Why don't financial advisors recommend annuities?

Editorial team Published on

Financial advisors often dislike annuities because they carry high fees, limit access to cash, and do not fit into a standard growth-focused investment strategy.

High Fees and Commissions

  • Upfront costs: Some complex annuities charge high upfront commissions to the seller, sometimes ranging from 5% to 10% of the initial amount.
  • Ongoing expenses: Variable and indexed annuities can bleed 2% to 3% or more annually in administrative, mortality, and rider fees, eating into returns.
  • Fiduciary conflict: True fiduciary advisors—who legally must put your best interests first—often reject products with steep, hidden costs that benefit the seller more than the buyer.

Loss of Liquidity and Control

  • Surrender charges: Annuities lock money away for years. Taking out cash early triggers heavy surrender charges or tax penalties.
  • Tied-up principal: Once converted into a lifetime income stream, you often lose access to the lump sum, making it harder to handle sudden family emergencies or healthcare costs.

Fee Structure and Growth Focus

  • Asset under management (AUM) limits: Many fiduciary advisors charge a flat percentage based on the assets they manage for you. When money moves into an annuity, it often leaves their managed portfolio, meaning they can no longer charge their regular annual management fee on those funds.
  • Growth preference: Advisors focused on long-term wealth building prefer stocks, bonds, and mutual funds because they historically offer higher growth and fight inflation better than most insurance products.
  • Extreme complexity: Contracts are often long, confusing, and filled with riders that even financial professionals struggle to decode completely.

What does Warren Buffett think of annuities?

Warren Buffett views complex or market-tied annuities with skepticism, but he respects simple, contractual guarantees that function like basic insurance against outliving your money.

Key Views on Annuities

  • Criticism of Complex Products: Buffett has famously criticized life insurers for selling complicated variable and equity-indexed annuities with unrealistic promises or "crazy" financial guarantees tied to the stock market. He prefers simple, transparent contracts over multi-page legalese.
  • Value of Contractual Guarantees: He applies his core investment philosophy—focusing strictly on definite, contractual facts rather than hypothetical market growth or sales pitches.
  • The Insurer's Perspective: Through Berkshire Hathaway, Buffett is often on the selling or reinsuring side of annuity risk rather than buying them as a personal retail investment. He is confident that Berkshire can manage the long-term risk profitably.

Does Suze Orman recommend annuities?

Suze Orman does not give a blanket recommendation for all annuities, but she is not completely against them either; she approves of simple income annuities while strongly warning against variable and complex products.

What She Recommends

  • Single Premium Immediate Annuities (SPIAs) / Income Annuities: She is supportive of products that convert a lump sum into a guaranteed monthly lifetime income stream, particularly for retirees who lack a traditional pension and worry about outliving their savings.
  • CD-Type Fixed Annuities: She finds basic, fixed-rate accumulation products acceptable when funded with after-tax (non-qualified) money if the guaranteed rate makes sense for the surrender period.

What She Strongly Advises Against

  • Variable Annuities: She frequently warns people never to buy variable annuities because of high hidden fees, mortality charges, steep broker commissions, and unfavorable ordinary income tax treatment upon withdrawal.
  • Annuities Inside Retirement Accounts: She calls putting an annuity (especially a variable annuity) inside a tax-deferred account like an IRA or 401(k) a major mistake, because you pay high fees for tax deferral the account already provides for free.
  • Index Annuities: She cautions against equity-indexed annuities due to interest caps, inflation risks, and heavy surrender charges.

You can read more about her detailed breakdowns on the Suze Orman Annuities Resource Page.

Why are some financial experts against annuities?

Financial experts often criticize annuities because of their high fees, complex terms, and lack of liquidity.

An AARP report notes several key reasons why many advisors and investors advise caution:

  • High Fees and Commissions: Variable and complex annuities often feature high upfront sales commissions (sometimes 6% to 8%) alongside ongoing administrative, management, and rider fees that can top 3% annually.
  • Illiquidity and Surrender Charges: Money put into certain annuities is locked away. Withdrawing funds early often triggers steep surrender penalties that can last for a decade.
  • Extreme Complexity: Contracts are notoriously difficult to read, filled with confusing caps, participation rates, and hidden clauses that even seasoned consumers struggle to understand.
  • Inflation Risk: Standard payouts stay fixed over time. Without an expensive inflation rider, rising prices steadily erode the purchasing power of your monthly check.
  • Opportunity Cost: Tying up a large lump sum in an annuity means missing out on potentially higher long-term growth by investing directly in the stock market.

What does Dave Ramsey say about annuities?

Dave Ramsey strongly advises against buying annuities, calling them expensive, low-yielding products that are inferior to mutual funds.

