Which AAA card is better, Plus or Premier?

Editorial team Published on

AAA Premier provides significantly higher towing limits, RV/motorcycle coverage, and home lockout/rental car perks, whereas AAA Plus focuses on standard 100-mile towing.

Key Differences

  • Towing Distance:
    • AAA Plus: Up to 100 miles per tow (up to 4 calls per year).
    • AAA Premier: One tow up to 200 miles per household per year, plus up to 100 miles for remaining tows (up to 5 calls total).
  • Specialty Vehicle Coverage:
    • AAA Plus: Does not cover motorcycles or RVs.
    • AAA Premier: Includes roadside assistance for RVs and motorcycles.
  • Rental Car with Tow:
    • AAA Plus: Not included.
    • AAA Premier: Includes a 1-day free rental car with an in-territory tow.
  • Home Lockout & Extra Services:
    • AAA Plus: Standard vehicle lockout service up to $100.
    • AAA Premier: Adds home locksmith/lockout reimbursement up to $100 and free CARFAX vehicle history reports.
  • Trip Interruption Protection:
    • AAA Plus: Typically reimburses up to $750–$1,000 for food, lodging, or a rental car if a road trip is delayed.
    • AAA Premier: Higher reimbursement tier of up to $1,500.

Cost

Prices vary by region and local AAA club, but AAA Plus generally costs around $90–$117 per year, while AAA Premier costs around $119–$144+ per year for a primary member. You can compare regional details and sign up directly through the AAA Membership Overview.

Should I get AAA Plus or Premier?

Choose AAA Plus if you want the best everyday value with 100-mile towing, but upgrade to AAA Premier if you take long road trips, drive an RV or motorcycle, or want a free rental car during a tow.

AAA Plus

  • Towing: Up to 100 miles of towing per call (4 calls per year).
  • Cost: Roughly $90 to $117 per year depending on your region.
  • Key Perks: Free emergency fuel delivery, up to $100 for locksmith services, and up to $1,000 for trip interruption.
  • Best For: Most drivers. It covers long enough towing distances to get you home or to a trusted mechanic if you break down outside your immediate city.

AAA Premier

  • Towing: One 200-mile tow per household per year, with remaining tows up to 100 miles.
  • Cost: Roughly $119 to $144 per year.
  • Key Perks: Includes motorcycle and RV coverage, a 1-day free rental car with an in-territory tow, home lockout service, up to $1,500 in trip interruption protection, and free passport photos.
  • Best For: Frequent long-distance road trippers, owners of recreational vehicles/motorcycles, or anyone who wants the safety net of a free rental car when a breakdown stalls their day.

How much is AAA Premier per year for seniors?

AAA does not offer a standard nationwide senior discount on its yearly membership program. However, seniors pay the standard national rate for a AAA Premier membership, which generally ranges from $115 to $170 per year, depending on your specific location and local regional club.

Because AAA is structured as a network of regional clubs, base pricing varies slightly across different states:

  • AAA Mountain West Group (CA, UT, NV, AZ, etc.): $124.99 per year.
  • AAA Auto Club Group (FL, GA, MI, IA, etc.): $144 per year.
  • AAA Carolinas: $119 per year.
  • AAA Colorado: $170 per year.

Ways Seniors Can Lower the Cost

While there isn't a dedicated senior tier, retirees and seniors can reduce these membership costs through general AAA promotions:

  • Enroll in Automatic Renewal: Most clubs give a $5 to $10 discount on your annual dues if you opt into automatic credit card renewal.
  • Waived Enrollment Fees: New members frequently get the standard $10 to $15 one-time setup fee waived during sign-up events.
  • Add a Spouse or Family Member: Adding another household member to a Premier plan costs a discounted rate of roughly $45 to $85 per year rather than full price.

Why Premier is Popular with Seniors

Many retirees choose the Premier tier because its higher limits offer extra security for long-distance travel and fixed budgets. Key features include:

  • 200-Mile Towing: One free tow of up to 200 miles per year (remaining tows cover up to 100 miles).
  • Home Lockout Service: Up to $100–$150 reimbursement if you get locked out of your house, not just your car.
  • Trip Interruption & Emergency Medical: Up to $1,500 in reimbursement if travel is disrupted, plus medical transportation coverage.
  • Free Rental Car: A free one-day car rental if your vehicle requires a tow.

To find the exact base price for your zip code, check the AAA Membership Cost Tool or contact your local regional office.

What is the best AAA card?

The best AAA credit card depends on your spending habits, with the AAA Daily Advantage Visa Signature Card best for groceries and everyday essentials, and the AAA Travel Advantage Visa Signature Card best for gas and travel.

Both cards feature a $0 annual fee and 0% foreign transaction fees, plus a $100 statement credit after you spend $1,000 in the first 90 days.

AAA Daily Advantage Visa Signature® Credit Card

  • Best for: High grocery spending.
  • Rewards Structure: Earns 5% cash back on groceries (up to $10,000 spent per calendar year, then 1%), 3% on gas, EV charging, wholesale clubs, streaming, pharmacy, and AAA purchases, and 1% on everything else.
  • Cap: The 5% and 3% categories share a combined $500 annual cash back cap.

AAA Travel Advantage Visa Signature® Credit Card

  • Best for: Commuters and travelers.
  • Rewards Structure: Earns 5% cash back on gas and EV charging (up to $350 in cash back per calendar year, then 1%), 3% on travel, dining, groceries, and AAA purchases, and 1% on other purchases.

App and User Experience

Feedback on Reddit is mixed; some users appreciate the mobile app, while others find the digital interface basic compared to major banks and prefer the desktop site.

Is there a senior discount for AAA membership?

No, AAA does not offer a standard nationwide senior discount on its yearly membership fees.

