Which doctor gets sued the least?

Editorial team Published on

Psychiatry, pediatrics, and allergy and immunology are the medical specialties that get sued the least.

Lowest-Risk Specialties

Data from studies published in the New England Journal of Medicine and reports by the American Medical Association show the lowest annual and career malpractice claim rates for these fields:

  • Psychiatry: Faces an annual claim rate of roughly 2.6%.
  • Pediatrics: Faces an annual claim rate around 3.1%.
  • Allergy and Immunology: Lifetime career claim rates hover around 7.0%.
  • Dermatology and Family Medicine: Maintain low annual claim rates of about 5.2% to 5.4%.
  • Hematology and Oncology: Around 8.0% lifetime risk of a claim.

Other Risk Factors

Beyond medical specialty, other factors reduce a doctor's statistical likelihood of facing a lawsuit:

  • Age: Doctors under the age of 40 have a significantly lower chance of being sued (around 8% to 9.5%) compared to physicians over age 54.
  • Gender: Female physicians statistically face fewer malpractice claims over their careers (about 23.8%) than male physicians (about 36.8%).
  • Practice Type: Employed physicians face fewer lawsuits on average compared to those in solo private practices.

What type of doctor gets sued most?

Obstetricians and gynecologists (OB/GYNs) and general surgeons face the highest rates of medical malpractice lawsuits over the course of their careers.

Data from the American Medical Association (AMA) shows that high-risk specialties see a large majority of physicians sued at least once.

Most Sued Specialties (Career Risk)

  • OB/GYNs: Roughly 62% to 79% face a claim during their career, driven by complex, high-stakes childbirth and reproductive care.
  • General Surgeons: Around 59% to 85% face a claim, due to invasive procedures and high risks of surgical complications.
  • Orthopedic Surgeons: About 47% to 81% face a claim, tied to complex bone and joint surgeries.
  • Neurosurgery and Cardiothoracic Surgery: While career totals vary, these fields have the highest annual risk, with roughly 19% of practitioners facing a lawsuit every single year.

Least Sued Specialties

  • Psychiatry: Around 16% face career claims, with an annual risk of about 2.6%.
  • Pediatrics: Roughly 18% face career claims, with an annual risk around 3.1%.
  • Allergy and Immunology: Among the lowest cumulative risk at around 7%.

Common Reasons for Lawsuits

  • Failure to diagnose or delayed diagnosis
  • Abnormal or surgical injuries
  • Failure to treat

How common is it for doctors to get sued?

Roughly 29% of U.S. physicians have faced a medical malpractice lawsuit at least once in their careers, according to data from the American Medical Association.

General Statistics

  • Career Risk: The older and more experienced a doctor gets, the higher the chance of a claim. Nearly half of physicians over age 54 have been sued, compared to less than 10% of doctors under 40.
  • Annual Rates: In any given year, only about 1.8% of physicians face a new malpractice claim.
  • Outcomes: Most claims do not result in payouts. About 65% of claims are dropped, dismissed, or withdrawn, and doctors or insurance defendants win nearly 9 out of 10 cases that go all the way to a trial verdict.

High-Risk vs. Low-Risk Specialties

The chance of getting sued depends heavily on the type of medicine a doctor practices:

  • Highest Risk: Surgeons and specialists dealing with high-stakes emergency or life-and-death care face the highest rates. Obstetricians-gynecologists (OB-GYNs) see roughly 59% to 62% career-long suit rates, and general surgeons face around 53% to 59%.
  • Lowest Risk: Doctors in fields with less invasive or lower-acuity procedures face much lower rates. For example, only about 4.5% to 8% of hematologists, oncologists, and allergists/immunologists report ever being sued.

Which doctor has the highest malpractice insurance?

Neurosurgeons and obstetricians/gynecologists (OB/GYNs) pay the highest medical malpractice insurance premiums in the medical field.

