What's better for knee pain, Voltaren or Biofreeze?

Editorial team Published on

Voltaren and Biofreeze treat knee pain differently, so the right choice depends on whether your pain comes from arthritis and inflammation or a short-term muscle strain. Most users on r/Osteoarthritis agree that Voltaren is generally preferred for joint and arthritis pain.

Voltaren (Diclofenac)

  • Type: Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID).
  • How it works: It penetrates the skin to target and reduce the cellular chemicals causing inflammation and pain inside the joint.
  • Best for: Chronic inflammatory conditions like knee osteoarthritis.
  • How to use: Results build over 7 to 14 days and require consistent use (3 to 4 times a day).
  • Considerations: It has potential drug interactions and warnings for people with specific conditions like high blood pressure or kidney disease.

Biofreeze (Menthol)

  • Type: Topical counterirritant.
  • How it works: Menthol cools cold receptors in the skin to block and distract the brain from pain signals quickly.
  • Best for: Fast, short-term relief, acute muscle soreness, pre-activity, or use during physical therapy.
  • How to use: Works within minutes, but the effect wears off after the application window closes.
  • Considerations: It provides comfort by masking pain, but it does not treat the underlying tissue inflammation or damage.

How does Voltaren gel work?

Voltaren gel works by delivering a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) called diclofenac directly through the skin to target pain and swelling at the source.

Mechanism of Action

  • Blocks COX enzymes: Diclofenac inhibits cyclooxygenase enzymes (COX-1 and COX-2), which the body uses to make prostaglandins.
  • Reduces prostaglandins: Prostaglandins are chemical signals that trigger pain, warmth, and swelling. Lowering these chemicals in the targeted area reduces local inflammation.
  • Penetrates tissue: The gel base helps the medicine pass through the skin layers to pool in underlying muscles, joints, and synovial fluid.
  • Minimizes systemic exposure: Because you apply the gel directly to the painful joint or muscle, less medication enters your bloodstream compared to taking pills by mouth.

Should Voltaren gel be rubbed in?

Yes, you should gently rub Voltaren gel into clean, dry skin over the affected area until it is fully absorbed.

Application Steps

  • Measure the dose: Use the plastic dosing card in the box. Use 2 grams for your hands, wrists, or elbows. Use 4 grams for your knees, ankles, or feet.
  • Rub it in gently: Use your hands to massage the gel into the skin until it covers the entire painful area.
  • Let it dry: Wait at least 10 minutes before you put on clothing or gloves. Do not wash the area for at least 1 hour.

Important Safety Rules

  • Avoid broken skin: Do not put the gel on cuts, open wounds, rashes, or infections.
  • Wash your hands: Wash your hands well after you finish, unless you are treating your hands.
  • No heat or tight wraps: Do not use heating pads or tight bandages over the area.

You can read more safety advice at the Mayo Clinic guide.

What happens if you apply too much Voltaren gel?

Applying too much Voltaren Gel increases the amount of diclofenac absorbed into your bloodstream, which can cause systemic side effects and signs of an NSAID overdose.

Local Skin Reactions

  • Severe skin irritation, redness, or dryness
  • Scaling, itching, or blistering at the application site

Systemic Toxicity and Overdose Signs

  • Stomach issues: Nausea, vomiting, severe abdominal pain, or black and tarry stools indicating gastrointestinal bleeding
  • Kidney stress: Decreased urine output and swelling in the legs or feet from fluid retention
  • Neurological effects: Dizziness, drowsiness, headache, or confusion
  • Cardiovascular risks: Increased blood pressure, rapid heart rate, or elevated risk of heart attack and stroke

What to Do

If you accidentally apply too much, wipe off any excess gel from the skin immediately. If large amounts are used, or if anyone swallows the gel, contact emergency services or call the Poison Help line at 1-800-222-1222 right away.

Why should people over 65 not use Voltaren?

People over 65 should use Voltaren (diclofenac) with caution or avoid it because aging bodies process nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) differently, raising the risk of severe systemic side effects.

