Which is cheaper, GEICO or Allstate?


Editorial team Published on

Geico is generally cheaper than Allstate for most drivers across almost every category.

Average Cost Comparison

  • Liability-Only Coverage:
    • Geico: ~$79 per month ($492 to $948 annually)
    • Allstate: ~$91 to $124 per month ($804 to $1,488 annually)
  • Full Coverage:
    • Geico: ~$143 per month ($1,937 to $2,148 annually)
    • Allstate: ~$159 to $217 per month ($2,609 to $3,205 annually)

Cost by Driver Profile

  • Good Drivers with Good Credit: Geico averages around $2,020 a year, compared to Allstate’s $3,210.
  • Drivers with Bad Credit: Geico is cheaper on average, though Allstate is close behind.
  • Drivers with Recent Accidents or Tickets: Geico offers lower rates (averaging $3,510 vs. Allstate’s $5,018).
  • Teen Drivers: Geico is significantly cheaper (averaging $4,323–$6,112 annually) than Allstate (averaging $5,146–$9,895 annually).
  • Drivers with a DUI: Allstate is occasionally cheaper in some markets for high-risk DUI profiles ($3,875 vs. $4,584 for Geico).

Key Differences to Keep in Mind

  • Business Model: Geico operates mostly direct-to-consumer online or by phone, which helps keep base rates lower. Allstate uses a local agent network, which increases operating costs but provides in-person service.
  • Coverages: Allstate offers add-ons like gap insurance and rideshare coverage, which Geico does not offer in most states.
  • Bundling: While Geico is cheaper for auto-only policies, Allstate often becomes much more competitive if you bundle auto and home insurance.