Which is safer laser or traditional cataract surgery?

Asked by: Jacky Grimes  |  Last update: December 2, 2023
Score: 4.4/5 (10 votes)

Traditional and laser-assisted cataract surgery are both safe, complications are rare, and both methods produce clear vision with little discomfort.

Who should not have laser cataract surgery?

Patients with autoimmune diseases are not good candidates for laser eye surgery. Many autoimmune conditions cause dry eye syndrome. A dry eye may not heal well and has a higher risk of post-surgery infection. Other conditions such as diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis, lupus, glaucoma or cataracts often affect results.

Which type of cataract surgery is best?

And many ophthalmologists prefer laser cataract surgery over traditional cataract surgery as a pre-treatment to “soften” cataracts. Traditional cataract surgery is performed by creating a small incision, using a scalpel, in the side of the cornea by hand.

Is laser surgery better than cataract surgery?

Laser cataract surgery comes with a higher level of precision, and it is considered marginally safer than traditional surgery. Laser surgery is also the best choice for people dealing with eye conditions such as astigmatism.

What are the disadvantages of laser eye surgery?

Risks
  • Dry eyes. ...
  • Glare, halos and double vision. ...
  • Undercorrections.If the laser removes too little tissue from your eye, you won't get the clearer vision results you were hoping for. ...
  • Overcorrections. ...
  • Astigmatism. ...
  • Flap problems. ...
  • Regression. ...
  • Vision loss or changes.

Should I Get Laser Cataract Surgery? | Laser-Assisted Versus Manual (Traditional) Technique!

38 related questions found

What percentage of people have complications from laser eye surgery?

How Safe is LASIK? All surgeries carry some risk of complications and side effects, but LASIK is generally considered a safe procedure with a low complication rate. In fact, LASIK is one of the safest elective surgical procedures available today, with a complication rate estimated to be less than 1%.

What is the risk of laser eye surgery going wrong?

Can Laser Eye Surgery Go Wrong? The chances of experiencing complications from laser eye surgery, including various minor ones, has been documented to be less than one per cent. Most laser eye surgery complications actually arise when the patients treated are not good candidates for the procedure.

What is the safest procedure for cataract surgery?

Traditional and laser-assisted cataract surgery are both safe, complications are rare, and both methods produce clear vision with little discomfort.

Is laser cataract surgery worth the extra money?

Laser assisted surgery is also definitely worth the money when you have a level of astigmatism between 0.5 diopters and 1.00 diopters. The reason is that the laser can precisely place arcuate cuts to lower this level of astigmatism and improve your refractive and visual outcome.

Why won t insurance cover laser cataract surgery?

Some insurance companies offer a vision plan which may provide a discounted price or apparent partial coverage for laser eye surgery. Because laser eye surgery is an elective surgery, many health insurance companies consider it cosmetic and not medically necessary.

What age is best for cataract surgery?

There is no single recommended age to get refractive cataract surgery. Cataracts normally develop after age 40, and some people elect for early intervention to restore their vision sooner. Patients can also delay their procedure until they're in a more convenient place in life.

What is the most advanced technique for cataract surgery?

Laser cataract surgery is more precise and requires less recovery time than traditional cataract surgery, while premium IOLs can be used to improve vision so that you don't need glasses after your cataract surgery.

Which type of cataract is the most visually disabling?

Interestingly, our results appeared to show that for each 1% of lens area involved by cortical cataract, axially located cortical cataract caused the greatest effect on visual function, reducing visual acuity and contrast sensitivity, and increasing glare disability.

What percentage of cataract surgeries are done by laser?

Despite the high volume of interested surgeons, however, few are currently offering the surgery. Only 8 percent of cataract patients receive laser-assisted cataract surgery, and more than half of young surgeons have no experience performing the procedure.

What are the problems with laser surgery for cataracts?

Possible Complications

There may be some temporary blurring, cloudiness or redness immediately following cataract surgery, but those usually clear up within a few days. Some patients may also experience short-term grittiness, redness or irritation, halos, faint floaters and/or discharge.

Why is laser eye surgery not for everyone?

Scarring from a previous eye injury or surgery can impede the surgeon's ability to perform the operation safely. Other eye diseases that affect the cornea or infections must be resolved before you can get LASIK. In some cases, you may find that because of eye diseases or another procedure, you cannot get LASIK.

How long does traditional cataract surgery take?

Perhaps the questions should really be: “How quick is quick? And does increased speed equal better surgery?” Regardless of whether a patient chooses traditional or laser cataract surgery, the procedure typically takes approximately 10 minutes per eye.

Is laser cataract surgery covered by Medicare?

Although Original Medicare doesn't cover routine vision care, it does help pay for cataract surgery if it's done using traditional surgical techniques or lasers. This is through Medicare Part B , the medical insurance portion of Original Medicare.

Why do some people need laser after cataract surgery?

YAG laser capsulotomy is surgery to help you see clearly after cataract surgery. You may need this surgery because months or years after cataract surgery, your vision may get fuzzy again. This happens when a membrane in your eye, called the posterior capsule, becomes cloudy.

Is traditional cataract surgery painful?

How painful is cataract surgery? Most people feel little or no pain during or after cataract surgery. You'll receive a topical anesthetic (eye drops) to numb your eye during the surgery. Shortly after surgery, your eye may feel gritty or slightly tender, but over-the-counter pain medicine should improve this.

What happens if you accidentally bend over after cataract surgery?

There are several things people should avoid after eye surgery. Avoid bending over for the first 48 hours after the surgery, as this can cause pressure to build up in the eyes and interfere with healing.

What is the failure rate of cataract surgery?

You'll be happy to know that not only is cataract surgery nearly painless with a quick recovery process, but it also has a very high success rate — 97-98% according to recent studies. This is because it is a common surgery that involves very few (if any) possible complications.

Do people regret laser eye surgery?

The surgery is not without complications, but it is rare for any extreme issues to arise. One paper has found that the majority of Lasik recipients were happy with their results, with only 1.2% reporting dissatisfaction.

Can your eyesight get worse after laser eye surgery?

For those who haven't previously worn glasses or contacts in the past, there is virtually no chance your vision after Laser Eye Surgery will be worse than before. For those who have a glasses prescription, the chances of your visual acuity being reduced by even a minute degree is around 1 in 1,000.

What are the long term side effects of laser eye surgery?

The long term side effects of laser eye surgery
  • Double vision, also called ghosting.
  • Dry eye.
  • Glare.
  • Halos.
  • Light sensitivity.
  • Starbursts.