Who pays the most for healthcare in the US?

Editorial team Published on

Medicare (administered by the federal government) is the single largest overall payer of healthcare services in the United States.

Key Details on US Healthcare Payers

  • Government vs. Private: Public programs like Medicare and Medicaid provide the largest share of overall national health expenditures, with CMS (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) managing public funding.
  • Largest Private Payer: UnitedHealth Group is the largest private health insurance company and commercial payer in the U.S. by revenue and total membership.
  • Spending Breakdown: Public programs account for over 40% of total U.S. healthcare spending, while private health insurance accounts for roughly 31%.

Did healthcare get more expensive under Trump?

Healthcare costs and insurance premiums have increased under President Trump, driven by federal budget legislation, expired subsidies, and general market inflation.

Rising Costs and Policy Impacts

  • Budget Cuts: According to reports by Families USA, a federal budget bill cut nearly $1 trillion from Medicaid and restricted eligibility, which increased the uninsured rate and shifted uncompensated care costs.
  • Expired Subsidies: Enhanced Affordable Care Act (ACA) premium tax credits expired without a congressional extension, causing net marketplace premiums to spike for many consumers.
  • Family Expenses: The Center for American Progress states that administration policies, higher deductibles, and tariff impacts have added financial pressure to household healthcare budgets.

Administration Actions on Transparency

  • Price Transparency: According to PBS News, the Trump administration has warned hundreds of hospitals to disclose pricing data or face fines, aiming to use market competition to lower costs over time.
  • Affordability Proposals: The White House introduced the "Great Healthcare Plan" framework to target pharmacy benefit managers, expand over-the-counter drug options, and promote lower prescription pricing.

What group pays the largest amount on healthcare in the US?

The U.S. Federal Government pays the largest amount on healthcare in the United States, financing roughly 29% to 41% of total healthcare spending through public programs like Medicare and Medicaid.

Major Healthcare Payers

  • Public Programs: Government programs like Medicare, Medicaid, and CHIP account for the largest share of national health expenditures.
  • Private Health Insurance: Commercial and employer-sponsored private insurance covers the second-largest portion of total spending.
  • Households (Out-of-Pocket): Individuals pay directly for care via out-of-pocket costs, deductibles, and co-pays.

Do Americans pay more for healthcare than Europeans?

Yes, Americans pay significantly more for healthcare than Europeans, both per person and as a share of the national economy.

Spending Comparison

  • Per Capita Spending: The U.S. spends nearly $14,800 per person annually on healthcare, which is about double the average of wealthy peer nations like Germany, the Netherlands, and France, where spending ranges from roughly $5,000 to $9,000 per person.
  • Share of GDP: Healthcare accounts for roughly 17% to 19% of the U.S. Gross Domestic Product (GDP), compared to an average of about 11% or less in comparable European countries.
  • Out-of-Pocket and Prescription Costs: Americans face much higher out-of-pocket expenses, deductibles, and prescription drug prices. Common medications like insulin can cost several times more in the U.S. than in Europe.

Why Costs are Higher in the U.S.

  • Higher Prices: Studies consistently show that higher prices—rather than higher usage rates—are the main driver of the cost gap. European governments often use central price controls or negotiations with pharmaceutical companies, whereas the U.S. market allows providers and manufacturers greater pricing freedom.
  • Administrative Waste: The fragmented, multi-payer U.S. private insurance system generates vastly higher administrative expenses per person compared to tax-funded or social health insurance models in Europe.
  • System Structure: Most European nations provide universal, public-funded healthcare that decouples coverage from employment, whereas the U.S. relies on a market-based, private-dominant model where millions remain uninsured or underinsured. As discussed in analyses on Health and Taxes, these structural differences mean Americans pay vastly more despite often lagging behind in overall population health outcomes.

Who pays the most for healthcare in the world?

The United States pays the most for healthcare per person in the world, spending roughly $14,885 per resident each year according to data tracked by the Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker.

Top Spending Countries

  • United States: $14,885 per person each year. This is about 17.2% of the country's total economic output (GDP).
  • Switzerland: $9,963 per person each year. It is the second highest spender globally.
  • Germany: $9,365 per person each year.
  • Other Wealthy Nations: Peer countries average about $7,371 per person, which is half of U.S. spending.

Why U.S. Healthcare Costs So Much

Experts from Johns Hopkins and the Commonwealth Fund point to several main reasons for high U.S. spending:

  • Higher Prices: Medical services, prescription drugs, and hospital visits cost much more in the U.S. than anywhere else.
  • Provider Salaries: Doctors and nurses earn higher average salaries in the U.S. than in peer countries.
  • Administrative Waste: Complex private insurance systems create high administrative overhead costs.
  • Fewer Price Controls: Unlike many European nations, the U.S. lacks strict government price limits on medical care.