Health Risks for Older Adults

  • Stomach Bleeding: NSAIDs irritate the digestive lining, causing a higher risk of ulcers and gastrointestinal bleeding.
  • Kidney Damage: Aging kidneys filter blood less efficiently; NSAIDs reduce blood flow to the kidneys, which can trigger rapid decline or failure.
  • Heart Complications: These drugs cause fluid retention, which can worsen high blood pressure and congestive heart failure, and increase the risk of heart attacks and strokes.

Oral vs. Topical Form

  • Pills vs. Gels: Oral NSAIDs carry the highest systemic risks and cause thousands of hospitalizations in older adults each year.
  • Topical Safety: Topical Voltaren gel delivers medication locally through the skin with much lower absorption into the bloodstream (about 3% to 7%), making it a safer option than pills for many seniors, though heart and kidney warnings still apply.

Compare Voltaren, Biofreeze, Hempvana and CBD creams for Pain, Arthritis by a Physical Therapist

9 related questions found

Is it okay to use Voltaren on knees?

Yes, it is safe and approved to use Voltaren Gel on your knees for arthritis pain.

How to Use It Correctly

  • Dose: Use the enclosed dosing card and measure a 4-gram line (about 4.5 inches) for each knee.
  • Frequency: Apply it up to four times a day on the affected knee.
  • Application: Rub the gel gently into clean, dry, and intact skin. Do not put it on open cuts or wounds.
  • Limits: Do not use it on more than two body parts at the same time. Do not use heating pads or cover the area with tight bandages after applying.

Safety and Precautions

  • Allergies: Do not use Voltaren if you are allergic to aspirin or other NSAIDs like ibuprofen.
  • Duration: Stop use and talk to a doctor if your pain does not improve after 7 days, or if you need to use it for more than 21 days in a row.
  • Health Conditions: Check with a doctor first if you have heart disease, high blood pressure, kidney or liver disease, stomach ulcers, or if you are pregnant.

What to avoid when using Voltaren gel?

When using Voltaren Gel, you must avoid applying it to open wounds, broken skin, infections, or areas with a rash.

Application and Skin Habits to Avoid

  • Do not use heat or bandages: Avoid covering the treated area with bandages or exposing it to external heat sources like heating pads, hot tubs, or saunas. Heat and wrapping increase how much medicine your body absorbs.
  • Do not apply skin products on top: Avoid putting cosmetics, sunscreen, lotions, bug spray, or other topical medications on the exact same skin spot.
  • Do not wash it off right away: Wait at least 1 hour after applying before you shower, bathe, or wash the area.
  • Do not touch sensitive areas: Avoid getting the gel in your eyes, nose, or mouth. Wash your hands thoroughly after application unless your hands are the treated joint.
  • Avoid sunlight: Minimize exposing the treated skin to direct sunlight or tanning beds.

Medications and Substances to Avoid

  • Other NSAIDs and aspirin: Avoid taking oral NSAIDs (like ibuprofen, naproxen, or oral diclofenac) or aspirin unless your doctor specifically approves it. Combining them raises your risk of stomach ulcers and bleeding, even though the gel is topical. Always check over-the-counter cold, flu, or pain medication labels first.
  • Alcohol: Limit or avoid drinking alcohol, which further increases your risk of stomach bleeding and gastrointestinal ulcers when combined with NSAIDs.
  • Blood thinners: Use extreme caution or avoid combining with anticoagulants (like warfarin) without medical supervision due to bleeding risks.

Health Conditions Requiring Caution

  • Heart or cardiovascular history: Avoid use if you just had coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery. Use with extreme caution if you have high blood pressure, heart failure, or a history of heart attacks/strokes.
  • Kidney or liver disease: Avoid or limit use if you have severe kidney or liver impairment, as the medication can worsen organ function.
  • Aspirin-induced asthma: Do not use if you have a history of asthma attacks or severe allergic reactions triggered by aspirin or other NSAIDs.
  • Pregnancy: Avoid use if you are pregnant past 20 weeks.

Is it bad to use Voltaren gel every day?

Using over-the-counter Voltaren Gel every day is generally safe and intended for continuous daily use up to 21 days for arthritis pain, provided you follow the package directions.

