What insurance company is with Costco?

Editorial team Published on

Costco partners with American Family Insurance (specifically through its CONNECT by American Family Insurance program) to provide auto, home, and umbrella insurance to its members.

Here are the specific underwriters and partners for other types of insurance offered through Costco:

  • Auto Insurance: Underwritten by American Family Connect Property and Casualty Insurance Company, American Family Connect Insurance Company, or Midvale Indemnity Company.
  • Homeowners/Property Insurance: Underwritten by various subsidiaries of Homesite Insurance.
  • Life Insurance: Handled and underwritten by Protective Life.
  • Pet Insurance: Offered through Figo Pet Insurance.
  • Health Insurance Marketplace: Handled via a partnership with CBC Benefit & Insurance Services for individual and family options.

What insurance companies does Costco partner with?

Costco partners with specific insurance companies through the Costco Insurance Agency to offer discounted rates and special member benefits.

Auto, Home, and Umbrella Insurance

  • CONNECT by American Family Insurance: This is Costco's primary partner for auto, home, and personal umbrella insurance.
  • Underwriters: Auto policies are underwritten by American Family Connect Property and Casualty Insurance Company, American Family Connect Insurance Company, or Midvale Indemnity Company. Home policies are underwritten by Homesite Insurance companies.

Other Insurance Types

  • Life Insurance: Handled and underwritten by Protective Life.
  • Pet Insurance: Offered in partnership with Figo, which is underwritten by Independence American Insurance Company.
  • Medicare Advantage Plans: Partnered with SCAN Health Plan in select counties across California and Nevada.
  • Health, Dental, and Vision Insurance: Offered through the CBC Health Insurance Marketplace for Costco members, featuring multiple carrier networks like Ameritas, Delta Dental, and UnitedHealthcare.

What insurance company is Costco affiliated with?

Costco partners with CONNECT by American Family Insurance for auto and home insurance, and with Protective Life Insurance Company for term life insurance.

Auto and Home Insurance

  • Underwriter: Policies are provided through CONNECT (American Family Connect Property and Casualty Insurance Company) and Homesite for property coverage.
  • Perks: Executive members often get extra benefits like roadside assistance and lifetime renewability.

Life Insurance

  • Provider: Costco offers Member Advantage term life insurance through Protective Life.
  • Details: Rates are discounted exclusively for members.

Is Costco car insurance actually cheaper?

Yes, Costco car insurance is often cheaper on average, but it depends heavily on your location and driving record.

How It Works

  • Costco does not sell insurance directly.
  • They partner with CONNECT (underwritten by American Family Insurance) to offer special member discounts.
  • You can learn more or request an estimate on the Costco Auto and Home Insurance Services page.

Why It Can Be Cheaper

  • Member Discounts: Costco members get lower base rates compared to the general public.
  • Good Driver Savings: CONNECT targets drivers with clean records, offering extra perks for no recent accidents or tickets.
  • Perks: Policies often include extra value like a glass repair deductible waiver for windshields. Executive members may also get roadside assistance and lifetime renewability.

The Catch

  • Not Universally the Lowest: Opinions on Reddit are mixed; some drivers find better deals with other major carriers like State Farm or GEICO.
  • Limited Availability: CONNECT is not available in every state, and they have stopped taking new customers in some areas like California.
  • Best for Clean Records: If you have a poor driving history or need only bare-minimum state coverage, prices may be higher than average.

What are people saying about Costco Protective Life insurance?

Costco’s life insurance program through Protective Life offers competitively priced term coverage with special member perks, though reviewers recommend comparing quotes independently.

General Feedback and Pros

  • Affordable Rates: Many users and reviewers note that the rates offered through the Costco partnership are often lower or more competitive than standard market options.
  • Financial Strength: Protective Life Insurance Company holds high financial stability ratings (such as "AA" from S&P and Moody's), giving buyers confidence in the company's backing.
  • Structure: Forum users on Bogleheads point out that the underlying universal life (UL) product functions essentially like a term policy, keeping things straightforward without building cash value.
  • Flexibility: Policies can generally be canceled at any time without penalty.

Criticisms and Cons

  • Structure Nuances: Some insurance critics, like those noted by NerdWallet, mention that specific Costco-endorsed plans may have premiums that shift or adjust after an initial period (such as the first five years).
  • Limited Options: Costco only sells term-style life insurance through this partnership, meaning those looking for permanent whole-life policies must look elsewhere.
  • Mixed Independent Opinions: Some insurance brokers argue that member-exclusive programs do not always beat every individual profile's best open-market rate, emphasizing the need to shop around.

Costco (CONNECT) Car Insurance: Is It Worth It?

9 related questions found

What are people saying about Costco's auto and home insurance?

People are sharing mixed opinions about auto and home insurance offered through the Costco Insurance Agency and underwritten by American Family Insurance (CONNECT) and Homesite.

