Why do providers not like Medicaid?

Asked by: Keanu Trantow Jr.  |  Last update: May 18, 2025
Score: 4.8/5 (22 votes)

One reason is that reimbursement rates for Medicaid are lower than for Medicare or commercial insurance. Another (often overlooked) factor, however, is physician's risk of payment denials and the administrative hassle they face trying to get reimbursed by Medicaid.

Why do most doctors not accept Medicaid?

That's because Medicaid physician payment rates have historically been well below those of Medicare or private insurance rates. This fee discrepancy has contributed to many physicians' reluctance to accept new Medicaid patients, which has left them clustered in a subset of practices.

How does Medicaid affect providers?

Medicaid patients experience increased barriers to care compared with privately insured patients. In a nationwide survey of primary care providers in 2015, only 45% indicated they were willing to accept new Medicaid patients while 94% were willing to accept new privately insured patients.

Why do people disagree with Medicaid?

  • It's expensive to those who pay for it.
  • The reimbursement rate is poor, such that many doctors limit this population in their practice.
  • Hence, the service level is poor, since a participant will have a hard time finding a doctor that accepts new Medicaid patients.

What is the main problem with Medicaid?

But it has been difficult to launch and sustain managed care under Medicaid: Program design has been complicated and time-consuming, and administrative costs are higher, at least in the initial stages (Freund et. al., 1989; Spitz and Abramson, 1987). The Federal waiver process has been cumbersome for many States.

Doctors: Medicaid Isn't Reimbursing Us For Treatement

36 related questions found

What is the drawback of Medicaid?

One of the most serious problems with understanding the Medicaid program is that it is not a single program, but rather an umbrella program that has several components serving vastly different populations that have in common the sole misfortune of having insufficient income to meet their health care needs.

Why do some people not get Medicaid?

Adults who fall into the coverage gap have incomes above their state's eligibility for Medicaid but below poverty, making them ineligible for subsidies in the ACA Marketplaces (Figure 2).

Why Medicare is better than Medicaid?

While Medicare is the primary payer for medical needs, Medicaid can cover costs that Medicare coverage does not. When you visit a provider that takes both Medicare and Medicaid, Medicare pays first for the cost of your care. Medicaid pays second, covering copays and other costs not covered.

Is Medicaid actually helpful?

The general finding of the studies is that having insurance (including Medicaid) is associated with better access to care and increases in the use of health-care services relative to being uninsured.

Can a provider refuse Medicaid?

If a provider refuses to accept a patient as a Medicaid patient, the provider shall inform the patient before providing any services or supplies, except when it would delay provision of an appropriate medical screening, medical examination, or treatment as required by 42 U.S.C. 1395dd.

Do a lot of doctors take Medicaid?

This gap was much larger in some states than others. For example, in New Jersey, Florida, Louisiana, and California, physicians were more than 30 percentage-points less likely to accept new patients with Medicaid coverage than those with private insurance.

Who uses Medicaid the most?

In 2020, Medicaid and CHIP provided coverage for nearly 55 million people of color. These programs provide essential coverage for a population that is more diverse than the broader U.S. population—especially among children, with 61 percent of Medicaid and CHIP enrollees under age 19 being children of color.

Why do doctors not like Medicare?

Medicare payments are lower, on average, than payments from private insurers and are not automatically indexed to keep pace with inflation in medical practice costs.

Do doctors get paid less for Medicaid patients?

Summarizing, we do find corroborative evidence (admittedly based on physician self-reports) that both Medicare and Medicaid pay significantly less (e.g., 30-50 percent) than the physician's usual fee for office and inpatient visits as well as for surgical and diagnostic procedures.

What does Medicaid not cover?

Though Medicaid covers a wide range of services, there are limitations on certain types of care, such as infertility treatments, elective abortions, and some types of alternative medicine. For example, the federal government lists family planning as a mandatory service benefit, but states interpret this differently.

What are the disadvantages of Medicaid?

Disadvantages of Medicaid
  • Lower reimbursements and reduced revenue. Every medical practice needs to make a profit to stay in business, but medical practices that have a large Medicaid patient base tend to be less profitable. ...
  • Administrative overhead. ...
  • Extensive patient base. ...
  • Medicaid can help get new practices established.

Why do so few doctors accept Medicaid?

One reason is that reimbursement rates for Medicaid are lower than for Medicare or commercial insurance. Another (often overlooked) factor, however, is physician's risk of payment denials and the administrative hassle they face trying to get reimbursed by Medicaid.

Who gets turned down for Medicaid?

The most common reason an applicant is denied Medicaid is income or assets above the eligibility criteria. In most states in 2025, an applicant's monthly income must be less than $2,901/month, and their assets (including money in bank accounts) must be less than $2,000.

Do doctors prefer Medicaid or Medicare?

Physicians in general/family practice were less likely to accept Medicaid patients (68%) than Medicare (90%) or private insurance (91%). Only 36% of psychiatrists accepted new Medicaid patients compared to 62% who took Medicare patients and also 62% who accepted on private insurance.

What happens if you make too much money while on Medicaid?

If you're over the Medicaid income limit, some states let you spend down extra income or place it in a trust to help you qualify for Medicaid. If you receive long-term care but your spouse doesn't, Medicaid will allow your spouse to keep enough income to avoid living in poverty.

Why is Medicaid not accepted?

Second, practices with no Medicaid are more likely to be urban, in low poverty areas, and in states that have not expanded Medicaid; this finding suggests that providers who have access to a large enough patient base outside of Medicaid may be less willing to take Medicaid.

What are the hardest states to get Medicaid?

The 10 most deficient state programs have overall scores ranging from between 317.8 and 379.1 of the total 1000 points. The worst, in order from 50th to 41st, are in Mississippi, Idaho, Texas, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Indiana, South Carolina, Colorado, Alabama, and Missouri.

What is the issue with Medicaid?

Polls show many in the population believe Medicaid is an unaffordable/unnecessary government entitlement program that benefits those not eligible and those who elect to forego purchasing coverage for themselves and their families.