Which is better, humana or devoted?

Editorial team Published on

Devoted Health and Humana are both top providers of Medicare Advantage plans, but they differ significantly in size, availability, and customer service approach.

Availability and Reach

  • Humana: A massive, established national carrier offering Medicare Advantage plans in 46 states and Washington, D.C., covering roughly 85% of U.S. counties.
  • Devoted Health: A newer, rapidly growing regional carrier offering plans in select counties across 29 states.

Costs and Premiums

  • Humana: Known for low-cost or $0 monthly premium options in nearly every state, plus competitive out-of-pocket prescription costs and "Giveback" plans that help cover part of Medicare Part B premiums.
  • Devoted Health: Features $0 monthly premiums on 92% of its plans, with 95% of those including prescription drug coverage. Out-of-pocket maximums vary by location.

Benefits and Care Model

  • Humana: Highly rated by major financial and health platforms for strong preventive care, robust national provider access, and chronic care support.
  • Devoted Health: Focuses heavily on a high-touch, personalized care navigation model using dedicated member "Guides" and specialized chronic condition management. Extra perks often include food and home cards, fitness memberships, and over-the-counter allowances.

Customer Feedback and Reliability

  • Devoted Health: Users on platforms like Reddit reach a consensus that while the PPO options and extra card benefits are helpful, some frustration persists regarding strict prior authorization rules and reimbursement delays for out-of-network claims.
  • Humana: Generally praised for widespread network availability, though local provider choices depend heavily on your specific county and active hospital contracts.

Is Devoted a good Medicare Advantage plan?

Devoted Health is widely considered a high-quality Medicare Advantage provider, earning strong ratings from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) and high marks for clinical quality and prevention. However, whether it is a "good" plan for you depends heavily on your location, your specific medical needs, and whether your preferred doctors are in their network.

The Pros of Devoted Health

  • High Star Ratings: Devoted consistently scores well above the national average in CMS quality and performance metrics, with a large majority of members in 4-star or higher plans.
  • $0 Premium Options: A high percentage of their plans (around 92%) feature $0 monthly base premiums.
  • Extra Benefits: Most plans include prescription drug coverage, dental allowances, vision, hearing, fitness perks, and a Food & Home Card for groceries or utilities.
  • Dedicated Support: Members get access to U.S.-based customer service representatives known as "Devoted Guides".

The Cons and Limitations

  • Geographic Availability: Devoted Health only operates in a select number of states (around 13 to 29 depending on the year's expansion), meaning it might not even be available where you live.
  • Network Restrictions: Like most HMO plans, seeing out-of-network doctors for non-emergency care is generally not covered, and some users note that provider directories can occasionally be inaccurate.
  • Mixed Customer Feedback: While some members praise the personal support, others on platforms like Trustpilot have reported frustrating communication, payment processing delays, or challenges with out-of-pocket reimbursements. Forum discussions (such as on Reddit) reflect mixed opinions: some beneficiaries love the extra perks and service, while others warn about limited specialist access or unexpected changes in medication tiers.

What's the best health insurance to have with Medicare?

The "best" coverage to pair with Medicare depends on whether you choose to keep Original Medicare with supplemental insurance or switch to an all-in-one private plan.

1. Original Medicare + Medigap (Medicare Supplement) + Part D

If you want predictable medical costs and the freedom to see any doctor in the U.S. who accepts Medicare, the best choice is a Medigap policy combined with a standalone Part D prescription drug plan.

  • How it works: Original Medicare (Parts A & B) covers your core care, Medigap pays for leftover costs like copays and coinsurance (such as the 20% Part B gap), and Part D handles medications.
  • Top Medigap Providers: Highly rated companies like Mutual of Omaha and AARP/UnitedHealthcare are nationally recognized for stable rate histories and strong claims processing.
  • Best Plans: Plan G and Plan N are currently the most popular and comprehensive choices for new enrollees.

2. Medicare Advantage (Part C)

If you prefer lower monthly premiums and extra perks like dental, vision, or hearing, the best choice is a private Medicare Advantage plan.