Membership Pricing and Local Variations

  • No national discount: The Official AAA Membership FAQ confirms that age-based price reductions do not exist for joining the program.
  • Regional promotions: Local regional AAA clubs sometimes offer special introductory rates, promotional codes, or partner deals. Check with your Local AAA Club to see if any local offers apply.

Senior Perks with Membership

While membership costs the same regardless of age, an active AAA membership provides access to various senior-friendly savings:

  • Travel & Hotels: Reduced rates on car rentals (like Hertz and Thrifty), hotels, and vacation packages.
  • Insurance: Potential auto insurance discounts, such as defensive driving course discounts or multi-vehicle policies.
  • Retail & Services: Special pricing on everyday goods, prescription savings, and technology offers.

AAA Premier Membership Review - Is It Worth It? (Pros & Cons Of AAA Premier Membership)

9 related questions found

How many free tows do I get with AAA Premier?

With a AAA Premier membership, you get up to 5 total roadside service calls per member per year, which includes up to 5 free tows.

Towing Distance Breakdown

  • Long-Distance Tow: Across your entire household, one of these tows is covered for up to 200 miles.
  • Standard Tows: The remaining tows are covered for up to 100 miles each.

What Counts as a Service Call

Each of the following counts as one of your 5 annual service calls:

  • Towing
  • Battery jump starts or testing
  • Flat tire changes
  • Emergency fuel delivery
  • Lockout service
  • Vehicle extrication (if stuck)

Note: Specific rules and waiting periods (like a 7-day wait for long-distance towing benefits on new upgrades) can vary slightly depending on your regional AAA club.

What is the downside of AAA?

Depending on the context, the downside of AAA can refer to the costs and limitations of an American Automobile Association membership or the severe health risks of a medical abdominal aortic aneurysm.

AAA Roadside Membership Downsides

  • Higher Cost: An annual AAA membership typically costs between $40 and $120+, which is often more expensive than adding roadside assistance directly through a standard auto insurance policy.
  • Short Towing Limits: The cheapest "Classic" membership tier usually only covers free towing for a very short distance, often just 3 to 5 miles.
  • Service Call Caps: Memberships limit you to a set number of service calls per year, typically four.

Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm (Medical AAA) Risks

  • Silent Danger: A medical AAA is an abnormal swelling in the body's main belly artery that usually grows with no symptoms at all.
  • High Fatality Rate: If the weakened artery wall ruptures, it causes massive internal bleeding that carries an 80% to 90% mortality rate.

How do I lower my AAA membership?

You can lower your AAA membership tier or cost by logging into your account via the AAA Online Account Portal to change your plan level, or by calling AAA Member Services directly.

Ways to Lower Your AAA Cost

  • Downgrade Your Plan: Switch from an expensive tier (like Premier or Plus) down to the basic Classic tier, which costs the least annually and still covers basic roadside assistance and towing.
  • Remove Optional Add-ons: Review your account for extra household associate drivers, RV coverage, or motorcycle endorsements that increase your yearly bill, and remove them.
  • Call for Retention Offers: Call customer service to ask if there are any promotional discounts, lower regional rates, or unadvertised retention deals available for your account.

How to Make the Change

  • Online: Sign in to your local AAA club website (e.g., AAA Northern California FAQ), go to your account dashboard, navigate to My AAA, select Membership, and choose Change Plan under the plan level section.
  • By Phone: Call your regional AAA club's membership department (such as the national/northeast line at 1-800-222-8252 or the western region at 1-800-922-8228) to have a representative process your downgrade immediately.

Opinions on Reddit are mixed regarding whether premium tiers are worth the price, with many users suggesting that downgrading to the Classic plan is the best way to save money if you rarely use long-distance towing.

Is AAA cheaper through Costco?

No, AAA memberships are not sold or discounted through Costco.

🛑 Membership Details

  • Independent Services: Costco and AAA are completely separate companies with separate memberships.
  • No Cross-Discounts: Costco does not sell AAA memberships, and AAA does not offer discounts on Costco memberships.
  • Costco Pricing: A standard Costco membership costs $60 annually, while AAA varies by region, typically ranging from $40 to $160 per year.

💡 Alternative Options

  • Roadside Help: Costco does not offer roadside assistance, so you must buy AAA directly from your regional AAA auto club.
  • Travel Perks: Both offer separate travel booking perks, but they operate through different partner networks.

Is AAA overcharging its customers?

AAA is generally not systematically overcharging customers on its base memberships or insurance, but pricing varies significantly by region, affiliate, and individual risk profiles, with some regional clubs facing legal scrutiny over past practices.

📊 Understanding AAA Pricing

  • Membership costs: Base fees are relatively flat, though regional auto clubs set their own prices.
  • Insurance rates: Opinions are mixed; AAA is nationally rated as relatively cheap, but individual quotes spike based on age, location, or driving history.
  • Hidden friction: Some customers report surprise rate increases or unauthorized auto-renewals.

⚠️ Legal and Consumer Complaints

  • Pandemic lawsuits: Affiliates like CSAA faced class-action lawsuits for allegedly maintaining pre-pandemic rates during 2020–2021 when driving plummeted.
  • Billing issues: Consumers occasionally report unverified or confusing charges tied to separate regional club or insurance accounts.
  • Loyalty pricing: Like many insurers, algorithms can drive up renewal rates for long-term policyholders if they appear price-inelastic.

💡 Tips to Avoid Overpaying

  • Call to negotiate: Ask retention agents to match lower tier pricing or apply unlisted loyalty discounts.
  • Audit statements: Check monthly drafts for bundled roadside or insurance add-ons you did not authorize.
  • Shop competitors: Compare at least three independent insurance quotes before accepting a steep renewal.