Will insurance pay for a stolen car if the keys were left in it?
Asked by: Itzel Dare | Last update: June 12, 2025Score: 4.6/5 (27 votes)
What happens if you leave keys in a car and it gets stolen?
First and foremost, you can rest easy; as long as you have comprehensive insurance, the theft will be covered! We've got all the details on if insurance covers a stolen car and the process of replacing your lost car keys in the guide below.
Will insurance pay out if keys are left in the car?
Drivers in that situation may be wondering “Does insurance cover a stolen car if the keys are left inside?” If you have a comprehensive insurance plan, then you are most likely covered if your vehicle is stolen and the keys are inside. However, this will vary from plan to plan and the specifics of your circumstances.
How much will insurance pay for a stolen car?
Car Theft Insurance: When Am I Entitled to Coverage? Downey drivers whose cars are stolen in Califonia will have car theft insurance if they have comprehensive coverage. That should cover you up to the Actual Cash Value (ACV) of your vehicle. If your car is damaged due to a break-in, you'll also be covered.
Does Progressive insurance cover stolen car if keys left?
Comprehensive coverage will cover a stolen car, including its keys, but it won't cover lost keys. Other kinds of insurance — like homeowners — may also cover car keys in case of theft.
If your car is stolen, will insurance cover it?
How long does insurance take to pay out a stolen car?
How long does it take for insurance to pay out on a stolen vehicle? The timeframe of an insurance payout for a stolen vehicle varies based on the company. But in general, you should expect the funds after a 30-day waiting period.
How does insurance determine the value of a stolen car?
Insurance companies generally use your car's ACV to determine whether it's a total loss after an accident. If you have comprehensive or collision coverage, most auto insurance policies will also largely base your payment on the car's ACV after it's totaled or stolen.
Do you get money if your car was stolen?
If someone steals your car and you have comprehensive coverage, your insurance provider will pay out based on your vehicle's actual cash value. This doesn't mean they give you the amount you paid for your car. Instead, they pay out the cost to replace it minus depreciation.
Do I have to pay a deductible if my car is stolen?
If the vehicle is declared a total loss, your insurance company pays the actual cash value, just as they would if the car was stolen and not recovered. In both situations, your deductible would apply and be deducted from the claim payout.
What happens if your car gets stolen and you don't have full coverage?
Unfortunately, if your car is stolen and you don't have insurance coverage, you may be responsible for the full cost of replacing your vehicle. When a car is stolen, the owner typically files a police report and notifies their insurance company.
Can you report a car stolen if they have the keys?
As others have, yes if the title is in your name, you can report the car stolen. Keep in mind that once you have reported the car stolen, anyone driving it can be arrested and booked into a jail for a potential felony charge.
How does Progressive handle stolen vehicles?
Stolen vehicles are protected by comprehensive coverage
This may be true even if the car was stolen with the keys in it. If you recover your vehicle, but it sustained damage while stolen, the repairs should be covered by comprehensive. In both situations, your comprehensive auto deductible would apply.
What should I do if I left my keys in my car?
Don't panic, and don't resort to breaking in. You have many options for getting into your car when your keys are locked inside, including a locksmith, tow service, your dealer, a family member with a spare key, or even roadside assistance through your insurer.
Will insurance pay if car is stolen with keys in it?
If you have comprehensive coverage on the vehicle, then you're generally covered if it's stolen — even if you left the keys in the car. If you're a victim of auto theft, contact your local police station to file a report, then get in touch with your insurance company.
What happens if you permanently lose your car keys?
If you don't have an extra key, you'll likely need to get a replacement at a dealership and provide proof of ownership, according to Carfax. The dealership will then program a new key to work with your car. This may take a few days, during which they will need to hold onto the car.
How long after a car is stolen does insurance pay?
The average timeframe for a stolen car insurance claim payout falls within 30-45 days, but several factors can influence this, such as the complexity of the investigation, the availability of the police report, and whether your car is recovered.
How long does it take to recover a stolen car?
If you report your car as stolen immediately to police, there's a better chance it will be recovered. In fact, according to NICB data, 35% of recovered stolen vehicles are recovered on the same day as the theft, and 45% are recovered within two days.
What to do if someone steals out of your car?
Immediately Contact Law Enforcement and Your Lenders
The first thing you should do is notify your local law enforcement authority that your car was broken into and tell them what items were stolen. A police report is a vital document when recovering from any account fraud or other crimes using your identity.
Does insurance give you a new car if yours is stolen?
If your car is stolen, you would file a police report, then file a car insurance claim. For a covered claim, your insurer would cut you a check for $7,500 (the actual cash value minus your deductible), to help you replace your stolen vehicle.
How much value does a stolen car lose?
The car's next title will be referred to as a salvage title, even if the car is in perfect condition. Previously stolen cars with a salvage title can lose anywhere from 20% to 40% of their original value.
What usually happens when a car is stolen?
After you've filed a report with the police, the next call you need to make is to your insurance company. They will guide you through the process of filing a claim. Be prepared to provide them with information such as your policy number, the police report number and any other relevant details they may require.
Does your insurance go up after your car is stolen?
Claiming a stolen vehicle becomes a part of your insurance claim history. While comprehensive claims are generally not viewed as negatively as at-fault accidents, multiple claims, including theft claims, can still affect your premiums. Location Matters: The area where your car was stolen may influence your rates.
Can you negotiate insurance payout for a totaled car?
Yes, you can negotiate with the insurance company if your car is totaled. However, just like other types of claims, you should understand the potential value of your case and take this into account before accepting an offer from the insurer.
How do insurance companies pay out claims on a car?
Check. One common payment method is issuing a check directly to the policyholder. If your claim is approved, the insurance company will send you a check for the agreed-upon amount. This gives you the flexibility to use the funds as needed, whether it's for repairs, medical bills, or other expenses.