Which is better for me, Farmers or American Family insurance?

Editorial team Published on

American Family Insurance generally offers lower average rates and higher claims satisfaction, but Farmers Insurance provides wider national availability and more specialized discount options.

📊 Company Comparison

Feature🛡️ American Family🌾 Farmers
Average RatesGenerally cheaper across most driver profilesTypically higher average premiums
AvailabilityOperates in 19 statesOperates in 49 states and DC
Claims RatingHigh customer satisfaction for claims handlingFast payouts, lower complaint index (NAIC 0.71)
Discounts18 discount options (focus on defensive/safe driving)23 discount options (anti-theft, green vehicles, senior)

🛡️ American Family Insurance

  • Best For: Drivers looking for lower premiums and high claims satisfaction.
  • Pros:
    • Cheaper average annual rates.
    • High marks for claims processing.
  • Cons:
    • Limited availability (only about 19 states).
    • Fewer overall discounts available.

🌾 Farmers Insurance

  • Best For: Drivers outside AmFam's footprint or those wanting specialized discounts.
  • Pros:
    • Available in nearly every state.
    • Robust selection of niche discounts.
    • Strong financial stability.
  • Cons:
    • Higher average costs.
    • Mixed J.D. Power scores depending on the region.

What are the top 5 worst homeowners insurance companies?

Based on recent industry surveys like J.D. Power's property and satisfaction studies, the lowest-ranking homeowners insurance companies for customer satisfaction and claims include Universal Direct, Tower Hill Insurance, National General, Homesite, and Foremost.

Lowest-Ranking Home Insurers

  • Universal Direct: Ranks at the very bottom of major customer satisfaction and claims surveys due to slow response times and service issues.
  • Tower Hill Insurance: Frequently scores near the bottom for overall customer experience and policyholder satisfaction.
  • National General: Scores poorly on consumer satisfaction metrics regarding communication and payout handling.
  • Homesite: Routinely lands at the bottom of J.D. Power claims satisfaction rankings for property coverage.
  • Foremost: Receives below-average customer satisfaction scores for handling claims and policy value.

Does American family insurance have a good reputation?

American Family Insurance generally has a good reputation, backed by strong financial stability and high marks for claims handling, though it is only available in 19 states.

Financial Strength and Ratings

  • AM Best: Holds an A (Excellent) rating, meaning it has a strong ability to pay out customer claims.
  • J.D. Power: Receives above-average scores for customer and claims satisfaction in many regions.
  • NAIC Complaint Index: Scores lower than average for complaints, meaning it receives fewer consumer grievances than expected for a company of its size.
  • Better Business Bureau (BBB): Holds an A+ rating.

Pros and Cons

  • Strengths: Excellent bundling options, a wide variety of discounts (such as usage-based driving programs), and helpful local agents.
  • Weaknesses: Premiums can be higher than average depending on the driver profile or location, and coverage is limited to 19 states.

You can read more detailed evaluations on WalletHub's American Family Review or check expert comparisons on U.S. News.

Does farmers insurance have a good reputation for paying claims?

Farmers Insurance has a mixed reputation for paying claims, receiving average to slightly below-average marks from industry experts alongside polarized feedback from everyday customers.

Industry Ratings and Financial Strength

  • Financial Stability: Farmers holds an A rating from AM Best, which means the company has strong financial backing and the clear ability to pay out valid claims.
  • Industry Scores: In J.D. Power studies, Farmers scores around industry averages or slightly below depending on the specific line of coverage; for instance, it scored 878 out of 1,000 in general claims tracking reported by WalletHub, but scored lower in auto-specific satisfaction metrics evaluated by MarketWatch.
  • Complaints: The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) indexes show that Farmers generally receives a reasonable volume of complaints relative to its massive national size, though scores vary by state and specific policy type.

Customer Feedback

  • The Positives: Many policyholders praise the company for making the initial claims-filing process simple via mobile apps or online tools, and several highlight positive experiences working closely with responsive local agents.
  • The Negatives: Dissatisfied customers on platforms like Trustpilot report frustrations regarding delayed communication, unexpected claim denials, or lower-than-expected payout offers after property damage. Opinions on Facebook are mixed, with users noting that working through a dedicated local agent rather than remote corporate adjusters often makes a major difference in how smoothly a claim resolves.

What insurance is better than Farmers?

State Farm, GEICO, and Progressive are generally considered better than Farmers for most drivers because they offer lower average rates and higher customer satisfaction scores.

Top Competitors vs. Farmers

  • State Farm: Best for overall value, featuring lower average rates for auto and home insurance alongside high customer satisfaction.
  • GEICO: Best for budget-conscious drivers looking for lower monthly premiums and strong digital tools.
  • Progressive: Best for customizable or specialized coverage options with slightly cheaper average rates than Farmers.
  • Nationwide: Best for safe drivers wanting lower full-coverage and liability rates across a wide geographic footprint.

When Farmers Might Still Work For You

  • Deep Discounts: Farmers offers a wide array of stacking discounts that can occasionally rival competitors if you qualify for multiple.
  • Specialized Needs: Farmers provides robust, highly customizable add-ons and unique coverage choices for high-risk or distinct profiles.

NEW | American Family Insurance Review 2025 | Is AmFam Still a Top Choice for Home & Auto?

9 related questions found

What homeowners insurance to avoid?