Core Arguments Against Annuities

  • High Fees and Commissions: Ramsey highlights that many annuities carry steep hidden fees, surrender charges, and high commissions (sometimes up to 10%) that eat into your returns.
  • Low Returns: He argues that fixed annuities offer poor growth (often comparing them to a low-paying Certificate of Deposit with extra fees), claiming you can make much higher long-term returns by investing in growth stock mutual funds.
  • Illiquidity: He points out that locking your money into an annuity contract makes it difficult and expensive to access if you need cash before the surrender period ends.
  • The "Rare Exception": Ramsey states he only sees a potential use for a variable annuity (a mutual fund inside an insurance contract) if you are completely out of debt, your home is paid off, and you have already maxed out all standard retirement accounts like 401(k)s and IRAs. Otherwise, his blanket advice is to avoid them entirely.

Common Industry Counterpoints

Many financial planners and insurance specialists argue that Ramsey’s blanket stance is overly dismissive:

  • Guaranteed Income: Critics note that What Is an Annuity and How Does It Work? - Ramsey defines annuities as insurance contracts for guaranteed lifetime income, not pure growth investments.
  • Principal Protection: Fixed and multi-year guarantee annuities protect your principal from market crashes, which can benefit risk-averse retirees who cannot afford sequence-of-returns risk.
  • Fee Misconceptions: Many fixed or no-load annuities feature zero annual administrative fees if you do not add expensive optional riders.

Why Do Financial Advisors Love or Hate Annuities So Much?

9 related questions found

Do millionaires use annuities?

Yes, many millionaires and high-net-worth individuals use annuities, but they buy them for risk management, tax strategy, and asset protection rather than basic income replacement.

While middle-class retirees often buy annuities purely to cover fundamental living expenses, wealthy investors utilize specific contracts to solve advanced financial challenges.

Why Millionaires Buy Annuities

  • Bypassing Contribution Caps: Traditional retirement accounts like 401(k)s and IRAs limit annual savings. Once those are maxed out, high earners use non-qualified deferred annuities to store large sums of money with unlimited tax-deferred growth.
  • Asset Protection from Creditors: In states like Florida and Texas, annuity products offer strong legal shields. They protect accumulated capital from lawsuits, court judgments, and creditor seizures during severe financial or business liability.
  • Tax-Efficient Compounding: Instead of paying yearly taxes on standard certificates of deposit (CDs) or taxable brokerage interest, wealthy clients use Multi-Year Guarantee Annuities (MYGAs) to let interest compound tax-free until withdrawal.
  • Estate and Legacy Planning: Millionaires can add specific riders to pass remaining contract values directly to beneficiaries. This avoids the slow, public probate process and simplifies asset distribution for heirs.
  • Long-Term Care Management: Wealthy retirees often use hybrid policies tied to the Pension Protection Act. These combine annuities with long-term care riders to pay for potential medical or nursing home costs without liquidating core investment portfolios.

The Drawbacks for High-Net-Worth Buyers

  • Illiquidity: Annuities lock up capital behind strict surrender periods and early withdrawal penalties.
  • Fees: Certain variable or complex products carry heavy administrative and management charges.
  • Tax Status: Withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income rather than lower capital gains rates.

Why does Dave Ramsey not like annuities?

Dave Ramsey dislikes annuities because he believes they carry high fees, lock up money with strict penalties, and offer lower long-term returns than growth-stock mutual funds.

Key Reasons for Ramsey's Dislike

  • High Fees and Commissions: Ramsey highlights that many annuities—especially variable annuities—feature steep management fees, administrative costs, and high upfront sales commissions (sometimes up to 7% to 10%) that eat into returns.
  • Lower Growth Potential: He prefers investing in good growth-stock mutual funds, targeting higher historical market averages (10% to 12%), whereas he views fixed or indexed annuities as underperforming and failing to build optimal wealth.
  • Illiquidity and Surrender Charges: Annuities often penalize early withdrawals heavily through multi-year surrender charges (frequently declining to zero over 5 to 10 years), which limits access to your cash in an emergency.
  • Redundant Tax-Advantaged Status: Ramsey strongly advises against placing an annuity inside an IRA or 403(b), arguing it creates a "double tax-deferred" redundancy that provides no extra tax benefit while adding unnecessary fees.

For a broader overview of how these insurance products operate, you can read the SEC Investor Guide to Annuities.

Why do people say don't buy an annuity?

Financial experts and consumers often warn against buying annuities because of high fees, limited access to your money, and complex contract terms.

For a deeper dive into the common criticisms and underlying features, you can read more about why people hate annuities and their benefits.

High Fees and Costs

  • Variable fees: Some variable annuities cost up to 2% to 4% annually in administrative and management fees.
  • Commissions: Financial advisors often earn large, hidden upfront commissions for selling complex annuities, which can incentivize bad alignment with your actual needs.