What experts say about who has the world's best health-care system | Opinion

9 related questions found

Did Trump stop funding HealthCare?

President Donald Trump has not stopped all healthcare funding, but his administration has canceled, deferred, or scaled back billions of dollars in specific health programs and grants.

According to reports from KFF Health News and Roll Call, the administration's specific actions on healthcare funding include:

  • Pocket Rescissions and Program Cuts: The Trump administration canceled $810 million in congressionally approved health and social program funding, affecting refugee resettlement health services, minority health grants, and medical research.
  • Medicaid Restrictions and Deferrals: The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) blocked federal Medicaid coverage for certain legal immigrants and refugees, ended federal Medicaid funding for youth gender-affirming care, and paused over $1 billion in Medicaid payments to states like California and Minnesota over documentation and fraud compliance reviews.
  • Agency Scale-Backs: The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) saw substantial staff departures and a halt to numerous patient safety research grants.
  • Core Entitlements Continue: Major federal healthcare programs like Medicare and standard Medicaid remain active, though the administration has targeted various specific grants, administrative budgets, and specialized program scopes.

What race is the most uninsured?

American Indian and Alaska Native (AIAN) and Hispanic people have the highest uninsured rates in the United States.

According to data from KFF, the uninsured rates for people under age 65 break down as follows:

  • American Indian and Alaska Native (AIAN): 18.9%
  • Hispanic: 18.4%
  • Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander (NHPI): 12.3%
  • Black: 10.1%
  • White: 6.8%
  • Asian: 5.7%

Why do Republicans oppose free healthcare?

Republicans generally oppose government-run or universal "free" healthcare because they favor free-market competition, lower taxes, and a limited role for the federal government.

According to policy analyses published on platforms like the National Institutes of Health, conservative opposition is driven by specific economic and philosophical beliefs.

Free-Market Beliefs

  • Market Competition: Republicans argue that private companies and market competition provide the best medical care. They believe private choices keep quality high.
  • Avoiding Market Distortions: Conservative lawmakers, such as past statements noted by public policy groups, argue that direct government involvement distorts prices and harms the medical system.

Economic Concerns

  • Higher Taxes: Universal healthcare requires massive public funding. Republicans oppose the increased income or payroll taxes needed to pay for a government-run system.
  • National Debt: Conservatives argue that adding a large entitlement program increases government spending and national debt.

Distrust of Government Control

  • Bureaucracy: Public opinion data from sources like Pew Research Center shows a deep partisan divide, with most Republicans saying the federal government is not responsible for ensuring health coverage.
  • Reduced Choice: Many conservatives worry that a single government system leads to reduced medical choices, bureaucracy, and potential care rationing.
  • Individual Mandates: Laws that force citizens to buy insurance or participate in government-backed plans are viewed by the party as a violation of personal freedom.

Which state is ranked #1 in healthcare?

Depending on the organization doing the evaluation, Hawaii, New Hampshire, Minnesota, or Massachusetts is ranked #1 in healthcare across major national studies.

Major #1 Rankings by Source

  • Hawaii ranks #1 overall in healthcare according to the U.S. News & World Report Best States Rankings, scoring high in care quality, access, and public health outcomes.
  • New Hampshire ranks #1 overall in WalletHub's Best & Worst States for Healthcare, which measures cost, access, and health outcomes.
  • Massachusetts ranks #1 overall for overall health system performance according to The Commonwealth Fund State Health System Scorecard, driven by high insurance coverage and affordability.

Why is American healthcare so ridiculously expensive?

American healthcare is extremely expensive primarily because of higher prices for services, drugs, and procedures rather than people using more care than other countries.

High Prices and Monopolies

  • Higher Unit Costs: Surgeries, routine visits, and prescription drugs cost double or multiple times more in the U.S. than in other wealthy nations.
  • Hospital Consolidation: Mergers allow large hospital systems to buy out competitors and gain market power, letting them charge higher prices with little competition.
  • No Central Price Controls: Unlike other developed countries where the government negotiates or caps prices, the U.S. lets individual providers and private companies set their own rates.

Administrative Complexity

  • Fragmented Insurance: The system uses hundreds of private and public insurance plans, each with different rules, coding requirements, and payment structures.
  • High Overhead: Doctors and hospitals spend massive amounts of time and money just processing billing and paperwork, adding over $1,000 per person in administrative waste.

Misaligned Market Incentives

  • Third-Party Payers: Because insurance or the government covers most of the bill, the person receiving care rarely sees the true price upfront, which removes normal market pressure to keep costs down.
  • Higher Salaries: Medical professionals and specialists in the U.S. earn significantly higher salaries than their peers abroad, driven partly by high medical education costs and supply limits.