When can you get indemnity costs?

Editorial team Published on

You can get indemnity costs when a court exercises its discretion to award them due to exceptional circumstances, unreasonable conduct, or specific settlement offer rules.

🛑 Common Situations for Indemnity Costs

  • Rejection of formal settlement offers (such as beating a Part 36 Offer in UK-style jurisdictions).
  • Unreasonable or improper conduct by the losing party that goes "out of the norm" of standard litigation.
  • Abuse of the court process, fraud, or advancing a case on a false basis.
  • Contractual terms that explicitly and unambiguously provide for indemnity-scale cost recovery upon enforcement.
  • Specific fiduciary or representative entitlements, such as certain costs payable to trustees or personal representatives.

📊 Standard vs. Indemnity Costs

  • 📉 Standard Basis: Recovers a fair, reasonable, and proportionate amount, typically yielding roughly 60% to 80% of actual legal bills.
  • 📈 Indemnity Basis: Recovers all reasonably incurred costs without proportionality limits, shifting the burden of proving unreasonableness to the paying party and yielding up to 85%–100% of the bill.

When can you seek indemnity costs?

Indemnity costs are awarded when the conduct of a party or the nature of a case takes it "out of the norm" of standard litigation.

Unlike standard costs, indemnity costs do not require the amount to be proportionate, and any doubt over whether an expense is reasonable is resolved in favour of the receiving party.

When Are Indemnity Costs Awarded?

Courts have broad discretion, but they commonly award indemnity costs in the following situations:

  • Unreasonable Conduct: A party behaves in a particularly unreasonable, improper, or vexatious way during the legal proceedings.
  • Failing to Beat a Part 36 Offer: A claimant makes a formal settlement offer under Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) Part 36 that the defendant rejects, and the claimant later achieves a judgment at trial that is at least as advantageous as their offer.
  • Weak or Speculative Claims: A party pursues a case that is manifestly weak, thin, or speculative, or continues running claims long after their position becomes impossible to justify.
  • Dishonesty or Lack of Integrity: There is evidence of dishonesty, bad faith, or serious misconduct in how the case or evidence was handled.
  • Specific Rules: Certain provisions in the CPR dictate indemnity costs automatically, such as in specific trustee proceedings or solicitor-client assessments.

What are indemnity costs and what are they considered?

Indemnity costs are a type of legal cost order where the losing party in a lawsuit must pay a much higher percentage of the winning party's legal fees than usual.

How Indemnity Costs Work

  • Higher Recovery: Standard costs usually cover about 60% to 75% of legal bills. Indemnity costs often cover roughly 70% to 90% (or more) of the actual expenses incurred.
  • Reversed Burden of Proof: Under a standard basis, the winner must prove every cost was reasonable. Under an indemnity basis, any doubt is resolved in favor of the winning party, meaning the paying party must prove the costs are unreasonable.
  • No Proportionality Rule: Regular costs must be proportionate to the value and complexity of the case. Indemnity costs drop this requirement, focusing only on whether the expenses were reasonably incurred.

When Courts Award Indemnity Costs

Courts do not award these costs as a default. They use them as a penalty or deterrent when a party acts "out of the norm". Common triggers include:

  • Bad Behavior: Engaging in fraud, dishonesty, perjury, or bad faith during the case.
  • Hopeless Claims: Pursuing a claim or defense that has no reasonable prospect of success.
  • Abuse of Process: Starting a lawsuit for an improper or malicious purpose.
  • Rejected Settlement Offers: Failing to beat a formal, reasonable settlement offer (such as a Part 36 offer in the UK).

What are the three types of indemnity?

The three main types of express indemnity clauses found in contracts (especially in construction and business agreements) are broad form, intermediate form, and limited form.

1. Broad Form Indemnity

  • Definition: The indemnitor (the party paying for protection) agrees to cover all losses and liabilities, even if the indemnitee (the protected party) is 100% at fault.
  • Impact: Places the highest possible risk on the person signing the indemnity agreement.
  • Note: Many states restrict or completely ban broad form indemnity in certain industries, like construction, because it is unfair.

2. Intermediate Form Indemnity

  • Definition: The indemnitor covers all losses, damages, and claims, except when the loss is caused solely by the negligence or fault of the indemnitee.
  • Impact: If both parties share some blame, or if the indemnitor is at fault, the indemnitor pays for the entire loss. If the indemnitee is completely at fault alone, the indemnitor does not have to pay.

3. Limited Form Indemnity

  • Definition: The indemnitor is responsible only for the portion of a loss that is directly caused by their own negligence or the negligence of their workers.
  • Impact: This is the most balanced and narrow type of protection. Each party remains responsible for their own share of mistakes and resulting damages.

What are the disadvantages of indemnity insurance?

Indemnity insurance can have high costs and strict limits that leave you to pay extra money out of your own pocket.

High Costs and Fees

  • Expensive premiums: Monthly or yearly costs for indemnity policies are often very high compared to other types of coverage.
  • Higher out-of-pocket costs: You may still have to pay large amounts for deductibles, copays, or coinsurance before the policy kicks in.
  • Rate increases after a claim: Filing a single claim can cause your insurance company to raise your future rates.

Coverage Limits and Gaps

  • Payout caps: Plans often have maximum payout limits. If a legal judgment or medical bill goes above that limit, you must pay the rest.
  • Strict exclusions: Most policies do not cover intentional wrongdoing, fraud, illegal acts, or pre-existing conditions.
  • No fix for root problems: Property or title indemnity insurance only covers financial loss; it does not actually fix the legal defect or stop a local council from enforcing rules.