  • How it works: These private plans bundle Part A, Part B, and usually Part D into a single plan, though you must stay within a specific network of local doctors and often need referrals for specialists.
  • Top Providers: Industry leaders evaluated by Forbes Advisor include UnitedHealthcare for massive nationwide networks, Humana for robust extra benefits, and specialized regional carriers like Devoted Health.

Why are people leaving Humana?

People are "leaving" Humana largely because Humana is involuntarily discontinuing and canceling Medicare Advantage plans for approximately 600,000 enrollees ahead of the 2027 coverage year.

Why Humana is Dropping Plans

  • Unprofitable Markets: Humana is exiting specific geographic regions and dropping lower-margin offerings to reach a sustainable profit margin target of at least 3% by 2028.
  • Lower Star Ratings: Reductions in federal CMS (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) star ratings have lowered quality bonus payments, prompting Humana to scrap plans with lower ratings (3.5 stars or below).
  • Rising Medical Costs: Higher medical utilization and rising treatment and drug costs (up roughly 10%) have forced major insurers like Humana to pull back footprints nationwide.
  • Industry-Wide Trend: This is part of a broader industry retreat alongside competitors like UnitedHealth, Aetna, and Centene, which are also dropping millions of policyholders from unprofitable or lower-rated private Medicare plans.

For comprehensive coverage details and updates, check the Yahoo Finance Coverage on Humana and MarketWatch Insights.

Which insurance is better than Humana?

Whether an insurance company is "better" than Humana depends on your specific needs, particularly whether you are looking at Medicare Advantage or other health plans.

Top Alternatives to Humana

  • UnitedHealthcare: Better for provider network size and higher nationwide CMS (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) quality star ratings on average. It features a massive network of over 1 million providers, making it ideal if doctor choice and PPO flexibility are top priorities.
  • Aetna: Better for government quality ratings, often scoring higher in CMS star ratings and customer experience metrics compared to Humana, alongside a strong mix of zero-dollar premium options.
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield: Better for broad regional coverage and traditional network acceptance, contracting with roughly 90% of doctors and hospitals across the United States.

How They Compare

  • Humana Strengths: Highly competitive pricing, strong wellness and HMO plan options, and popular zero-dollar premium plans.
  • Humana Drawbacks: Often ranks lower in customer satisfaction and specific CMS quality scores compared to competitors like UnitedHealthcare or Aetna. Keep in mind that both Humana and UnitedHealthcare are scaling back or adjusting certain Medicare Advantage coverage areas.

UnitedHealthcare vs Humana Comparison 2025 | Best Health Insurance Plans Reviewed

9 related questions found

What are the top three Medicare Advantage plans?

The top-rated national Medicare Advantage providers based on recent industry evaluations and quality scores are UnitedHealthcare, Humana, and Aetna.

📊 Top Medicare Advantage Providers

  • âś… UnitedHealthcare
    • Largest enrollment base nationwide.
    • Extensive national provider network.
    • Robust digital tools.
  • âś… Humana
    • High customer satisfaction ratings.
    • Broad state availability.
    • Strong supplemental wellness perks.
  • âś… Aetna
    • High CMS quality star ratings.
    • CVS pharmacy network integration.
    • Comprehensive extra dental/vision benefits.

đź’ˇ Choosing Your Plan

  • Availability varies heavily by ZIP code.
  • Check local provider networks for your doctors.
  • Review specific prescription formularies.

Which Medicare Advantage plan denies the most claims?

Centene and UnitedHealthcare deny the highest share of prior authorization requests among major Medicare Advantage insurers, according to analyses from Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) and Newsweek.

Prior Authorization Denial Rates by Insurer

Recent federal and industry data tracking private Medicare Advantage organizations show varying denial percentages for initial pre-approval requests:

  • Centene: ~13.6% denial rate (with a high appeal overturn rate of over 93%).
  • CVS Health (Aetna): ~11% denial rate.
  • Kaiser Permanente: ~10% denial rate.
  • UnitedHealthcare: ~9.1% to 17% denial rate depending on the specific service category and year analyzed, representing the highest overall volume of denials due to its massive market share.
  • Cigna: ~7.7% denial rate.
  • Humana: ~3.5% to 6.8% denial rate.

