Why do financial planners not like annuities?

Editorial team Published on

Financial advisors often dislike annuities because they carry high fees, limit access to cash, and do not fit into a standard growth-focused investment strategy.

High Fees and Commissions

  • Upfront costs: Some complex annuities charge high upfront commissions to the seller, sometimes ranging from 5% to 10% of the initial amount.
  • Ongoing expenses: Variable and indexed annuities can bleed 2% to 3% or more annually in administrative, mortality, and rider fees, eating into returns.
  • Fiduciary conflict: True fiduciary advisors—who legally must put your best interests first—often reject products with steep, hidden costs that benefit the seller more than the buyer.

Loss of Liquidity and Control

  • Surrender charges: Annuities lock money away for years. Taking out cash early triggers heavy surrender charges or tax penalties.
  • Tied-up principal: Once converted into a lifetime income stream, you often lose access to the lump sum, making it harder to handle sudden family emergencies or healthcare costs.

Fee Structure and Growth Focus

  • Asset under management (AUM) limits: Many fiduciary advisors charge a flat percentage based on the assets they manage for you. When money moves into an annuity, it often leaves their managed portfolio, meaning they can no longer charge their regular annual management fee on those funds.
  • Growth preference: Advisors focused on long-term wealth building prefer stocks, bonds, and mutual funds because they historically offer higher growth and fight inflation better than most insurance products.
  • Extreme complexity: Contracts are often long, confusing, and filled with riders that even financial professionals struggle to decode completely.

What did Warren Buffett say about annuities?

Warren Buffett famously criticized life insurers for selling complex variable annuities with unrealistic guarantees, calling those offers "crazy", while his own company, Berkshire Hathaway, has selectively acted as a corporate reinsurer to take on legacy annuity liabilities from other firms.

💡 Buffett's Core Stance on Annuities

  • Skepticism of Complexity: He prefers simple contracts (ideally one page), warning that complex products often hide structural costs or risks.
  • Criticism of Unrealistic Guarantees: During the 2008 financial crisis, he criticized insurers offering "crazy" market-tied guarantees on variable annuities.
  • Reinsurance vs. Retail: When Berkshire Hathaway "buys" or reinsures annuities, it acts as a corporate backstop for profit, not as a retail consumer buying a retirement contract.

📊 Consumer Takeaway: Simple vs. Complex

  • ✅ Simple Immediate/Fixed Annuities: Align with his general philosophy of absolute contractual guarantees for basic lifetime income.
  • ⚠️ Complex/Variable/Indexed Annuities: Feature high fees, opaque rules, and speculative market-growth pitches that contradict basic investing discipline.

What does Suze Orman think of annuities?

Suze Orman is generally skeptical of most annuities, but she acknowledges that simple, income-focused products can be useful if you lack a traditional pension and need guaranteed lifetime income.

Her detailed views break down into what she avoids, what she accepts, and her main warnings.

What Suze Orman Rejects

  • Variable annuities: She strongly advises against variable annuities, calling them expensive and unnecessary.
  • Annuities inside retirement accounts: She states it makes little sense to put an annuity inside an IRA or 401(k) because those accounts are already tax-advantaged, making the tax-deferral feature of an annuity redundant while adding high fees.
  • High fees and complex contracts: She frequently criticizes products with steep broker commissions (often 5% to 6%), hidden caps, and long surrender periods (5 to 10 years) where you pay heavy penalties to access your money.
  • Using insurance as an investment: She warns against using complex indexed or variable annuities as pure growth investments instead of safer or more direct market alternatives.

What Suze Orman Accepts

  • Immediate and fixed income annuities: She is open to Single-Premium Immediate Annuities (SPIAs) or basic fixed income annuities if a retiree has insufficient guaranteed income to cover basic living expenses.
  • Filling an income gap: If your reliable monthly income (like Social Security) doesn't cover your essential bills, she recognizes that converting a portion of savings into a predictable lifetime paycheck can prevent you from outliving your money.