Restrictions and Rules

  • No contact rules: Property indemnity policies often become invalid if you try to contact or alert the third party involved (like a neighbor or local council) about the property defect.
  • Claims-made limits: If you have a claims-made policy, you get no coverage for past incidents unless you report them while the policy is actively running.
  • Complex terms: The fine print can be very hard to read and understand without help from a legal expert or broker.

What do "partial indemnity" and "substantial indemnity" mean in costs?

9 related questions found

Is indemnity a promise to pay?

Yes, an indemnity is a direct promise to pay or compensate another party for specific losses, damages, or liabilities.

How It Works

  • Primary obligation: It is a first-hand promise to cover a loss when a specific trigger event happens. You do not have to wait to prove someone else breached a contract.
  • Risk shifting: One party (the indemnitor) takes on the financial risk of a potential future event to protect the other party (the indemnitee).
  • Common examples: Insurance policies are a everyday form of indemnity where an insurer promises to pay for covered accidents or damages. They also appear as clauses in business, construction, and rental contracts.

Indemnity vs. Guarantee

  • Indemnity: A standalone, primary promise to pay a loss regardless of anyone else's fault or duty.
  • Guarantee: A secondary promise to fulfill a third party's debt or duty only if that third party fails to pay first (e.g., "If they don't pay, I will").

Can I recover legal fees?

You generally cannot recover your legal fees in the United States unless a specific contract, state or federal statute, or court rule allows it.

This standard practice is known as the American Rule, which means that both sides pay their own attorney fees no matter who wins the lawsuit. However, several major exceptions override this rule.

Common Exceptions to the Rule

  • Contractual Clauses: If your signed agreement contains a "fee-shifting" provision stating that the winning party can recover reasonable legal fees, the court can order the loser to pay. Many states also render one-sided contract clauses reciprocal.
  • Statutory Allowances: Specific laws explicitly allow the winning party to collect fees. Examples include civil rights violations, consumer protection disputes, and certain employment or housing discrimination claims.
  • Bad Faith or Frivolous Conduct: A judge may order a party to pay fees as a sanction if they acted in bad faith, abused the court process, or filed a completely groundless, frivolous lawsuit.
  • Discovery Sanctions: If an opposing party unreasonably denies requests or abuses the discovery process, the judge may order them to pay the resulting legal expenses immediately.

How Recovery Works

To get your fees reimbursed, you must first win your case (or a dispositive motion like a summary judgment) and then file a formal motion for attorney fees within a strict deadline set by court rules. Courts only award reasonable fees and will scrutinize hourly rates and total hours worked.

What is the difference between standard costs and indemnity costs in litigation?

The main difference between standard costs and indemnity costs in litigation is how the court assesses the amount the losing party must pay the winning party, with indemnity costs offering a much higher and more generous level of recovery.

Standard Costs

  • Default Rule: This is the standard or regular basis used by courts for most legal cost orders.
  • Reasonable and Proportionate: The court only allows costs that were reasonably incurred, are a reasonable amount, and are proportionate to the value and complexity of the case.
  • Burden of Proof: The winning party must prove that every requested cost is reasonable and proportionate.
  • Benefit of the Doubt: If the court has any doubts about whether a cost is fair or proportionate, it resolves that doubt in favor of the paying party (the loser).

Indemnity Costs

  • Punitive or Exceptional: The court awards indemnity costs as a penalty for bad behavior, unreasonable conduct, or circumstances "out of the norm" during litigation (such as rejecting a fair settlement offer).
  • No Proportionality Test: The requirement for costs to be "proportionate" is completely removed.
  • Reasonableness Only: Costs must still be reasonable in amount and incurred, but the hurdle to pass is lower.
  • Burden of Proof: The burden shifts to the paying party to prove that the claimed costs are unreasonable.
  • Benefit of the Doubt: If the court has any doubts, it resolves that doubt in favor of the receiving party (the winner), often allowing a recovery of 90% to 100% of actual expenses.

What are reasonable legal costs?

Reasonable legal costs are charges by a lawyer that are directly related to necessary work, proportional to the case's complexity, and aligned with standard market rates.

Key Factors Determining Reasonableness

  • Justification: The work must directly advance the case, covering necessary tasks like legal research, document drafting, and court appearances.
  • Proportionality: Costs must match the financial value and legal complexity of the dispute, avoiding excessive or inflated spending.
  • Market Rates: Hourly rates should reflect regional guidelines and the appropriate level of experience required for the file handler.

Components of Legal Costs

  • Professional Fees: Charges for the time your solicitor or barrister spends working on your case.
  • Disbursements: Third-party outlays such as court filing fees, expert witness reports, or medical records.

What does indemnity fee mean?

An indemnity fee (or indemnity cost/payment) is a charge or financial obligation where one party agrees to compensate another for specific potential losses, damages, or legal costs.

Key Contexts

  • Legal and Court Costs: An order for costs on an indemnity basis requires a losing party to pay the winning party's legal fees. These fees do not have to follow standard rules of proportionality, meaning the recipient often recovers a much higher percentage of their total expenses.
  • Contracts and Business: Commercial agreements often include indemnity clauses. These require one party to cover pound-for-pound losses or legal defense expenses if a specific breach, injury, or third-party claim occurs.
  • Insurance: It functions like a premium or deductible mechanism where the insurer covers losses or liabilities incurred by the policyholder.