Lack of Liquidity (Illiquidity)

  • Locked-up cash: Many income annuities require you to hand over a lump sum permanently in exchange for regular payments, meaning you lose control of the principal.
  • Surrender charges: Withdrawing your money early can trigger steep surrender charges that last for several years and sometimes reach up to 25%.

Inflation Risk

  • Fixed payouts lose power: If you choose a fixed lifetime payout without an inflation rider, the rising cost of living will shrink the real purchasing power of your monthly check over time.
  • Expensive riders: Adding inflation protection often cuts your initial payout size significantly (sometimes by 30% to 50%).

Complexity and Missed Market Gains

  • Capped returns: Fixed index annuities protect your principal from market drops, but they also cap your maximum upside earnings during strong market years.
  • Confusing rules: The contracts feature complex rules, fine print, and tax treatments that are taxed as ordinary income rather than lower capital gains rates.

How much will a $100,000 annuity pay monthly?

A $100,000 single-premium immediate annuity (SPIA) will typically pay between $525 and $1,000+ per month for life. The exact amount depends heavily on your age, gender, and the payout structure you select.

Because life insurance companies calculate payouts using life expectancy, older buyers receive higher monthly checks (as the insurer expects to make fewer total payments). Additionally, men receive slightly higher payouts than women of the same age due to shorter average life expectancies.

Estimated Monthly Payouts by Age and Gender

The following table outlines what a $100,000 immediate fixed annuity generates monthly under a Single Life Only structure (maximizing monthly income with no survivor benefits):

Age at PurchaseMonthly Payout (Male)Monthly Payout (Female)
Age 60$565 – $579$503 – $565
Age 65$625 – $644$584 – $616
Age 70$698 – $729$668 – $689
Age 75$817$770
Age 80$1,006$934

How Payout Structures Impact Your Check

Choosing to protect a spouse or leave money to heirs will reduce your monthly income stream:

  • Single Life Only: Highest payout. Payments stop entirely when you pass away, and any remaining principal is kept by the insurance company.
  • Joint and Survivor: Continues paying as long as either you or your spouse is alive. For a couple both aged 65, this drops the monthly payout to roughly $530 to $560.
  • Period Certain (e.g., 10 or 20 Years): Guarantees payments for life, but if you pass away early, your beneficiaries receive the checks for the remainder of the chosen term. A 20-year certain option for a 65-year-old male drops the payout to about $577.
  • Cash Refund: If you pass away before receiving your initial $100,000 back via monthly installments, the remainder is paid to your heirs in a lump sum. For a 65-year-old male, this yields roughly $606.

Hidden Costs & Strategy Notes

  • Inflation Risk: Fixed immediate annuities do not automatically adjust for inflation. A $600 check today will buy significantly less 15 years from now. Adding an inflation rider is possible, but it severely lowers your initial monthly payout.
  • Irreversibility: Once you buy an immediate annuity, you generally surrender control of the $100,000 principal in exchange for the lifetime income. You cannot withdraw the cash for unexpected emergencies.
  • Taxation: If bought with "pre-tax" retirement funds (like a Traditional IRA), the entire monthly payment is taxed as ordinary income. If bought with "after-tax" cash, only the interest portion of each check is taxed.

To tailor this guidance, how old are you, and are you looking for an income stream that covers just yourself or a spouse as well?

Is there a better investment than an annuity?

Whether an investment is "better" than an annuity depends entirely on your financial goals, as annuities are insurance products designed for guaranteed lifetime income rather than maximum market growth.

If your primary goal is higher growth, flexibility, or lower fees, several alternatives outperform annuities:

For Growth and Market Returns

  • Stocks, Mutual Funds, and ETFs: These offer significantly higher long-term return potential than annuities by participating directly in the market. They also provide much better liquidity and lower internal fees, though they lack downside protection and guaranteed income.
  • Low-Cost Retirement Accounts (IRAs and 401(k)s): Standard tax-advantaged accounts give you full control over your asset allocation with a fraction of the administrative or rider fees found in variable and indexed annuities.

For Safety and Principal Protection

  • Certificates of Deposit (CDs) and Treasury Bonds: If you want to protect your principal without complex fee structures, high-yield CDs (which carry FDIC insurance up to $250,000) and U.S. Treasuries offer predictable returns with complete transparency and no hidden surrender charges.
  • Bond Ladders: Staggering bond maturity dates can create a reliable, predictable stream of fixed income for a specific number of years while allowing you to retain direct ownership of your principal.

When an Annuity Might Still Be Better

Annuities are hard to beat if your main worry is longevity risk—the distinct possibility that you will outlive your savings. Traditional investments like bond ladders or stock portfolios can run out of money, whereas a lifetime income annuity pays out for as long as you live.