Her Core Warnings

  • Insurers' financial strength: Orman reminds investors that an annuity guarantee is only as strong as the balance sheet of the insurance company backing it. If the insurer fails, your payout is at risk.
  • Liquidity loss: Locking your money away in a contract limits your flexibility for emergencies, especially if high surrender charges apply during the early years.

You can read more details directly on Suze Orman's Annuities Guide or explore independent context on Boldin's Retirement Analysis of Suze Orman.

Why are people so against annuities?

People dislike annuities mostly because of high fees, complex contracts, and strict limits on getting your money out.

Annuities are insurance contracts where you give money to a company in exchange for guaranteed future income. While they provide safety, they trigger strong negative reactions for several key reasons.

1. High Fees and Commissions

  • Hidden costs: Fees for complex variable annuities can total up to 3% or more each year when you add up administrative charges, fund management, and optional riders.
  • Big payouts for sellers: Agents and brokers often receive large upfront commissions—sometimes up to 7% or more—which leads many critics to believe the product helps the salesperson more than the buyer.

2. Lack of Liquidity (Locked Money)

  • Surrender charges: If you need your cash early, you may face heavy surrender penalties that start at 7% to 10% and last for 5 to 10 years.
  • Tied-up funds: Deferred annuities lock your money away, making them a poor choice if you suddenly need emergency or healthcare funds.

3. Inflation and Purchasing Power

  • Fixed payouts: Standard fixed annuities pay a set monthly amount that does not increase with inflation.
  • Lost value: Over 20 or 30 years in retirement, rising consumer prices can severely erode what your monthly check can buy.

4. Complexity and Confusion

  • Hard to understand: Contracts are filled with confusing jargon regarding different types (fixed, variable, indexed) and add-on riders.
  • Psychological framing: People often view annuities as poor investments compared to the stock market rather than seeing them as insurance against outliving their money.

5. Loss of Principal Upon Death

  • Keeping the balance: With traditional immediate annuities, if you die shortly after buying it, the insurance company often keeps the remaining balance, meaning your heirs get nothing unless you bought a specialized death benefit that lowers your payout.

You can read more about these drawbacks in the detailed AARP Annuity Concerns Guide or explore the balanced overview provided by Trajan Wealth's 5 Reasons People Hate Annuities.

Why are financial advisors pushing annuities?

Financial advisors often push annuities because they provide high upfront commissions alongside legitimate client benefits like guaranteed lifetime income.

🛑 Financial Incentives & Commissions

  • Upfront payouts: Ranges from 5% to 10% of the contract value.
  • Ongoing compensation: Trail fees or bonuses add long-term advisor revenue.
  • Corporate perks: Volume-based trips, marketing support, and higher tiers.

✅ Legitimate Retirement Benefits

  • Guaranteed income: Functions like a personal pension to cover fixed costs.
  • Principal protection: Shields retirement savings from severe market crashes.
  • Tax-deferred growth: Compounds earnings without immediate tax hits.

⚠️ Hidden Costs & Trade-Offs

  • High expenses: Administrative, rider, and mortality fees average over 2%.
  • Liquidity traps: Severe surrender charges apply if you withdraw early.
  • Capped upside: Market-indexed gains limit your total investment return.

Why Do Financial Advisors Hate Annuities?

9 related questions found

What does Dave Ramsey think of annuities?

Dave Ramsey strongly dislikes annuities and advises people to stay away from them for long-term retirement investing.

Why Dave Ramsey Rejects Annuities

  • High Fees and Commissions: Ramsey argues that variable and indexed annuities carry excessive internal fees and high sales commissions compared to standard mutual funds.
  • Low Returns: He calls fixed annuities "glorified CDs" (certificates of deposit) that offer low growth. He believes their returns cannot beat inflation or match the historical 10% to 12% average return of growth-stock mutual funds.
  • Complexity and Surrender Charges: He dislikes the complex contracts and steep surrender charges that lock up investor money for years.