Avoid policies and coverage traps that leave you unprotected or financially exposed when buying homeowners insurance.

Policies and Plan Types to Avoid

  • Actual Cash Value (ACV) Policies: Avoid policies that pay out based on ACV instead of replacement cost. ACV subtracts depreciation for age and wear, meaning you will receive far less than what it actually costs to rebuild your home or replace items today.
  • The Cheapest Policy Available: Do not automatically pick the lowest-cost premium. Rock-bottom prices usually hide high deductibles, low coverage caps, and severe structural exclusions.
  • Poorly Rated Insurers: Research financial stability and customer satisfaction. Companies with low A.M. Best ratings, excessive NAIC complaint ratios, or a reputation for slow claims processing (such as certain low-tier or high-complaint regional providers) can make post-disaster recovery painful.

Coverage Gaps and Exclusions to Watch For

  • Standard Flood and Earthquake Exclusions: Standard policies never cover rising natural floodwaters or ground movement. If you skip separate flood or earthquake endorsements, you carry 100% of the risk.
  • Sewer and Drain Backups: Water backup from overloaded municipal sewers or failing sump pumps is excluded by default. Always add an endorsement if your basement contains finished living space.
  • Unscheduled High-Value Valuables: Standard limits for jewelry, fine art, firearms, and collectibles are very low. Avoid leaving these items unlisted; purchase a scheduled personal property rider.

Common Mistakes During the Buying Process

  • Insuring for Market Value vs. Rebuilding Costs: Never base your policy limit on your mortgage balance or original purchase price. Insure your home for current local construction and labor replacement costs.
  • Neglecting a Home Inventory: Failing to document your belongings with photos or videos before a loss makes the claims process slow and difficult.
  • Failing to Disclose High-Risk Features: Forgetting to mention trampolines, aggressive dog breeds, or unpermitted renovations can lead an insurer to deny a claim or cancel your policy entirely.

Which is better for me, Farmers or American Family insurance?

American Family generally offers lower average rates and higher overall customer satisfaction ratings than Farmers Insurance, though Farmers provides broader national availability and more extensive policy options.

Cost and Pricing

  • American Family: Tends to be more affordable, especially for teen drivers and good drivers looking for minimum or full coverage.
  • Farmers Insurance: Frequently features higher average premiums, though costs vary significantly based on your driving record, age, and location.

Coverage and Availability

  • American Family: Operates as a super-regional insurer available in a more limited number of states (roughly 19 states), but offers robust bundling and unique perks like generational discounts.
  • Farmers Insurance: Features a larger national footprint with wider availability and a vast selection of specialized policy types and add-ons.

Customer Satisfaction and Claims

  • American Family: Scores higher on general editorial reviews and customer satisfaction indices like WalletHub, though complaints can vary by region.
  • Farmers Insurance: Scores competitively on specific claim satisfaction metrics (around 4.4/5 from J.D. Power data), but generally trails in overall consumer rating aggregates.

Is American family insurance overpriced?

American Family Insurance is generally priced in the middle of the pack compared to other major national carriers, though its average rates tend to run slightly higher than the national average depending on your location, age, and driving profile.

📊 Cost vs. National Averages

  • Minimum coverage: Averaging around $68 to $115 per month, which can trend higher than typical national baselines.
  • Full coverage: Averaging roughly $209 to $283 per month ($2,300–$2,800 annually), landing close to or slightly above industry medians.
  • High-risk pricing: Rates spike more noticeably for drivers with speeding tickets, accidents, or poor credit histories.

✅ Why It Can Feel Affordable

  • Deep discount roster: Offers over 20 ways to save, including multi-policy bundling and safe-driver telematics.
  • Strong claims satisfaction: High marks for claims handling help offset slightly higher baseline premiums.
  • Competitive for specific groups: Often prices lower than competitors for teen drivers or specific clean-record profiles in certain regions.

Does American Family pay claims well?

Yes, American Family Insurance pays claims well and earns above-average marks for its claims-handling performance.

Financial Strength and Payout Scores

  • AM Best Rating: American Family holds an A (Excellent) financial strength rating, which shows the company has the money required to pay out large volumes of claims.
  • J.D. Power Score: The company scores 882 out of 1,000 in customer satisfaction for claims, which ranks above the industry average.
  • Complaint Index: The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) shows American Family receives fewer consumer complaints than expected for an insurance company of its size.

The Claims Process

  • Timeline: Standard payouts take about 30 days, though the exact speed depends on how fast you submit details and respond to requests.
  • Filing Rules: There is no strict time limit to file a claim, but waiting too long can hurt the investigation and lead to a denial.
  • Common Criticisms: Some policyholders report underpaid property damage estimates or slow communication during complicated claims, which is common across most major insurance carriers.

You can read full reviews and check policy details directly on the WalletHub American Family Profile.

Who is Farmers Insurance's biggest competitor?

State Farm is Farmers Insurance's biggest competitor based on overall market share and industry standing in the U.S. property and casualty market.

Major Competitors

  • State Farm: Holds the largest market share in the country and directly competes with Farmers in home, auto, and personal lines.
  • Allstate: Operates a very similar captive-agent business model and targets the same traditional personal insurance customer base.
  • Progressive: Competes aggressively on auto insurance pricing, digital tools, and telematic discounts.
  • Liberty Mutual: Matches Farmers closely in overall size and multi-line property and casualty offerings.