What to do if a COBRA is too expensive?
Asked by: Zola Kertzmann DVM | Last update: July 13, 2025Score: 4.7/5 (47 votes)
What to do when a COBRA is too expensive?
Can I drop it during Marketplace Open Enrollment and enroll in a Marketplace plan instead? During Marketplace Open Enrollment, you can sign up for a Marketplace plan even if you already have COBRA.
What if you can't afford COBRA?
Instead of enrolling in COBRA continuation coverage, there may be other more affordable coverage options for you and your family through the Health Insurance Marketplace, Medicaid, or other group health plan coverage (such as a spouse's plan) through what is called a “special enrollment period.” Some of these options ...
Why is COBRA so unaffordable?
In general, COBRA is expensive because you pay both your employee side of premiums AND the employer side of premiums. For example, this could be a total of like $600 for a single person that's young.
Why is my COBRA premium so high?
COBRA is expensive because when you pay for it you pay 100% of the actual premium. The employer part is no longer paid by the employer. The job I retired from my share of the total payment when working was 20% of the premium, so I felt bad for people who had to pay 5 times that amount if they needed to carry COBRA.
Why is COBRA So Expensive?
How can I reduce my COBRA cost?
To reduce your COBRA insurance cost per month, one option is to see whether your employer offers other lower-cost plan options with a lower coverage level. This tradeoff could make sense if you're healthy. You can't switch plans immediately after losing your job.
Can I negotiate COBRA premiums?
Your employer may subsidize COBRA, either pursuant to a company-wide plan or an individual severance agreement that you negotiate.
Is there a better option than COBRA?
Marketplace insurance, available through the Affordable Care Act, often offers more affordable premiums than COBRA. The cost difference can vary based on the chosen plan, location, and income, as subsidies may reduce premiums for marketplace plans.
Is COBRA even worth it?
While it may seem like a lot of money, COBRA may actually cost you less than what you'll pay on the open market. That's because you may still get your former company's group discount. You can also use a health savings account (HSA) to pay for your COBRA premiums. They're considered a qualified medical expense.
What is the average COBRA payment?
Average Cost of COBRA Insurance in 2025
COBRA is a continuation of your most recent employer group health plan. According to Value Penguin, the average cost of individual health insurance in the United States is $537/month in 2025. However, costs vary significantly by state.
What is the COBRA loophole?
If you decide to enroll in COBRA health insurance, your coverage will be retroactive, meaning it will apply to any medical bills incurred during the 60-day decision period. This loophole can save you money by avoiding premium payments unless you actually need care during this time.
What can I do instead of COBRA?
- You can enroll in a Marketplace plan within 60 days of losing your job-based coverage.
- Find Marketplace plans and prices to compare them to your COBRA coverage or offer.
- If eligible for Medicaid or CHIP, you can enroll in those programs any time and coverage can start immediately.
How do I waive COBRA coverage?
If you are currently receiving COBRA coverage for which a premium is being paid and you wish to waive future coverage, you can simply refrain from paying the COBRA premium for that coverage period.
Can you go from COBRA to marketplace?
When employer contributions to COBRA premiums cease, you can also qualify for a special enrollment opportunity to switch to Marketplace coverage.
Can COBRA premiums be refunded?
Request a Refund for Amounts Paid in COBRA Premiums Exceeding Federal Employment Tax Liability: The employer may claim the Credit through an employment tax refund on the applicable employment tax return, generally Form 941, Employer's Quarterly Federal Tax Return.
Can I decline a COBRA?
You must decide to accept or reject COBRA coverage during a certain time period (usually 60 days after your employer notifies you). You must pay your monthly premiums or you can lose your coverage. Once you have used up all your COBRA benefits, you may be able to get an extension of coverage under Cal-COBRA.
Is Obamacare cheaper than COBRA?
COBRA costs an average of $599 per month. An Obamacare plan of similar quality costs $462 per month—but with the government subsidies available, the average cost of an Obamacare plan on HealthSherpa is less than $10 per month. But ultimately, it depends on your situation.
What are the cons of COBRA?
- It's expensive. Your premiums will probably go up since your employer isn't contributing. ...
- You're subject to your employer's plan offerings. You might lose COBRA coverage if the employer changes its plan or goes out of business.
Why is Cobra insurance so high?
COBRA continuation coverage is often more expensive than the amount that active employees are required to pay for group health coverage, since the employer usually pays part of the cost of employees' coverage and all of that cost can be charged to individuals receiving continuation coverage.
What is the largest disadvantage of COBRA?
COBRA coverage is not cheap. Why? Because you're now responsible for paying your portion of your health insurance: The cost your employer contributed to your premium, in addition to the 2% service fee on the cost of your insurance.
Does health insurance end the day you quit?
When does health insurance expire after leaving a job in California? Your health insurance may expire the day you leave your job, or at the end of that month. For instance, if you quit on January 10th, you may have coverage through January 31st. You'll need to find out what your employer's policy is.
Can I get a COBRA if I quit my job?
Yes, You Can Get COBRA Insurance After You Quit Your Job
COBRA allows you to keep your employer-sponsored health insurance for up to 18 months if your coverage ends due to job loss, quitting or termination.
What do I do if COBRA is too expensive?
If COBRA feels expensive, consider ACA plans or short-term health insurance. Marketplace plans during the open enrollment period or a special enrollment period can offer more budget-friendly options.
Can I ask new employer to pay for COBRA?
Yes, an employer can pay all or part of a former or current employee's COBRA premiums. Employers may do so as a means to assist an employee during a merger, acquisition, layoff, termination, temporary or permanent disability, retirement, or as part of a recruitment strategy.
Are COBRA payments tax deductible?
Are my COBRA premiums deductible? Yes they are tax deductible as a medical expense. There isn't necessarily a “COBRA Tax Deduction”. You can only deduct the amount of COBRA medical expenses on your federal income tax in excess of 7.5% of your Adjusted Gross Income and then only if you itemize deductions.