Safe Daily Use Guidelines

  • Frequency: Apply up to four times a day on the affected joints.
  • Limits: Use it on no more than two body parts at the same time.
  • Duration: Stop use and talk to a doctor if your pain lasts more than 21 days.
  • Measurement: Use the included dosing card to measure 2 grams for upper joints (hands, wrists, elbows) or 4 grams for lower joints (feet, ankles, knees).

Risks of Misuse or Overuse

Using too much gel, applying it to too many areas, or using it alongside oral NSAIDs (like ibuprofen or naproxen) increases the risk of side effects:

  • Stomach Issues: Risk of ulcers and gastrointestinal bleeding.
  • Heart Risks: Potential increased risk of high blood pressure, heart attack, or stroke.
  • Organ Strain: Overuse can affect liver and kidney function.

Do not use Voltaren gel if you have a history of allergic reactions to aspirin or other NSAIDs, or if you are undergoing heart bypass surgery. Check the official Voltaren Arthritis Pain Gel FAQ for more safety details.

What organ is Voltaren hard on?

Voltaren (diclofenac) is hardest on the stomach (gastrointestinal tract), the kidneys, and the heart/cardiovascular system. It can also impact the liver.

Like all nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), Voltaren works by blocking enzymes that trigger pain, but these same enzymes protect vital organ functions. While oral Voltaren tablets pose the highest risk, topical Voltaren gel still carries these risks because a small amount is absorbed into the bloodstream.

Voltaren impacts specific organs in the following ways:

1. The Stomach and Intestines

The gastrointestinal tract is highly susceptible to NSAID damage. Voltaren reduces the protective lining of the stomach, which can cause:

  • Stomach ulcers and severe irritation.
  • Gastrointestinal bleeding or perforations (holes in the stomach or intestinal walls), which can be life-threatening.

2. The Kidneys

Kidneys rely on specific compounds to maintain proper blood flow. Voltaren restricts this flow, potentially leading to:

  • Fluid retention and swelling (edema) in the hands, ankles, or feet.
  • Acute kidney injury or kidney failure, particularly in individuals who already have kidney disease or are dehydrated.

3. The Heart and Blood Vessels

Voltaren carries a "black box warning" regarding cardiovascular risks. It can cause:

  • Increased blood pressure, making existing hypertension harder to control.
  • An elevated risk of heart attack or stroke, even with short-term use.
  • Worsening of heart failure due to dangerous fluid buildup.

4. The Liver

Though less common than stomach or kidney irritation, Voltaren can be hard on the liver. It can cause elevated liver enzymes, indicating liver inflammation, and in rare cases can lead to severe liver injury or liver failure.

How to Reduce the Risk

If you are using oral tablets, always take them with food and use the lowest effective dose for the shortest time possible. If you are using the topical gel, apply it exactly as directed and avoid applying it to broken skin. If you have a history of heart, kidney, liver, or stomach issues, consult your doctor before using any form of Voltaren.

What is the safest anti-inflammatory for seniors?

Acetaminophen (such as Tylenol) is generally the safest over-the-counter pain reliever for seniors, though it is an analgesic rather than a true anti-inflammatory drug. When true inflammation reduction is needed, oral non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) carry high risks for older adults, making topical options or careful medical supervision essential.

Understanding Pain and Inflammation Relief Options

  • Acetaminophen (Tylenol): Relieves general pain safely at standard doses (typically under 3,000 mg daily), avoiding the stomach and kidney hazards tied to anti-inflammatory pills. It does not treat inflammation itself.
  • Topical NSAIDs (Voltaren / Diclofenac): Gels applied directly to a painful joint provide localized relief. They pose fewer whole-body risks than oral pills while actively lowering local inflammation.
  • COX-2 Inhibitors (Celecoxib / Celebrex): Prescription options designed to be gentler on the stomach lining than traditional NSAIDs. They still require monitoring for kidney and heart health.

Risks of Traditional Oral Anti-Inflammatories

  • Stomach issues: Drugs like ibuprofen and naproxen raise the risk of ulcers and internal bleeding.
  • Kidney strain: Regular use can reduce blood flow to the kidneys, worsening blood pressure and kidney function.
  • Heart risks: Oral NSAIDs can cause fluid retention or increase cardiovascular event rates in vulnerable older adults.