Why is capping insulin prices bad?

Asked by: Mrs. Monica Metz  |  Last update: September 28, 2023
Score: 4.4/5 (40 votes)

Creating Price Caps for Insulin Hurts Health Care
When supply is low and demand is high, prices rise or, in this case, where businesses are constrained, profits must be funneled away from research and innovation. Numerous economic studies indicate price caps reduce the number of new drugs being brought into the market.

What does it mean to cap insulin prices?

Eli Lilly announced they are lowering the cost of insulin by 70% and capping what patients pay out-of-pocket for insulin at $35. This action, driven by the momentum from the Inflation Reduction Act, could benefit millions of Americans with diabetes in all fifty states and U.S. territories.

Why insulin should not be cheaper?

Making Insulin Cheaper Isn't Enough. If the drug becomes significantly cheaper than newer, better diabetes treatments, more people could die from the disease.

Will insulin prices be capped?

and Raphael Warnock (D-Ga.) today introduced the bipartisan Affordable Insulin Now Act of 2023 to cap the price of insulin for all patients, including those who are uninsured, at $35 for a 30-day supply.

Why insulin is overpriced in the US?

Insulin is a protein molecule, so it's a lot more complicated than small molecules,” Tichy said. “So, there's only a couple of companies that make it and if more companies enter the market, then that would sort of drop the prices.”

Despite $35 insulin price cap, pricing pressure continues

44 related questions found

Will insulin ever be affordable?

Today, Lilly is reducing the list price of insulins by: Cutting the list price of its non-branded insulin, Insulin Lispro Injection 100 units/mL, to $25 a vial. Effective May 1, 2023 , it will be the lowest list-priced mealtime insulin available, and less than the price of a Humalog® vial in 1999.

Who sets the price of insulin in the US?

Doescher: Pharmaceutical companies or manufacturers develop the insulin and set a list price. Then you have wholesalers who transport the insulin and sell it to the pharmacy. The patient, you and me, pays the copay amount to the pharmacist, then the pharmacy sends a bill to the insurer.

Is insulin price gouging?

Eli Lilly, Novo Nordisk, and Sanofi make up roughly 90% of the insulin market in the United States—a market that for decades has been characterized by skyrocketing costs and unbelievable price gouging. Some might say that these price capping announcements are examples of corporate responsibility.

Why is Eli Lilly capping insulin?

This price cap will help those with high-deductible insurance or plans that come with a high cost-share instead of set co-pays. In these cases, the insurer might pay 80% of the cost and the patient would cover the remaining 20%—of the drug's list price—a massive financial burden for many.

How many states have capped insulin prices?

To date, 22 states and the District of Columbia have capped copayments on insulin, devices, or diabetes supplies for state-regulated health insurance plans. Below is information for each of those states.

What percentage of Americans Cannot afford insulin?

The new findings, published Oct. 18 in the Annals of Internal Medicine, are based on data from an ongoing federal health survey. In 2021, it included 982 U.S. adults with diabetes who used insulin. Overall, 16.5% said they'd rationed insulin in the past year -- translating to 1.3 million Americans with diabetes.

How do diabetics afford insulin?

Insulin manufacturers provide insulin at no cost through their patient assistance programs to people who are uninsured and meet income eligibility requirements. For more information about manufacturer patient assistance programs, visit InsulinHelp.org.

How to get insulin for $35?

Through the Lilly Insulin Value Program, all Lilly insulins are available for $35 a month whether you have commercial insurance or no insurance. These savings cover all Lilly insulins. Terms and conditions apply.

What does the $35 cap on insulin mean?

Lilly's new $35 out-of-pocket cap means that privately insured patients and those without insurance requiring insulin will spend no more than that monthly for copays.

Why did Eli Lilly reduce insulin prices?

The big drug company said its action was all about helping diabetes patients, its goal being to “help Americans who may have difficulty navigating a complex healthcare system that may keep them from getting affordable insulin.”

Did the insulin price Reduction Act passed?

In August 2022, Democrats in Congress passed the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), which is already lowering costs and improving health care for millions of Americans. Effective January 1, 2023, insulin copays are capped at $35 per month for more than three million people with diabetes covered by Medicare.

Does Eli Lilly overcharge for insulin?

In recent years, Lilly has seen a good deal of criticism over the pricing of its insulin products. In January, California Attorney General Rob Bonta filed a lawsuit against Lilly and other insulin manufacturers, alleging the companies used their market power to overcharge diabetes patients for insulin.

How much does it cost to make 1 vial of insulin?

A 2018 study estimated it costs roughly $2 to $4 to produce a vial of analog insulin, the type used by most patients. Most of the insulin list price increases have gone to PBMs, the go-between companies.

Why does Trulicity cost so much?

Trulicity is a brand-name medication approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to help lower blood sugar levels in people with type 2 diabetes. It may reduce the risk of heart attack or other cardiovascular problems in patients with diabetes. Because no generic is available for Trulicity, it is expensive.

Who has a monopoly on insulin?

Second, there is virtual monopoly on insulin that has been sustained for decades. Three companies, Novo Nordisk, Sanofi-Aventis, and Eli Lilly control most of the market.

What is the real cost of insulin?

For those without health insurance, the older human insulins cost anywhere from $25 to $100 per vial; for example, Walmart has human insulin available at $25 per vial. The newer human analog insulins cost between $174 to $300 per vial, according to a report published in 2018.

Is it legal to sell your extra insulin?

It is illegal to distribute or receive any prescription drug without a license, but because insulin is not a controlled substance, the penalties for trading the substance are murky.

Who pays the most for insulin?

Those with private insurance or no insurance paid the most out-of-pocket for insulin, followed by those with Medicare. Individuals with Medicaid or other insurance coverage paid the lowest out-of-pocket costs.

Who is the biggest provider of insulin?

DAVENPORT, Iowa — The three largest insulin manufacturers, Eli Lilly, Novo Nordisk and Sanofi who supply 90% of the U.S. Insulin market, all have capped prices of Insulin to $35 for most users.