Highest-Cost Medical Specialties

  • Neurosurgery: Annual premiums often exceed $150,000 to $200,000 in high-litigation areas. This field carries high risk because procedures involve the brain and spine, where errors can lead to catastrophic or fatal outcomes.
  • Obstetrics and Gynecology (OB/GYN): Annual premiums typically range from $60,000 to over $100,000. High costs stem from frequent lawsuits and massive lifetime care payouts associated with childbirth injuries.
  • Other High-Risk Fields: Orthopedic surgeons, cardiothoracic surgeons, and general surgeons also face exceptionally high rates due to the invasive nature of their work.

Key Cost Factors

  • Location: Premiums vary drastically by state and county based on local tort laws and litigation rates (e.g., high-risk states like New York or Florida feature much steeper rates).
  • Procedure Scope: Specialists who perform complex spinal surgeries or high-risk invasive operations pay more than peers within the same broader specialty who focus on non-invasive care.

What percent of doctors are sued in their career?

About 28.7% of U.S. physicians have been sued for medical malpractice at least once in their careers, according to data from the American Medical Association.

Key Risk Factors

  • Age: The risk increases over time. Only 11% of doctors under 45 have been sued, compared to 45.2% of doctors aged 55 and older.
  • Specialty: Surgical and high-risk fields face the highest rates. Nearly 59.6% of OB-GYNs and 53.1% of general surgeons have faced a lawsuit. Low-risk fields like endocrinology (8.9%) and psychiatry (9.2%) have much lower rates.
  • Gender: Male physicians report higher career suit rates (around 36.8%) compared to female physicians (around 23.8%).

Lawsuit Outcomes

  • Most claims are dropped, dismissed, or withdrawn without any payment.
  • When cases go to trial, defendants (the doctors) win nearly 9 out of 10 verdicts.

If Your Doctor Has Been SUED MANY Times, Can You Use Past Lawsuit History at Your Trial in NY?

9 related questions found

What doctor is least likely to be sued?

Physicians in allergy and immunology, psychiatry, pediatrics, and hematology and oncology have the lowest risk of facing a medical malpractice lawsuit.

Lowest-Risk Specialties

Data from the American Medical Association and public health studies show that career malpractice claim rates are lowest in non-invasive or consultative fields:

  • Allergy and Immunology: ~7% to 15% lifetime claim rate.
  • Psychiatry: ~2.6% annual risk or roughly 9% to 16% lifetime claim rate depending on the dataset.
  • Pediatrics: ~3% annual risk or ~16% to 17% lifetime claim rate.
  • Hematology and Oncology: ~4.5% to 8% lifetime claim rate.
  • Endocrinology and Diabetes: ~8.6% to 8.9% lifetime claim rate.

Why These Doctors Face Lower Risk

  • Lower Acuity / Non-Surgical: These specialties rarely involve high-risk, invasive surgical procedures or acute life-or-death emergencies where rapid failure leads directly to severe physical trauma.
  • Patient Relationships: Specialties like psychiatry and pediatrics often involve long-term, communicative relationships with patients or parents, which can reduce the likelihood of legal action when adverse outcomes happen.
  • Forum Discussions: Opinions on Reddit are mixed regarding day-to-day stress, but users generally agree that outpatient and non-procedural internal medicine subspecialties experience far fewer legal claims than procedural fields.

Are most surgeons Republican or Democrat?

Most surgeons lean Republican, according to data on political party registrations and campaign contributions analyzed in studies like those featured by Advisory Board.

Political Leanings of Surgeons

  • Party Registration and Voting: Research matching physician databases with voter records shows that roughly 65% to 67% of surgeons lean Republican or register with the Republican party.
  • Campaign Contributions: Data from election cycles (such as the 2020 election) indicates that nearly 60% of political donations made by US surgeons went to Republican candidates and conservative groups.

Why Surgeons Lean Republican

  • Income Levels: Higher-earning medical specialties consistently correlate with stronger Republican leanings, partly due to tax policy preferences among higher income earners.
  • Professional Priorities: Surgeons often favor policy positions historically supported by Republicans, such as medical malpractice and tort reform, as well as protections for Medicare reimbursement rates.
  • Specialty Comparison: While overall physicians are more evenly split or lean slightly Democratic depending on the field, surgical and procedural subspecialties remain firmly on the conservative side of the spectrum, contrasting with fields like psychiatry or pediatrics which lean heavily Democratic.

