What is the cheapest insurance company for a bad driving record?

Asked by: Gerard Wiegand  |  Last update: January 14, 2026
Score: 4.5/5 (45 votes)

State Farm is the cheapest major car insurance company for drivers with an accident or speeding ticket on their record. After an accident, full coverage insurance from State Farm costs an average of $154 per month. That's 41% less than the national average.

What car insurance is best with a bad driving record?

Have tickets or accidents on your record? State Farm and Geico are among our top picks for high-risk drivers. Car insurance companies consider motorists with a history of at-fault accidents, speeding tickets or DUI convictions high-risk drivers and charge them some of the highest rates of any demographic.

Does Allstate accept high-risk drivers?

Yes! Direct Auto is a trusted affiliate of Allstate that offers affordable policies, flexible payment options and discounts to high-risk drivers Even if you have a history of violations, accidents or low credit, Direct Auto has options to keep you protected.

Who typically has the cheapest insurance?

Geico, Nationwide and Travelers are among the least expensive for car insurance. Americans are paying a lot for car insurance these days: Average annual rates for a full coverage policy are up to $2,638 per year, while minimum coverage averages $767 per year.

Is Progressive good for bad drivers?

If you've been at fault in an accident, or you have a traffic ticket on your record, Progressive's rates are often higher than most companies. However, if you have a driving under the influence (DUI) conviction, Progressive actually offers cheaper rates than average, at $2,547 per year.

Car Insurance with a Bad Driving Record | Stewardship - Money Well Rooted

19 related questions found

How to get auto insurance with a bad record?

Get a policy from a private insurance company that specializes in “high-risk” drivers –These insurers write "non-standard" policies for people with bad accident records, high-performance cars, or who live in high-risk neighborhoods.

Who is cheaper, GEICO or Progressive?

GEICO is cheaper and has better ratings than Progressive. Your experience with GEICO and Progressive will vary based on individual rating factors.

Is Allstate cheaper than Geico?

GEICO is much cheaper and has better ratings than Allstate. Your experience with GEICO and Allstate will vary based on individual rating factors.

Which type of car insurance is the cheapest?

Typically, fully comprehensive insurance is the least expensive, though prices are influenced by individual circumstances.

What state has the worst insurance rates?

Oklahoma, Kansas, Nebraska, Florida, and Colorado are the most expensive states for homeowners insurance. Oklahoma has the highest average cost of homeowners insurance in the U.S. at $5,858 per year.

How long are you considered a high risk driver?

How long are you considered a high-risk driver? Traffic violations, such as speeding, typically remain on your driving record for 3-5 years, depending on your state. At-fault accidents, DUI convictions, and other more serious violations may be considered for five years or more, depending on your insurer and state.

How do I get around high insurance?

7 ways to lower your car insurance premium
  1. Qualify for insurance discounts. Getting more discounts that lower your car insurance premium might be easier than you think. ...
  2. Increase your deductible. ...
  3. Reduce your coverage. ...
  4. Compare rates. ...
  5. Try usage-based insurance. ...
  6. Take a defensive driving course. ...
  7. Get a car that's cheaper to insure.

What is the cheapest car insurance after license suspension?

Progressive and National General have the cheapest liability car insurance for a suspended license with a major violation. Progressive's rates average $91 a month. This is slightly less than National General's average of $104 a month. State Farm has the cheapest liability quotes for a minor violation suspension.

What makes someone uninsurable for car insurance?

Poor driving history is a top reason drivers can face challenges obtaining auto insurance. A track record of collisions, traffic violations, or DUI convictions can make getting coverage difficult and extremely costly. Insurers consider drivers with such records high-risk; some may deny coverage altogether.

Is it fair that people with bad driving records pay more for car insurance?

If you have a bad driving record that includes an at-fault car accident, speeding ticket, or DUI, car insurance companies will typically regard you as a high-risk driver. As such, you can expect to pay higher car insurance rates than people with a clean driving record.

How do insurance companies know your driving record?

Insurance companies obtain Motor Vehicle Reports (MVRs) directly from the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) or relevant authorities. These reports provide a detailed account of your driving history, including traffic violations, accidents, and license status.

How do I get lower car insurance?

Nine ways to lower your auto insurance costs
  1. Shop around. ...
  2. Before you buy a car, compare insurance costs. ...
  3. Ask for higher deductibles. ...
  4. Reduce coverage on older cars. ...
  5. Buy your homeowners and auto coverage from the same insurer. ...
  6. Maintain a good credit record. ...
  7. Take advantage of low mileage discounts. ...
  8. Ask about group insurance.

Who is cheaper, State Farm or Allstate?

State Farm offers cheaper rates on auto and home insurance than Allstate. State Farm also has higher customer service ratings. However, Allstate offers a few home and car insurance coverages that State Farm doesn't have.

Who is cheaper, Allstate or Progressive?

Allstate: Cheapest for drivers with bad credit

In many states, car insurance companies can use a driver's credit history as a factor when determining car insurance premiums. For drivers with bad credit, Allstate once more edges out Progressive with cheaper average premiums.

Is State Farm cheaper than GEICO?

GEICO is cheaper and has better ratings than State Farm. Your experience with GEICO and State Farm will vary based on individual rating factors.

Who can beat GEICO insurance?

Typically, Esurance offers better prices than GEICO for drivers with credit scores of 579 or less. Those with outstanding credit — a score of 800 or better — should opt for Esurance as well, which typically beats GEICO by $295 per year. View average insurance rates by credit tier for GEICO and Esurance below.

What is accident forgiveness?

What is Accident Forgiveness? Available in select states, Accident Forgiveness is an auto insurance coverage option that potentially helps you avoid a rate increase after your first at-fault accident. Others on your policy can also benefit from Accident Forgiveness. But it can only be used once per policy.

Is State Farm cheaper than Progressive?

State Farm has cheaper home and car insurance quotes than Progressive. It also has higher customer satisfaction ratings. However, Progressive offers more discounts and coverage options, including gap insurance. Progressive is better for specialized car insurance coverage.