General Sentiment and Pricing

  • Initial Savings: Many users on platforms like Reddit and Facebook report getting cheaper initial rates and saving significantly compared to their previous carriers.
  • Premium Increases: A common complaint among customers is that rates often jump higher after the first renewal year, prompting some to switch back to other providers.
  • Perks: Members appreciate specific add-ons like the glass repair deductible waiver for windshields and extra benefits for Executive members.

Claims and Availability

  • Claim Experiences: Experiences vary; some customers praise the smooth handling of smaller auto claims, while others report that major property or home claims can be difficult to navigate.
  • Strict Eligibility: The service tends to cater to safe drivers, meaning high-risk drivers or those with prior major claims may face higher quotes or coverage denials. Additionally, home insurance availability is restricted or unavailable in certain high-risk states like California and Florida.

What is the best homeowners insurance company?

Amica is the best overall homeowners insurance company for customer and claims satisfaction, according to industry rankings from sources like U.S. News & World Report and J.D. Power.

Top Home Insurance Companies by Category

  • Best Overall: Amica ranks highest for customer service and claims handling.
  • Best for Military and Veterans: USAA offers top-tier coverage and high satisfaction, though eligibility is restricted to military families.
  • Best for Large National Provider: State Farm provides low average rates, 24/7 service, and strong local agent networks.
  • Best for High-Value Homes: Chubb specializes in high-value properties with extended replacement cost options.
  • Best for Independent Agents: Auto-Owners Insurance pairs local agents with robust coverage packages.
  • Best for Digital Experience: Lemonade offers a fast, user-friendly app and online claims process.

Key Factors to Consider

  • Customer Satisfaction: Look at how well companies handle claims when emergencies happen.
  • Financial Strength: Verify that the insurer holds strong ratings (like A or A+) from agencies such as AM Best to ensure they can pay out major catastrophes.
  • Cost and Bundling: Compare rates by bundling home and auto policies, which often yields the biggest discounts.

Who is the carrier for Costco auto insurance?

Costco auto insurance is underwritten and serviced by American Family Insurance (formerly branded as CONNECT).

Underwriting Details

  • Primary Carrier: American Family Insurance
  • Underwriting Companies: Policies are officially underwritten by American Family Connect Property and Casualty Insurance Company, American Family Connect Insurance Company, or Midvale Indemnity Company.
  • Brand Change: The service previously known as CONNECT by American Family transitioned to the American Family Insurance brand name on policy documents.

Member Benefits

  • Executive Perks: Executive members may qualify for additional perks like lifetime renewability and 24-hour roadside assistance.
  • Availability: Offered in most U.S. states, excluding Alaska, Maine, North Dakota, Rhode Island, West Virginia, and Wyoming.

Is Costco really selling insurance?

Yes, Costco insurance is completely legitimate.

Costco does not underwrite or issue the policies directly; instead, the Costco Insurance Agency partners with established, highly rated third-party companies—primarily CONNECT by American Family Insurance for auto and home policies.

How It Works

  • Underwriting: Auto policies are backed by American Family Connect or Midvale Indemnity, while home insurance is often through Homesite.
  • Financial Strength: American Family holds an "A (Excellent)" financial rating from AM Best, meaning they have a stable and reliable backing to pay out claims.
  • Exclusive Perks: Members often get lower rates, free roadside assistance for Executive members, and a glass repair deductible waiver on auto policies.

What Real Customers Say

Opinions are mixed regarding customer satisfaction and long-term pricing. As discussed in user forums on Reddit and Facebook, some members report saving a significant amount of money on their initial premiums and having smooth claims experiences. However, others note that rates can jump noticeably after the first year, or mention difficulties with home claims and customer service during major regional catastrophes.

Can I get auto insurance through Costco?

You can get auto insurance through the Costco Auto and Home Insurance Services program, which is underwritten by CONNECT, powered by American Family Insurance.

How It Works

  • Membership Requirement: You must have an active Costco membership to purchase a policy, though you can request a quote online without a membership.
  • Underwriter: Policies are actually provided and serviced by American Family Connect Property and Casualty Insurance Company or its affiliates, not by Costco directly.
  • Availability: The insurance is available in most U.S. states, but it is not offered in Alaska, Maine, North Dakota, Rhode Island, West Virginia, or Wyoming, and new policies are currently restricted in certain states like California and Florida.

Member Benefits & Savings

  • Exclusive Discounts: Members often receive special discounted rates, plus extra savings if they bundle auto policies with home, renters, or umbrella insurance.
  • Executive Perks: Executive members may receive added benefits at no extra cost, such as 24-hour roadside assistance and lifetime renewability in qualifying states.
  • Community Feedback: Most users on Reddit agree that bundling options can provide solid savings, though experiences with claims and customer service can vary.