The Rare Exceptions

Ramsey makes a tiny exception for variable annuities, but only if you are completely debt-free, own your home, and have already maxed out all other tax-advantaged retirement accounts like 401(k)s and IRAs. Even then, he considers them a low-priority option.

Criticisms of His Advice

Many independent financial planners and annuity specialists argue that Ramsey’s blanket advice is flawed:

  • Conflating Products: Critics note he often groups safe, zero-fee fixed annuities or MYGAs (Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities) together with expensive, high-fee variable annuities.
  • Ignoring Risk Tolerance: For a risk-averse retiree, an annuity can provide guaranteed lifetime income and principal protection that the stock market cannot guarantee.
  • You can read a detailed breakdown on What Dave Ramsey Gets Wrong About Annuities or check out an independent overview of how these products function via the Investor.gov Annuities Guide.

Do millionaires use annuities?

Yes, many millionaires and high-net-worth individuals use annuities, but they buy them for risk management, tax strategy, and asset protection rather than basic income replacement.

While middle-class retirees often buy annuities purely to cover fundamental living expenses, wealthy investors utilize specific contracts to solve advanced financial challenges.

Why Millionaires Buy Annuities

  • Bypassing Contribution Caps: Traditional retirement accounts like 401(k)s and IRAs limit annual savings. Once those are maxed out, high earners use non-qualified deferred annuities to store large sums of money with unlimited tax-deferred growth.
  • Asset Protection from Creditors: In states like Florida and Texas, annuity products offer strong legal shields. They protect accumulated capital from lawsuits, court judgments, and creditor seizures during severe financial or business liability.
  • Tax-Efficient Compounding: Instead of paying yearly taxes on standard certificates of deposit (CDs) or taxable brokerage interest, wealthy clients use Multi-Year Guarantee Annuities (MYGAs) to let interest compound tax-free until withdrawal.
  • Estate and Legacy Planning: Millionaires can add specific riders to pass remaining contract values directly to beneficiaries. This avoids the slow, public probate process and simplifies asset distribution for heirs.
  • Long-Term Care Management: Wealthy retirees often use hybrid policies tied to the Pension Protection Act. These combine annuities with long-term care riders to pay for potential medical or nursing home costs without liquidating core investment portfolios.

The Drawbacks for High-Net-Worth Buyers

  • Illiquidity: Annuities lock up capital behind strict surrender periods and early withdrawal penalties.
  • Fees: Certain variable or complex products carry heavy administrative and management charges.
  • Tax Status: Withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income rather than lower capital gains rates.

Why are annuities a bad retirement investment?

Annuities are often criticized as bad retirement investments because they carry high fees, offer low liquidity, and feature complex terms that favor the insurance company.

High Fees and Costs

  • Steep expenses: Variable annuities can charge over 2% to 3% annually when combining administrative, mortality, and rider fees.
  • Compounding drag: Even a 1% fee can reduce total retirement savings by up to 30% over a 30-year period.

Poor Liquidity and Lockups

  • Surrender charges: Withdrawing money early during the surrender period (often 3 to 10 years) triggers heavy penalties.
  • Restricted access: Even after the lockup ends, contracts limit how much cash you can pull out annually without penalty.

Complexity and Hidden Risks

  • Opaque structures: Contracts are often confusing, making it hard to understand actual payout calculations or performance caps.
  • Insurer risk: Your payout guarantees depend entirely on the financial health and credit rating of the issuing insurance company.
  • Inflation vulnerability: Fixed payouts lose purchasing power over time unless you buy a costly inflation rider.

Tax and Redundancy Issues

  • Redundant in IRAs: Buying an annuity inside an IRA or 401(k) provides zero extra tax advantages.
  • Ordinary income tax: Earnings and pretax contributions are taxed at ordinary income rates rather than lower capital gains rates available in standard brokerages.

How much will a $100,000 annuity pay monthly?

A $100,000 single-premium immediate annuity (SPIA) will typically pay between $525 and $1,000+ per month for life. The exact amount depends heavily on your age, gender, and the payout structure you select.

