Why did universal healthcare fail in the US?

Asked by: Vivienne Feeney  |  Last update: September 17, 2025
Score: 4.9/5 (36 votes)

Opposition from doctors, labor, insurance companies, and business contributed to the failure of Progressives to achieve compulsory national health insurance. In addition, the inclusion of the funeral benefit was a tactical error since it threatened the gigantic structure of the commercial life insurance industry.

Why does universal healthcare fail?

The main challenges related to UHC concerning delivering services, as shown in Figure 5, are unregulated and fragmented healthcare delivery systems [16,19,22,23,25]; inadequate care and services in terms of quality [1,29,33]; the aging of the population, which increases the risk of geriatric health issues [23,27,35]; ...

Why do the USA not have universal health care?

Groups with significant economic resources have long been opposed to universal health insurance. We have a political system so sophisticated about finding the middle ground that we have had long periods in which the parties have been essentially even in their control of power in the national government.

Why is the American healthcare system broken?

The Challenges of Access and Coverage

While Medicaid and Medicare offer essential support, they don't cover everything. Many patients still face high medical bills and struggle to afford their medications. There's also a significant gap in coverage, leaving many Americans uninsured or underinsured.

Which country is #1 in quality healthcare?

The Legatum Prosperity Index 2023

According to the index, Singapore ranks first for healthcare, followed by Japan in second place and South Korea in third. In contrast, the United States ranks much lower, coming in at 69th place in this assessment. The full rankings are listed below.

EXPOSED: The Real Reason U.S. Healthcare is so Expensive

36 related questions found

Where does Canada rank in healthcare?

Across over 40 indictors measured, Canada's performance for availability and timely access to medical resources was generally below that of the average OECD country. In 2022, Canada ranked 28th (of 30) for the relative availability of doctors and 25th (of 30) for hospital beds dedicated to physical care.

Why does the U.S. rank so low in healthcare?

Access to care was the US' weakest area, with the country placing last due to issues like high out-of-pocket costs and its 26 million uninsured individuals. In contrast, countries like the Netherlands and Germany excelled due to universal coverage and affordable care.

What is the biggest problem with US healthcare?

(2024) Here Are 7 Big Issues Facing Healthcare Right Now
  • Rising Costs of Healthcare Services. ...
  • Financial Challenges for Providers. ...
  • Shortage of Healthcare Professionals. ...
  • The Need for Improved Mental Health Systems. ...
  • Increased Demand for Personalized Care. ...
  • Big Data and Cybersecurity Issues.

What country has the most expensive health care?

The United States: the world's highest medical expenses

The United States has the most expensive healthcare system of any country. A medical consultation with a general practitioner costs, on average, $190 or around €170. A stay in hospital can result in bills amounting to tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars.

What happens in America if you can't afford healthcare?

Americans are no longer taxed for not carrying health insurance. Medical debt contributes to a large number of bankruptcies in America. Access to quality primary care is critical, but doctors have the right to refuse patients without insurance or who are able to pay out-of-pocket expenses.

How is healthcare in Canada compared to the US?

Compared to the US system, the Canadian system has lower costs, more services, universal access to health care without financial barriers, and superior health status. Canadians and Germans have longer life expectancies and lower infant mortality rates than do US residents.

What would happen if the US had universal healthcare?

Universal health care, it was estimated, could have saved 212,000 lives in 2020 alone. Today, however, market-based US health care continues to be a global flagship for the neoliberal economic model and its entrenched inequities. The tentacles of economic neoliberalism reach deep into health systems around the world.

Does Russia have free healthcare?

The Constitution of the Russian Federation has provided all citizens the right to free healthcare since 1993. In 2008, 621,000 doctors and 1.3 million nurses were employed in Russian healthcare. The number of doctors per 10,000 people was 43.8, but only 12.1 in rural areas.

Why is the US healthcare system not universal?

Typical explanations include a history of individualistic culture, union bargaining, inflationary pressure, or favourable tax treatment for employer-sponsored health insurance (Scott 2023b).

Does Canada have universal healthcare?

Table of contents. Canada has a universal health care system funded through taxes. This means that any Canadian citizen or permanent resident can apply for public health insurance. Each province and territory has a different health plan that covers different services and products.

What are the disadvantages of universal healthcare?

Con: limited budgets

Universal health care that's funded or heavily subsidised by the state may not offer treatments or medicines deemed not effective or proven enough to justify the expense. This practice, known as "care rationing", can even be expanded to frontline treatment.

What country has 100% free healthcare?

Brazil. Brazil stands out as the model of countries that have free healthcare. The Brazilian free and universal healthcare system is funded by the government and is accessible to any person in Brazil, including citizens, legal residents, tourists, and even refugees and immigrants.

What is the average healthcare cost per person in Canada?

Total health expenditures in Canada are projected to reach $372 billion, or $9,054 per Canadian. Total health expenditures increased by 1.7% in 2022 and 4.5% in 2023, and are expected to rise 5.7% in 2024.

Why is US healthcare so inefficient?

The fundamental cause is a combination of high prices for inputs, poorly restrained incentives for overutilization, and a tendency to adopt expensive medical innovations rapidly, even when evidence of effectiveness is weak or absent.

What was the #1 leading health problem in the US?

Heart disease and stroke still the leading causes of death for both U.S. men and women.

What percent of Americans can't afford healthcare?

Healthcare Affordability Index Findings

Nearly half of Americans are now struggling to afford healthcare services and prescription medications. The Index revealed a record-low affordability rate of 55% in 2024, down from 61% in 2022.

What country has the best doctors in the world?

Here are the top 10 countries known to have the best doctors according to the World Population Review 2024:
  1. United States. The United States is often considered a global leader in the medical field. ...
  2. India. ...
  3. United Kingdom. ...
  4. Germany. ...
  5. France. ...
  6. Switzerland. ...
  7. Canada. ...
  8. Italy.

How is the Canadian healthcare system different from the US?

There is a significant difference in coverage for medical care in Canada and the United States. In Canada, all citizens and permanent residents are covered by the health care system, while in the United States, studies suggest that 7% of U.S. citizens do not have adequate health insurance, if any at all.

Can the US afford universal healthcare?

The numbers involved with a single-payer health system can seem scary. With so much of the U.S. government's money already being allocated elsewhere, it is hard to see how it is possible. But it is possible; the U.S. government could afford to pay for a single-payer health system, with the right systems in place.