What are the five most common reasons patients sue doctors?

The five most common clinical and interpersonal reasons patients file medical malpractice lawsuits against doctors are misdiagnosis, treatment or surgical errors, failure to treat, poor communication, and medication mistakes.

1. Misdiagnosis or Delayed Diagnosis

  • Missed conditions: Failing to identify a disease or mistaking one condition for another is a leading cause of legal action.
  • Impact: Delays prevent timely treatment, allowing conditions like cancer or cardiovascular issues to worsen significantly.

2. Surgical and Treatment Errors

  • Technical mistakes: Operating on the wrong body part, leaving surgical instruments behind, or damaging nearby organs and nerves.
  • Complications: Procedural negligence during operations or trauma care often leads to permanent disability or severe injury.

3. Failure to Treat or Follow Up

  • Premature discharge: Releasing a patient from the hospital too soon without proper instructions.
  • Neglected oversight: Failing to order necessary diagnostic tests, consult specialists, or manage abnormal test results in a timely manner.

4. Poor Communication and Unanswered Questions

  • Interpersonal friction: Research shows patients often decide to sue when doctors appear rushed, dismissive, or lack basic empathy.
  • Seeking transparency: Families frequently initiate legal action simply because a physician failed to explain what went wrong or refused to answer direct questions after an adverse outcome.

5. Prescription Medication Errors

  • Incorrect administration: Prescribing the wrong drug, calculating the wrong dosage, or missing dangerous interactions with other medications.
  • Allergic oversights: Failing to check patient history for known allergies or adverse drug reactions.

What profession has the most lawsuits?

Doctors and medical professionals face the highest number of lawsuits, primarily driven by medical malpractice claims.

Most Sued Professions and Specialties

  • Physicians and Surgeons: Medical doctors experience the highest litigation rates. Approximately 60% to 90% of surgeons face at least one malpractice claim during their careers.
  • Obstetricians/Gynecologists (OB-GYNs): Roughly 62% to 79% of OB-GYNs face lawsuits over their careers due to high-risk, high-stakes deliveries and time-sensitive care.
  • General and Orthopedic Surgeons: These specialties face intense scrutiny and high claim frequencies, with general surgeons averaging nearly two claims per 100 physicians annually.
  • Neurosurgeons: Frequently targeted at a rate of nearly 20% each year due to the delicate and high-risk nature of brain surgery.

Other High-Litigation Fields

  • Construction (Engineers and Architects): Large-scale structural development projects frequently result in multi-party litigation over delays, defects, and structural failures.
  • Lawyers: Legal malpractice claims are common, particularly for practitioners handling real estate, collections, bankruptcy, and family law.
  • Real Estate Agents and Brokers: Subject to frequent professional liability claims regarding disclosures and transactions.
  • Corporate Executives and Directors: Often targeted by shareholder and employment-related lawsuits.

You can read more about claim frequencies through the American Medical Association or check reports on Healthcare Brew.

Can a doctor earn $1,000,000 a year?

Yes, a doctor can earn $1,000,000 or more a year, though it is uncommon through a standard W-2 salary alone.

How Doctors Reach $1 Million a Year

  • High-Earning Specialties: Top surgical fields like neurosurgery, orthopedic surgery, oral and maxillofacial surgery (OMFS), and plastic surgery come closest through clinical work alone, with peak earnings or high-volume private practices frequently reaching or exceeding $1 million.
  • Private Practice and Business Ownership: Many physicians cross the $1 million mark by owning surgical centers, medical practices, or investing in medical real estate and external business ventures.
  • Alternative Practice Models: Implementing a concierge medicine model or high-value cash-pay packages allows some primary care or specialized doctors to scale revenue with fewer patients.
  • Extra Shifts and Locum Tenens: Taking on additional shifts, high-paying independent contractor work, or demanding call schedules can push total annual compensation higher.

According to data-driven breakdowns on platforms like the SalaryDr Blog, while annual salaries of $1 million require specific entrepreneurial or surgical tracks, building a $1 million net worth is a much more common milestone that most physicians achieve in their 40s through steady saving and investing.