Why is a Medigap plan better than an advantage plan?

Asked by: Prof. Josie Olson  |  Last update: July 30, 2025
Score: 4.6/5 (30 votes)

The biggest difference between Medicare Supplement Insurance, also known as Medigap, and Medicare Advantage is that with a Medigap plan, you have the freedom to see any doctor that accepts Medicare. With Medicare Advantage, you generally must get care within the plan's network of providers.

What is the downside to Medigap plans?

There are a couple of cons to consider before choosing a Medigap plan: Premiums: Medigap premiums can be pricey. Coverage: Medicare Supplement plans don't cover everything, so you'd still have to pay out of pocket for things like dental care, vision care and long-term care.

Why would I choose Medigap over Medicare Advantage?

A Medicare supplement, or Medigap, offers comprehensive coverage but may have higher premiums. Medicare Advantage plans, on the other hand, provide additional benefits and often lower out-of-pocket costs but come with network restrictions.

What is the biggest disadvantage of Medicare Advantage?

The biggest disadvantage of Medicare Advantage is that you have fewer doctors to choose from when you get medical care.
  • Plans can also cost more overall than Original Medicare if you have complex medical needs. ...
  • With some plans, you don't have any coverage if you use a doctor that isn't in the network.

Why do doctors not like Medicare Advantage plans?

Across the country, provider grumbling about claim denials and onerous preapproval requirements by Advantage plans is crescendoing. Some hospitals and physician practices are so fed up they're refusing to accept the plans — even big ones like those offered by UnitedHealthcare and Humana.

Medicare Advantage vs Supplement | Most Get This Wrong

31 related questions found

Why are people leaving Medicare Advantage plans?

Key takeaways: People leave Medicare Advantage plans because out-of-pocket costs vary between plans, network restrictions can cause frustration, prior authorization requests can delay care, and it can be difficult to use the additional benefits they provide.

What is the best medicare plan that covers everything for seniors?

Original Medicare with Medigap likely offers the most comprehensive coverage, but it may also be the most costly. A person can consider their income and how much they are able to spend before choosing a Medicare plan. Original Medicare with Medigap also offers a lot of flexibility when choosing a doctor or specialist.

Why is a plan G better than an advantage plan?

Medigap Plan G offers more comprehensive benefits than the Medicare Advantage plan and is more widely available. It also provides more freedom for enrollees. For example, a Medigap Plan G enrollee can visit a specialist without a referral.

Can I drop my Medicare Advantage plan and go back to original Medicare?

Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period: Between January 1 and March 31 of each year, if you already have a Medicare Advantage Plan (with or without drug coverage) you can: Switch to another Medicare Advantage Plan (with or without drug coverage). Drop your Medicare Advantage Plan and return to Original Medicare.

Do all hospitals accept Medicare Advantage plans?

While most hospitals do accept Original Medicare, there may be some that do not accept Medicare Advantage Plans. However, if you have a medical emergency while you're enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan, you can seek care at any ER or hospital in the country.

What does Medigap not pay for?

Medigap plans generally don't cover: Long-term care (like care in a nursing home) Vision or dental care. Hearing aids.

Why is Medicare Advantage not a good plan?

Disadvantages of Medicare Advantage plans can include difficulty switching out of the plans later, restrictions on care access, limited provider networks, and limitations on extra benefits.

What percentage of retirees have Medigap?

This is one reason why a much smaller share of traditional Medicare beneficiaries under age 65 and older have a Medigap policy compared with people age 65 and older (7% versus 46%). In addition, people under age 65 are more likely to have no supplemental coverage compared to people 65 and older (17% vs.

Is Medigap being phased out?

For example, Medigap plans C and F will no longer be available to new Medicare recipients after January 1st, 2020.

Why is it not a good idea to have supplemental insurance?

One of the most significant drawbacks of supplemental insurance policies is the coverage limits. For instance, with Mechanical Repair Coverage, you'll typically need to pay out of pocket until your deductible is met on your primary policy before supplemental insurance takes over to cover a costly vehicle repair.

Do Medigap plans cost more as you age?

Insurance companies set prices for Medigap policies in 1 of 3 ways: Attained-Age Rating — This is the most common way policies are priced in California. Attained age-rated policies increase in price as you age, because as you get older, you typically require more health care.

Why are hospitals refusing Medicare Advantage plans?

Among the most commonly cited reasons are excessive prior authorization denial rates and slow payments from insurers. In 2023, Becker's began reporting on hospitals and health systems nationwide that dropped some or all of their Medicare Advantage contracts.

Is there a penalty for switching from Medicare Advantage to Medigap?

While there's no penalty for switching from Medicare Advantage to Medigap, you may face higher Medigap premiums due to preexisting conditions if you enroll outside of the initial enrollment period. You could also face a penalty if you add Part D coverage.

Are there any 5 star Medicare Advantage plans?

"There isn't one Medicare Advantage plan that's the highest-rated; there are multiple plans that get an overall rating of 5 stars, which is the highest rating from CMS.

What is the best supplemental insurance for Medicare?

The best Medicare supplement plan providers
  • Best for extra plan benefits: Humana.
  • Best for straightforward coverage: State Farm.
  • Best for extensive medical care coverage: AARP by UnitedHealthcare.
  • Best for a range of Medigap plans: Blue Cross Blue Shield.

Why do people choose original Medicare over Medicare Advantage?

There's no one-size-fits-all answer, but Medicare Advantage typically has lower premiums and optional coverage, while Original Medicare often gives you more choice when it comes to choosing doctors.

What is the disadvantage of UnitedHealthcare?

Cons About UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage

You may only have access to certain HMO or PPO plans in your area. And while UnitedHealthCare has competitive pricing, your location may only have access to plans with higher deductibles, more copays, and fewer additional benefits.

Does everyone have to pay $170 a month for Medicare?

Most people pay no premiums for Part A. For Medicare Part B in 2025, most beneficiaries will pay $185 per month. Certain factors may require you to pay more or less than the standard Medicare Part B premium in 2025.