Because life insurance companies calculate payouts using life expectancy, older buyers receive higher monthly checks (as the insurer expects to make fewer total payments). Additionally, men receive slightly higher payouts than women of the same age due to shorter average life expectancies.

Estimated Monthly Payouts by Age and Gender

The following table outlines what a $100,000 immediate fixed annuity generates monthly under a Single Life Only structure (maximizing monthly income with no survivor benefits):

Age at PurchaseMonthly Payout (Male)Monthly Payout (Female)
Age 60$565 – $579$503 – $565
Age 65$625 – $644$584 – $616
Age 70$698 – $729$668 – $689
Age 75$817$770
Age 80$1,006$934

How Payout Structures Impact Your Check

Choosing to protect a spouse or leave money to heirs will reduce your monthly income stream:

  • Single Life Only: Highest payout. Payments stop entirely when you pass away, and any remaining principal is kept by the insurance company.
  • Joint and Survivor: Continues paying as long as either you or your spouse is alive. For a couple both aged 65, this drops the monthly payout to roughly $530 to $560.
  • Period Certain (e.g., 10 or 20 Years): Guarantees payments for life, but if you pass away early, your beneficiaries receive the checks for the remainder of the chosen term. A 20-year certain option for a 65-year-old male drops the payout to about $577.
  • Cash Refund: If you pass away before receiving your initial $100,000 back via monthly installments, the remainder is paid to your heirs in a lump sum. For a 65-year-old male, this yields roughly $606.

Hidden Costs & Strategy Notes

  • Inflation Risk: Fixed immediate annuities do not automatically adjust for inflation. A $600 check today will buy significantly less 15 years from now. Adding an inflation rider is possible, but it severely lowers your initial monthly payout.
  • Irreversibility: Once you buy an immediate annuity, you generally surrender control of the $100,000 principal in exchange for the lifetime income. You cannot withdraw the cash for unexpected emergencies.
  • Taxation: If bought with "pre-tax" retirement funds (like a Traditional IRA), the entire monthly payment is taxed as ordinary income. If bought with "after-tax" cash, only the interest portion of each check is taxed.

To tailor this guidance, how old are you, and are you looking for an income stream that covers just yourself or a spouse as well?

How much does Suze Orman say you need to retire?

Financial expert Suze Orman famously states that you need at least $5 million to $10 million if you plan to retire early. While she has received significant backlash for this high threshold, she insists that smaller nest eggs—even a $2 million portfolio—are "pennies" or "chump change" in today's economic climate due to inflation and catastrophic health risks.

Why Does She Say You Need So Much?

Orman’s calculations are conservative and assume worst-case scenarios, such as needing full-time medical care later in life. Her logic includes:

  • The $350,000 Rule: She bases her early retirement scenario on needing roughly $100,000 for standard annual living expenses plus an additional $250,000 a year for unexpected catastrophes or private long-term care.
  • Living Off the Yield: To generate $350,000 after taxes (about $500,000 pre-tax) using a safe 5% withdrawal or interest yield without draining your core principal, you mathematically require a $10 million portfolio.

The Standard Retirement Age Multipliers

If you are planning for a traditional retirement around age 67 rather than early retirement, Orman defaults to standard age-based income milestones:

  • By age 30: 1x your current salary saved
  • By age 40: 3x your current salary saved
  • By age 50: 6x your current salary saved
  • By age 60: 8x your current salary saved
  • By age 67: 10x your final salary saved

Other Crucial Retirement Rules from Suze Orman

Beyond a raw net-worth figure, Orman highlights several requirements before you can comfortably step away from work:

  • The Cash Reserve Rule: You should transition into retirement holding 3 to 5 years' worth of living expenses entirely in liquid cash (like a high-yield savings account), completely separated from the stock market, so you never have to sell equities during a market crash.
  • No Debt: She strongly believes you should not retire unless your primary mortgage is completely paid off.
  • Delay Social Security: Orman advises against collecting Social Security early at age 62, strongly pushing people to wait until age 70 to secure a 76% higher permanent monthly payout.