribution
According to national Medicaid data and KFF State Health Facts, the breakdown of total non-elderly enrollees by race and ethnicity is approximately:
- White (non-Hispanic): ~36% to 43%
- Hispanic / Latino: ~28% to 31%
- Black (non-Hispanic): ~19% to 21%
- Asian / Pacific Islander: ~4% to 5.5%
- American Indian / Alaska Native (AIAN): ~1.3%
Disproportionate Representation
While White enrollees represent the plurality of total users due to the larger size of the total U.S. White population, minority groups rely on Medicaid at much higher rates relative to their share of the general population:
- Hispanic people make up roughly 19.5% of the total U.S. population, but nearly 30% of Medicaid enrollees.
- Black Americans make up about 13.7% of the U.S. population, but roughly 20% of Medicaid enrollees.
- American Indian and Alaska Native individuals experience some of the highest reliance and coverage rates, particularly in specific categories such as coverage at the time of birth (64.6%), compared to 27.3% for White women.
What states are cutting Medicaid?
Several states are cutting Medicaid provider reimbursement rates, reducing program budgets, or implementing new cost-sharing rules following federal funding reductions from federal legislation (such as H.R. 1 / the reconciliation law passed in 2025) and state budget shortfalls.
States Directly Cutting Payments or Budgets
- North Carolina: Cut overall provider pay by at least 3% (including 8% for primary care and 10% for specialists) and faces major funding and service reduction pressures.
- Idaho: Implemented an across-the-board 4% provider payment cut and reduced disability service funding to address budget gaps.
- Washington State: Approved hundreds of millions in program cuts and tracking coverage gaps affecting thousands of low-income residents and immigrants.
- Colorado: Suspended planned Medicaid rate increases and cut some dental spending.
- Arizona: Reduced state agency and program budgets by 5%.
- Missouri: Cut specific related child care and support allocations.
- Montana and New Hampshire: Initiated steps to introduce enrollee cost-sharing and monthly premiums.
States Facing the Deepest Projected Cuts
Under upcoming federal caps on state-directed payments and financing changes from federal rules, nearly three dozen states face major reductions (10% to 25% drops in high-rate mechanisms). The states facing the most severe structural and budget impacts include:
- California and New York (experiencing the largest reductions in total dollar value)
- Arizona, Iowa, and Nevada (facing budget reductions exceeding 15%)
- Nebraska, Louisiana, South Carolina, Kentucky, New Mexico, Illinois, Tennessee, Florida, Georgia, and Mississippi
Track ongoing developments and state-specific policy responses through resources like KFF and State Health and Value Strategies.