Post-Acute and Inpatient Care Denials

Federal watchdog reports from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) highlight that large insurers—specifically UnitedHealth, Humana, and CVS—disproportionately deny specialized post-acute care. They reject more than 70% of long-term care hospital requests and over 50% of inpatient rehabilitation facility requests. However, a very high percentage of these specific denials (up to 95% for skilled nursing care) are overturned when patients or providers formally appeal.

What is the best health insurance for seniors over 70?

For seniors over 70 in the U.S., the best overall health insurance is Medicare, combined either with a Medigap (Medicare Supplement) policy or a comprehensive Medicare Advantage (Part C) plan.

Because Original Medicare (Parts A and B) does not cover everything—leaving a 20% coinsurance on many medical services and no prescription drug coverage—seniors typically choose one of two distinct paths:

Path 1: Original Medicare + Medigap + Part D

  • Original Medicare (Parts A & B): Covers hospital stays (Part A) and doctor visits or outpatient care (Part B) with any doctor who accepts Medicare.
  • Medigap (Supplement Insurance): Private insurance (from top-rated providers like AARP/UnitedHealthcare, Mutual of Omaha, or Cigna) that pays for out-of-pocket costs like copays, coinsurance, and deductibles.
  • Part D: Stand-alone prescription drug coverage from private insurers.
  • Best for: Seniors who want predictable out-of-pocket medical costs and the freedom to see any doctor nationwide without network restrictions.

Path 2: Medicare Advantage (Part C)

  • How it works: All-in-one plans bundled by private companies (such as UnitedHealthcare, Kaiser Permanente, or Humana) that replace Original Medicare.
  • Extra benefits: Frequently include built-in prescription drug coverage (Part D) plus extras like dental, vision, and hearing.
  • Best for: Seniors who want lower upfront monthly premiums and extra routine benefits, provided they use the plan’s local network of doctors and hospitals.

(Note: If you do not qualify for Medicare, affordable options with sliding-scale subsidies can be found through the Health Insurance Marketplace.)

Which medicare plan do most people choose?

Most people choose Medicare Advantage (Part C) over Original Medicare, with over 51% of eligible beneficiaries now enrolled in private Medicare Advantage Plans.

Why People Choose Medicare Advantage

  • All-in-one bundling: Combines Part A (hospital), Part B (medical), and usually Part D (prescription drugs) into a single plan.
  • Extra benefits: Often includes dental, vision, hearing, and gym memberships that Original Medicare does not cover.
  • Out-of-pocket caps: Features a yearly limit on out-of-pocket spending, which Original Medicare lacks.
  • Low premiums: Many options advertise $0 monthly plan premiums (though you still must pay your standard Part B premium).

The Alternative: Original Medicare

  • Original Medicare (run directly by the federal government) is chosen by the remaining 46% to 49% of beneficiaries.
  • Freedom of choice: Allows you to visit any doctor or hospital in the U.S. that accepts Medicare without needing referrals.
  • Supplemental coverage: Many people pair Original Medicare with a separate Medicare Part D drug plan and a private Medigap policy to cover remaining costs.

What is the biggest mistake seniors make when enrolling in Medicare?

The biggest mistake seniors make when enrolling in Medicare is missing key enrollment deadlines, which can lead to permanent, lifelong late-enrollment penalties and gaps in medical coverage.

Top Medicare Enrollment Mistakes

  • Missing the Initial Enrollment Period (IEP): Your window to sign up is a 7-month period that starts 3 months before the month you turn 65, includes your birthday month, and ends 3 months after. Missing this window without qualifying for a special enrollment period leads to delays and penalties.
  • Failing to Understand Work Rules: Many seniors either sign up for Part B when they don't need to (because they are still working and covered by an employer with 20 or more employees) or fail to realize they must sign up when they retire, missing their 8-month special window.
  • Ignoring Prescription Drug Coverage (Part D): Failing to sign up for Part D when first eligible—even if you take no medications—can trigger a permanent 1% penalty added to your monthly premium for every month you delayed.
  • Confusing Advantage and Supplement Plans: Assuming a low-premium Medicare Advantage plan always means lower overall out-of-pocket costs without checking network restrictions, copays, and prior authorization rules. You can read more details on avoiding these errors via the AARP Medicare Guide.